Tuesday Oct 19 SIT ANYWHERE TODAY Topic 10

  • Slides: 95
Download presentation
Tuesday Oct 19 SIT ANYWHERE TODAY: Topic #10 The Global Energy Balance & 2

Tuesday Oct 19 SIT ANYWHERE TODAY: Topic #10 The Global Energy Balance & 2 Sustainability Segments! ANNOUNCEMENTS • RQ-5 REMINDER: Cutoff is this THURSDAY Oct 21 st, 30 -minutes before class begins. • ASSIGNMENT I-3 is due IN CLASS a week from TODAY (Oct 26 th). The directions are posted in D 2 L. Please bring your WORKSHEET to class ALREADY STAPLED! (the Written Part of the assignment should be deposited in the Dropbox) • REMEMBER TO CHECK THE WEEKLY D 2 L CHECKLIST for what to do each week. NOTE: We’ll be reading more in the Dire Predictions text in upcoming weeks. • The EXAMS are being graded this week. You should have them back early next week.

CLICKER UPDATE: - If get >50% of answers correct, get credit for being here

CLICKER UPDATE: - If get >50% of answers correct, get credit for being here today

GOAL: Enhanced Understanding Of Global Change Science, How It Operates, & What It Means

GOAL: Enhanced Understanding Of Global Change Science, How It Operates, & What It Means To Me Personally ce cien te S ild Bu Clim a ndin g rsta Und e Physical Science foundation (matter& energy, electromagnetism, thermodynamics, laws of motion) The Science of Global Change 1 - 7 s # iple Global Climate Change processes rinc How science is done OBSERVATIONS al P On b sci eing en tist a Past & Present enti “H as ands sig nm on” en ts MODELS “ m Thi at nk er in ia g I l a de ! de i s c de se eply m ” le es ab b i ss ns o te ou P tio rp t u l so ro cou y v gr rs v a r S es e e GC nsum r se Co othe nts s Ess W we hat kn can & w ow is ha un stil t ce l rta in Future projections in as g o se n m m y es a te tta r in pr ed og k re no ss wl e s ed ge Climate Science Literacy & me ign ass l na s o s r Pe renes a aw lity i b a ain nts t s Su egme S How it links to my life

GLOBAL CHANGE in the News! http: //green. blogs. nytimes. com/2010/10/18/lake-mead-hits-record-low-level/? hp

GLOBAL CHANGE in the News! http: //green. blogs. nytimes. com/2010/10/18/lake-mead-hits-record-low-level/? hp

GLOBAL CHANGE in the News! http: //www. noaanews. noaa. gov/stories 2010/20101015_globalstats. html

GLOBAL CHANGE in the News! http: //www. noaanews. noaa. gov/stories 2010/20101015_globalstats. html

Topic # 10 THE EARTH’S GLOBAL ENERGY BALANCE Applying the laws, etc. to understand

Topic # 10 THE EARTH’S GLOBAL ENERGY BALANCE Applying the laws, etc. to understand how processes all work together to create global weather & climate!! BOOKMARK pp 49 & 122 in Class Notes now for lecture today

Today’s Quote: A Different Sort of “ENERGY BALANCE”: Look at life as an energy

Today’s Quote: A Different Sort of “ENERGY BALANCE”: Look at life as an energy economy game. Each day, ask yourself, Are my energy expenditures (actions, reactions, thoughts, and feelings) productive or nonproductive? During the course of my day, have I accumulated more stress or more peace? ~ Doc Childre and Howard Martin

Review: Absorption curve for the “Whole Atmosphere” OVERALL BALANCE: Incoming = Outgoing LW thru

Review: Absorption curve for the “Whole Atmosphere” OVERALL BALANCE: Incoming = Outgoing LW thru UV / Vis atmospheric window Incoming SW UV Visible NIR thru IR atmospheric window Far IR Review

Typical Energy Balance Diagram mesoscale. agron. iastate. edu/agron 206/animations/10_Atmo. Ebal. html From SGC-I Chapter

Typical Energy Balance Diagram mesoscale. agron. iastate. edu/agron 206/animations/10_Atmo. Ebal. html From SGC-I Chapter 3, p 50, Fig 3 -19 Similar to p 49 in Class Notes

Energy Balance Equation: Rnet = (Q + q) - a - Lu + Ld

Energy Balance Equation: Rnet = (Q + q) - a - Lu + Ld = H + LE + G (one of several ways this equation can be written)

Let’s try to find an easy way to understand remember all the components of

Let’s try to find an easy way to understand remember all the components of the Earth’s Energy Balance We’ll use “cartoon symbols”. . .

