Principle E 3SS Standards 464 A 461 F

  • Slides: 92
Download presentation
Principle E 3/SS Standards 464 A 461 F Performance Specs and Tailoring Requirements 1

Principle E 3/SS Standards 464 A 461 F Performance Specs and Tailoring Requirements 1

MIL-STD-461 F · Applies To Equipment and Subsystems · Conducted and Radiated Emissions, Susceptibility

MIL-STD-461 F · Applies To Equipment and Subsystems · Conducted and Radiated Emissions, Susceptibility (CE, CS, RE, RS) Requirements, and Test Procedures 461 F · Requirements Tailored to Equipment Characteristics and Installation · Appendix and DIDs 2

Changes from 461 E • Interchangeable Modular Equipment: Paragraph 4. 2. 7 deals with

Changes from 461 E • Interchangeable Modular Equipment: Paragraph 4. 2. 7 deals with interchangeable modular equipment, and is new in MIL-STD-461 F. • Prohibition of Use of Shielded Power Leads: Section 4. 3. 8. 6 ("Construction and arrangement of EUT cables") is more definitive than -461 E, stating shielded power conductors may not be used unless the platform shields the power bus from point-of-origin to the load. • Computer Controlled Instrumentation: 4. 3. 10. 2 has a title change from "Computer-controlled receivers" in 461 E to "Computer-controlled instrumentation“, recognizing that more than emissions tests are automated. • Emission Scanning Changes: Table II, "Bandwidth and measurement time, " which underwent a minor revision from -461 D to -461 E, is modified to provide an alternative faster sweep speed with multiple sweeps in "max hold" mode. • Susceptibility Scanning Changes: Above 1 GHz, the Table III step size has been increased, resulting in a much faster RS 103 test in that frequency range. CE 101: Now applicable for equipment used on surface ships. • 3

Changes from 461 E • CS 106, A New Requirement: 461 F includes a

Changes from 461 E • CS 106, A New Requirement: 461 F includes a Navy ships -only "CS 106" requirement that is superficially similar to the obsolete MIL-STD-461 A/B/C CS 06. • CS 109: Now only applicable for surface ship equipments that have an operating frequency of 100 k. Hz or less and have the sensitivity to read a signal at or below 1 µV. • CS 114: For Navy ships and submarines, there is a low frequency add-on to this requirement that models common mode noise generated by new power systems. • CS 115: Only applicable for submarine and surface ship procurements when specified by the Procuring Activity. This change fits with the addition of CS 106. • CS 116: There were previously two CS 116 limits, there is now just one, the more stringent of the two, which peaks at 10 Amps. 4

Changes from 461 E • • RE 102 – A universal change is in

Changes from 461 E • • RE 102 – A universal change is in the use of the 41" rod antenna, used below 30 MHz; – Figure RE 102 -6 is revised to show the antenna lowered so that the center point of the 41" rod element is 120 cm above the test chamber floor. Further, this figure shows that the coaxial cable emanating from the rod antenna base is carried directly to the floor and grounded there, with a ferrite bead installed between the rod base and the floor ground point. The ferrite bead should have between 20 – 30 Ohms impedance at 20 MHz. . – If a rod antenna is used with a coax output connector shell that is isolated from the case, this isolation should be defeated by grounding it to the case. RE 103: The requirement is now met if the harmonics do not exceed the applicable RE 102 limit. • RS 101: RS 101 for submarine procurements now applies only to equipment and subsystems that have an operating frequency of 100 k. Hz or less and have the sensitivity to read a signal at or below 1 µV. • RS 103: In paragraph 5. 20. 3. 4. d. 1. c. It states: "Ensure that the E-field sensor is indicating the field from the fundamental frequency and not from the harmonics. " MILSTD-461 F imposes a requirement that the radiated signal be demonstrated to be higher in amplitude than its harmonics. 5

Electromagnetic Interference Emanations to and From Equipment RE and RS Radiation into and out

Electromagnetic Interference Emanations to and From Equipment RE and RS Radiation into and out of Seams and Apertures RE Radiation from Panel Components CS Power line conduction Interface cable radiation and entry (conduction) CE and RS/CS Power line radiation RE 6