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent the Earth’s surface: Go to p 122

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent the Earth’s surface: Go to p 122

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent the atmosphere – composed of both invisible gases, aerosols, dust

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent the atmosphere – composed of both invisible gases, aerosols, dust and other particulate matter: p 122

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent CLOUDS p 122

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent CLOUDS p 122

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent SOLAR (shortwave) radiation coming in DIRECTLY. (aka Direct shortwave radiation)

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent SOLAR (shortwave) radiation coming in DIRECTLY. (aka Direct shortwave radiation) p 122

Direct SW radiation easily casts welldefined shadows when blocked Take notes

Direct SW radiation easily casts welldefined shadows when blocked Take notes

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent SOLAR (shortwave) radiation coming in as DIFFUSE shortwave radiation, i.

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent SOLAR (shortwave) radiation coming in as DIFFUSE shortwave radiation, i. e. scattered by gases, clouds, and particles in the atmosphere. p 122

Scattered, but still transmitted! Diffuse SW radiation is less likely to cast a well-defined

Scattered, but still transmitted! Diffuse SW radiation is less likely to cast a well-defined shadow! Take notes

Different sized dust particles, water droplets, aerosols, (even gas molecules themselves) Scattering of visible

Different sized dust particles, water droplets, aerosols, (even gas molecules themselves) Scattering of visible light review

An “aerosol-laden” atmosphere scatters the longer (red) wavelengths more readily “Clear” atmosphere composed primarily

An “aerosol-laden” atmosphere scatters the longer (red) wavelengths more readily “Clear” atmosphere composed primarily of fine particles, water droplets, gas molecules “Dirty” (aerosol-laden) atmosphere composed of fine particles, gases, & H 2 O -- PLUS larger dust particles, aerosols, pollution, etc.

ALSO: The angle at which direct SW radiation is intercepted by a surface makes

ALSO: The angle at which direct SW radiation is intercepted by a surface makes a difference!! Radiation is concentrated over a small area & hence is more intense when it comes in perpendicular to the surface Radiation is spread out over a larger area & hence is less intense per unit area when it comes in at an angle. From Figure on p 37 in SGC-I, Ch 3

Scenario 1: NOON at Point A Scenario 2: Late afternoon at Point A A

Scenario 1: NOON at Point A Scenario 2: Late afternoon at Point A A Q 1: which scenario will deliver MORE INTENSE radiation to Point A? 1 = Scenario 1 2 = Scenario 2

Q 2 = WHY is the intensity of the SW radiation at Point A

Q 2 = WHY is the intensity of the SW radiation at Point A not as strong in the late afternoon as it is at noon? 1 = because as the Sun goes down close to sunset time, it gives off less radiation 2 = because the SW radiation is coming in at an angle in the late afternoon, and is not directly overhead (perpendicular) like it is at noon. 3 = because the SW radiation is being transmitted through a thicker atmosphere & hence scattered more BOTH #2 & #3 are applicable!

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent SOLAR (shortwave) radiation that is REFLECTED (or scattered) BACK TO

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent SOLAR (shortwave) radiation that is REFLECTED (or scattered) BACK TO SPACE by: atmosphere, clouds, Earth’s surface, etc. p 122

New term: ALBEDO = reflectivity of a surface “symbol” = a Represented as: a

New term: ALBEDO = reflectivity of a surface “symbol” = a Represented as: a decimal from 0 to 1. 0 or % from 0 – 100 % (perfect reflectivity) Hence, amount ABSORBED = (1 – albedo) Flip back to p 49

YIKES! If a surface’s albedo is HIGH, absorption by the surface is LOW COOLER

YIKES! If a surface’s albedo is HIGH, absorption by the surface is LOW COOLER surface If a surface’s albedo is LOW absorption by the surface is HIGH => HOTTER surface!

Low albedo High albedo CLOUDS: 0. 44 (high, thin clouds) - 0. 90 (low,

Low albedo High albedo CLOUDS: 0. 44 (high, thin clouds) - 0. 90 (low, thick clouds) AVERAGE PLANET EARTH = ~ 0. 30 p 49

Q 3: What will happen to incoming SW over the Amazon Rain Forest if

Q 3: What will happen to incoming SW over the Amazon Rain Forest if parts of it are deforested? 1 = more SW will be absorbed 2 = less SW will be absorbed Before After

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent TERRESTRIAL (longwave IR) radiation emitted upward by the Earth’s surface

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent TERRESTRIAL (longwave IR) radiation emitted upward by the Earth’s surface or the atmosphere Return to p 122

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent TERRESTRIAL (longwave IR) re-radiation emitted downward by the Earth’s ATMOSPHERE

“CARTOON” SYMBOLS: To represent TERRESTRIAL (longwave IR) re-radiation emitted downward by the Earth’s ATMOSPHERE p 122

PUTTING IT TOGETHER: Can you place + and – signs where they ought to

PUTTING IT TOGETHER: Can you place + and – signs where they ought to go in the equation? RNET = + RNET= (Q + q) - + a - Lu + Ld p 123

Now we’ll look at the energy pathways in a bit more detail by combining

Now we’ll look at the energy pathways in a bit more detail by combining the cartoon symbols in various ways. . . See top p 49

First, what if. . . The Earth didn’t have an atmosphere, and therefore didn’t

First, what if. . . The Earth didn’t have an atmosphere, and therefore didn’t have a greenhouse effect? ? What would the energy pathways in the Earth-Sun system look like?

Which terms are not involved? No scattering by atmosphere No re-radiation of infrared by

Which terms are not involved? No scattering by atmosphere No re-radiation of infrared by GHG’s

To describe the real Earth. Atmosphere system, more detail is needed in our simple

To describe the real Earth. Atmosphere system, more detail is needed in our simple representation. . . We’ll use our symbols to build an energy balance “model” p 123

SW BEAMED DIRECTLY TO EARTH’S SURFACE WHERE IT IS ABSORBED: Incoming SW p 123

SW BEAMED DIRECTLY TO EARTH’S SURFACE WHERE IT IS ABSORBED: Incoming SW p 123

SW REFLECTED BACK TO SPACE: By clouds By Earth’s surface This is determined by

SW REFLECTED BACK TO SPACE: By clouds By Earth’s surface This is determined by the ALBEDO of the clouds or surface p 123

SW SCATTERED BACK TO SPACE BY ATMOSPHERE: p 123

SW SCATTERED BACK TO SPACE BY ATMOSPHERE: p 123

SW SCATTERED DOWN TO EARTH’s SURFACE where it is absorbed p 123

SW SCATTERED DOWN TO EARTH’s SURFACE where it is absorbed p 123

SW ABSORBED IN ATMOSPHERE BY GASES, DUST, etc. (including Ozone absorbing shortwave UV) Incoming

SW ABSORBED IN ATMOSPHERE BY GASES, DUST, etc. (including Ozone absorbing shortwave UV) Incoming UV SW absorbed by O 3, O 2 Incoming Visible SW absorbed by dust, O 3, O 2 p 123

SW ABSORBED In ATMOSPHERE BY CLOUDS & H 2 O vapor: (NOTE: clouds are

SW ABSORBED In ATMOSPHERE BY CLOUDS & H 2 O vapor: (NOTE: clouds are made up of tiny droplets of water surrounded by lots of water vapor) Incoming Visible & Near IR SW absorbed by water vapor & clouds Absorption curve for water vapor p 124

LW (IR) EMITTED FROM EARTH’S SURFACE ESCAPING TO Outgoing LW SPACE THROUGH THE “OUTGOING

LW (IR) EMITTED FROM EARTH’S SURFACE ESCAPING TO Outgoing LW SPACE THROUGH THE “OUTGOING IR ATMOSPHERIC WINDOW” p 124

IR EMITTED FROM EARTH’S SURFACE BUT ABSORBED IN THE ATMOSPHERE BY GREENHOUSE GASES (H

IR EMITTED FROM EARTH’S SURFACE BUT ABSORBED IN THE ATMOSPHERE BY GREENHOUSE GASES (H 2 O, CO 2, CH 4, ETC. ) p 124

IR EMITTED FROM ATMOSPHERE ESCAPING TO SPACE p 124

IR EMITTED FROM ATMOSPHERE ESCAPING TO SPACE p 124

IR EMITTED FROM ATMOSPHERE AND RADIATED BACK TO SURFACE WHERE IT IS ABSORBED p

IR EMITTED FROM ATMOSPHERE AND RADIATED BACK TO SURFACE WHERE IT IS ABSORBED p 124

All together now: Can you sketch all the pathways in yourself? p 124

All together now: Can you sketch all the pathways in yourself? p 124

Compare with simpler model of energy balance with NO atmosphere: p 125

Compare with simpler model of energy balance with NO atmosphere: p 125

Which terms are not involved? No scattering by atmosphere No re-radiation of infrared by

Which terms are not involved? No scattering by atmosphere No re-radiation of infrared by GHG’s NOTE: Technically, the SUN does give off incoming longwave infrared radiation (in addition to shortwave UV, visible, etc. ) – but if we view the incoming LW symbol above as TERRESTRIAL radiation that has been absorbed and RE-RADIATED BACK TO EARTH by the GHG’s in the atmosphere, this simplification is correct. p 125

Earth’s average albedo: 23 + 8 = 31 12 + 48 + 9 =

Earth’s average albedo: 23 + 8 = 31 12 + 48 + 9 = 69 Outgoing IR START HERE 23 100 8 12 48 9 3 20 18 GHE H 20 = 15 O 3 +others = 3 102 8 3 H 48 48 - 114 + 95 = 29 =0 114 95 G + H + LE 0 + 7 + 22 = 29 = Rnet 7 22 Back to p 49

Two Energy Balance Animations showing energy flow pathways & “units” of energy that eventually

Two Energy Balance Animations showing energy flow pathways & “units” of energy that eventually balance out: GLOBAL ENERGY BALANCE & PATHWAYS: http: //earthguide. ucsd. edu/earthguide/diagrams/energybalance/index. html SHORTWAVE & LONGWAVE ENERGY FLOW & BUDGET: http: //mesoscale. agron. iastate. edu/agron 206/animations/10_Atmo. Ebal. html

ZOMBIE BREAK !

ZOMBIE BREAK !

A new “SUSTAINABILITY SEGMENT” FILM HBO Documentary ( 2006 )

A new “SUSTAINABILITY SEGMENT” FILM HBO Documentary ( 2006 )

BACK TO THE BALANCE!

BACK TO THE BALANCE!

NET RADIATION = In – Out = Whatever is left over If some energy

NET RADIATION = In – Out = Whatever is left over If some energy is “left over, ” it can be used to DRIVE WEATHER & CLIMATE through HEAT TRANSFER processes or it can STORED by the Earth (in the ground or ocean). p 50 top

FINAL PART OF TOPIC #10: The RIGHT side of the ENERGY BALANCE EQUATION. .

FINAL PART OF TOPIC #10: The RIGHT side of the ENERGY BALANCE EQUATION. . .

Left side of equation Right side of equation R net = “net” left over

Left side of equation Right side of equation R net = “net” left over energy can be used to DRIVE WEATHER & CLIMATE through HEAT TRANSFER processes or it can STORED by the Earth (in the ground or ocean). p 50 top

Review of: THERMODYNAMICS & HEAT TRANSFER Conduction = passage of thermal energy through a

Review of: THERMODYNAMICS & HEAT TRANSFER Conduction = passage of thermal energy through a body without large‑scale movement of matter within the body. Most effective in SOLIDS. Convection = passage of thermal energy through a fluid (liquid or gas) by means of large‑scale movements of material within the fluid, as in a convection cell. Most effective in GASES & LIQUIDS. Radiation = the transfer of thermal energy by electromagnetic radiation. The only one of the three mechanisms of heat transfer that does not require atoms or molecules to facilitate the transfer process, i. e. , does not even need MATTER as a medium to transfer energy! p 51

CONVECTION Mass of warm air or liquid heats, expands, rises CONDUCTION Jiggling molecule jiggling

CONVECTION Mass of warm air or liquid heats, expands, rises CONDUCTION Jiggling molecule jiggling molecule transfer of heat (kinetic energy at molecular scale) RADIATION Photon /wave transport: even through a void! of p 61 review

HEAT TRANSFER & STORAGE DURING PHASE CHANGES: LE & H LE = LATENT (hidden)

HEAT TRANSFER & STORAGE DURING PHASE CHANGES: LE & H LE = LATENT (hidden) ENERGY (LE stored) (LE released, hence it can be sensed as H) H = SENSED (via thermometer) ENERGY Review p 51

Link to the Left Side of Equation: Radiation = the transfer of heat by

Link to the Left Side of Equation: Radiation = the transfer of heat by electromagnetic radiation. It doesn’t need MATTER to transfer energy! (sun earth, earth atmosphere, atmosphere earth, earth space)

Link to the Right Side of Equation: Conduction & convection plus energy stored &

Link to the Right Side of Equation: Conduction & convection plus energy stored & released during phase changes (latent energy => sensible heat, etc. ) p 51

G Back to p 50

G Back to p 50

Encore: Energy Balance Animation showing energy flow pathways & “units” of energy that eventually

Encore: Energy Balance Animation showing energy flow pathways & “units” of energy that eventually balance out: SHORTWAVE & LONGWAVE ENERGY FLOW & BUDGET: http: //mesoscale. agron. iastate. edu/agron 206/animations/10_Atmo. Ebal. html

AMAZON RAIN FOREST SONORAN DESERT

AMAZON RAIN FOREST SONORAN DESERT

Will the % of net radiation in LE form be HIGHER or LOWER in

Will the % of net radiation in LE form be HIGHER or LOWER in the Desert, when compared to a Rainforest? FOREST

What if humans put in canals (CAP), lakes, & artificial water bodies in a

What if humans put in canals (CAP), lakes, & artificial water bodies in a desert? Central Arizona Project (CAP) Canal

What if humans put in How would the % of LE in canals (CAP),

What if humans put in How would the % of LE in canals (CAP), lakes, & the Desert change? artificial water bodies in a desert?

How does DEFORESTATION change the local energy balance? ? ? Less More cooler temperatures?

How does DEFORESTATION change the local energy balance? ? ? Less More cooler temperatures? More warmer temperatures?

G-3 ASSIGNMENT (5 pts) Applying the Energy Balance Terms Your task is to decide

G-3 ASSIGNMENT (5 pts) Applying the Energy Balance Terms Your task is to decide which component or components working together are most directly related to or responsible for the observed phenomenon. # 1 – #12 : Left side of equation # 13 - #15: Right side of equation p 53

1. blue skies 2. Sunglasses while skiing 3. Bright even though cloudy

1. blue skies 2. Sunglasses while skiing 3. Bright even though cloudy

4. More intense solar radiation (tan /skin damage, etc. ) at noon vs. dawn

4. More intense solar radiation (tan /skin damage, etc. ) at noon vs. dawn or dusk Sun directly overhead NOON DAWN or DUSK Sun just above horizon Solar rays perpendicular to body 5. The Greenhouse Effect

To illustrate the GREENHOUSE EFFECT: SUN EARTH Greenhouse effect SUN EARTH C the BAis

To illustrate the GREENHOUSE EFFECT: SUN EARTH Greenhouse effect SUN EARTH C the BAis better than the B others. . . But only circled part represents the GH Effect!!. . .

6. Red sunsets 7. Infrared cameras / “night vision” 8. “Tennis whites” tradition

6. Red sunsets 7. Infrared cameras / “night vision” 8. “Tennis whites” tradition

9. Shadow on sunny day 10. Rainbow 11. Black streaks 12. Parking on blacktop

9. Shadow on sunny day 10. Rainbow 11. Black streaks 12. Parking on blacktop

13. Hot air balloon 14. Pigs cooling off in the mud 15. Evaporative coolers

13. Hot air balloon 14. Pigs cooling off in the mud 15. Evaporative coolers work best in the desert

TIME TO WRAP UP FOR TODAY! G-3 ASSIGNMENT (5 pts) (cont. ) Applying the

TIME TO WRAP UP FOR TODAY! G-3 ASSIGNMENT (5 pts) (cont. ) Applying the Energy Balance Terms Your task is to decide which component or components working together are most directly related to or responsible for the observed phenomenon. Don’t forget to SIGN IN with the #’s you wrote up! p 53

THE ANSWERS

THE ANSWERS

The LEFT side of the equation: 1. gases of atmosphere scatter shorter blue wavelengths

The LEFT side of the equation: 1. gases of atmosphere scatter shorter blue wavelengths 3. 2. 4. Noon: more 5. + dusk: more together = the Greenhouse Effect

6. (dust, thicker atmosphere longer red/orange wavelengths) 7. scatters radiates day & night; camera

6. (dust, thicker atmosphere longer red/orange wavelengths) 7. scatters radiates day & night; camera senses IR 8. 9. leads to distinct shadows, while diffuse SW radiation does not

10. All visible wavelengths scattered & transmitted in a colored spectrum by raindrops 11.

10. All visible wavelengths scattered & transmitted in a colored spectrum by raindrops 11. Attempt to increase absorption & reduce into eyes; reduces glare 12. More is absorbed, leads to more can then warm up car which

The RIGHT Side of the Equation: 13. H Hot air (less dense than surrounding

The RIGHT Side of the Equation: 13. H Hot air (less dense than surrounding cool air) rises in a convection current & lifts balloon LE 14. Wet mud evaporates from pig & cools him: Heat from pig’s body is conducted into soil: G 15. June is dryer, hence air can hold more water vapor, more evaporation occurs, hence more energy goes into instead of LE H

BE SURE TO REVIEW THE CLASS FOLLOW-UP IF YOU WANT TO GO OVER THESE

BE SURE TO REVIEW THE CLASS FOLLOW-UP IF YOU WANT TO GO OVER THESE ANSWERS AGAIN. . . See you on Thursday Don’t forget RQ-5!

SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE ENERGY BALANCE IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE GLOBE: http: //www.

SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE ENERGY BALANCE IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE GLOBE: http: //www. earthweek. com/

GLOBAL CHANGE in the News! Warmer-than-average conditions dominated the world’s land areas. The most

GLOBAL CHANGE in the News! Warmer-than-average conditions dominated the world’s land areas. The most prominent warmth was in western Alaska, most of the contiguous United States, eastern Canada, Greenland, the Middle East, eastern and central Europe, western and far eastern Russia and northeastern Asia. Cooler-than-average regions included much of Australia, western Canada, parts of the northern United States, parts of western and central Europe, and central Russia. This year also marked the 14 th consecutive September with belowaverage Arctic sea ice extent. Antarctic sea ice reached its annual maximum in September 2010 was the third largest sea ice extent on record (2. 3 percent above average), behind 2006 (largest) and 2007 (second largest).

http: //psc. apl. washington. edu/Arctic. Seaice. Volume/Ice. Volume. php http: //nsidc. org/data/seaice_index/index. html

http: //psc. apl. washington. edu/Arctic. Seaice. Volume/Ice. Volume. php http: //nsidc. org/data/seaice_index/index. html

This summer marks the fourth consecutive year--and fourth time in recorded history--that the fabled

This summer marks the fourth consecutive year--and fourth time in recorded history--that the fabled passage has opened for navigation. Over the past four days, warm temperatures and southerly winds over Siberia have also led to intermittent opening of the Northeast Passage, the shipping route along the north coast of Russia through the Arctic Ocean. It is now possible to completely circumnavigate the Arctic Ocean in ice-free waters, and this will probably be the case for at least a month. This year marks the third consecutive year--and the third time in recorded history--that both the Northwest Passage and Northeast Passage have melted free, according to the National Snow and Ice Data Center. The Northeast Passage opened for the first time in recorded history in 2005, and the Northwest Passage in 2007. It now appears that the opening of one or both of these northern passages is the new norm, and business interests are taking note--commercial shipping in the Arctic is on the increase, and there is increasing interest in oil drilling. The great polar explorers of past centuries would be astounded at how the Arctic has changed in the 21 st century. http: //www. wunderground. com/blog/Jeff. Masters/comment. html? entrynum=1589 Antarctic vs Arctic. . . http: //nsidc. org/seaice/characteristics/difference. html

http: //climateprogress. org/2010/08/28/arctic-sea-ice-volumenorthwest-passage-david-barber-antarctic-sea-ice/

http: //climateprogress. org/2010/08/28/arctic-sea-ice-volumenorthwest-passage-david-barber-antarctic-sea-ice/