Requirement Matrix Table V Requirement Applicability CE 102 CE 106 CS 101 CS 103

Requirement Matrix Table V Requirement Applicability CE 102 CE 106 CS 101 CS 103 CS 104 CS 105 CS 106 CS 109 CS 114 CS 115 CS 116 RE 101 RE 102 RE 103 RS 105 Surface Ships A A L A S S S A L A S A A A L Submarines A A L A S S S A L A S L A A L L Aircraft, Army, Including Flight Line A A L A S S S A A A L Aircraft, Navy L A S S S A A A L L L Aircraft, Air Force A L A S S S A A L A Space Systems, Including Launch Vehicles A L A S S S A A L A Ground, Army A L A S S S A A L L Ground, Navy A L A S S S A A L A A Ground, Air Force A L A S S S A A L S RS 101 CE 101 Equipment and Subsystems Installed In, On, or Launched From the Following Platforms or Installations A A L Legend: Applicable Limited as specified in the individual sections of this standard Procuring activity must specify in procurement documentation Requirement is not applicable. 8

MIL-STD-461 F General Test Configuration Access Panel Interconnecting Cable Bond Strap Power Source 5

MIL-STD-461 F General Test Configuration Access Panel Interconnecting Cable Bond Strap Power Source 5 cm Above Ground Plane EUT 10 cm 2 cm LISN Ground Plane 80 -90 cm 9

5. 4. CE 101, Conducted Emissions, Power Leads, 30 Hz to 10 k. Hz

5. 4. CE 101, Conducted Emissions, Power Leads, 30 Hz to 10 k. Hz • Applicable to leads that obtain power from sources that are not part of the EUT. There is no requirement on output leads from power sources. • Emission levels are determined by measuring the current present on each power lead. • For surface ships and submarines, the intent is to control the effects of conducted emissions peculiar to the shipboard power distribution system During the measurement system check, the signal generator may need to be supplemented with a power amplifier to obtain the necessary current 6 d. B below the applicable limit. • For Army aircraft, the concern is to ensure that the EUT does not corrupt the power quality on platform power buses • Navy aircraft applicable for installations using anti-submarine warfare (ASW) equipment. 10

Figure CE 101 -1 CE 101 Limit For Submarine Applications, DC. 11

Figure CE 101 -1 CE 101 Limit For Submarine Applications, DC. 11

Figure CE 101 -2 CE 101 Limit For Submarine Applications, 60 Hz 12

Figure CE 101 -2 CE 101 Limit For Submarine Applications, 60 Hz 12

Figure CE 101 -3 CE 101 Limit For Submarine Applications, 400 Hz 13

Figure CE 101 -3 CE 101 Limit For Submarine Applications, 400 Hz 13

Figure CE 101 - 4 CE 101 Limit For Navy ASW Aircraft And Army

Figure CE 101 - 4 CE 101 Limit For Navy ASW Aircraft And Army Aircraft (Including Flight Line) Applications 14

5. 5. CE 102, Conducted Emissions, Power Leads, 10 k. Hz to 10 MHz

5. 5. CE 102, Conducted Emissions, Power Leads, 10 k. Hz to 10 MHz • Lower frequency portion is to ensure EUT does not corrupt the power quality (allowable voltage distortion) on platform power buses • Voltage distortion is the Emission levels basis for power quality so are determined by measuring the voltage CE 102 limit is in terms of present at the output port on voltage. the LISN • Emission levels determined by measuring voltage present at the output port of the LISN Output port 15

 Figure CE 102 -1 CE 102 Limit (EUT Power Leads, AC and DC)

Figure CE 102 -1 CE 102 Limit (EUT Power Leads, AC and DC) For All Applications 16

5. 6. CE 106, Conducted Emissions, Antenna Terminal, 10 k. Hz to 40 GHz

5. 6. CE 106, Conducted Emissions, Antenna Terminal, 10 k. Hz to 40 GHz • • CE 106 is applicable to the antenna terminals of transmitters, receivers, and amplifiers Intent is to protect receivers on and off the platform from being degraded by antenna radiation from the EUT. Suppression to meet requirements can be severe resulting in significant design penalties. The limits may be tailored by establishing levels based on platform coupling studies Setup for Receivers and Transmitters in Stand-by Mode. Note: There are other test setups for low power and high average power transmitters. Attenuator Measurement Receiver Data Recording Device 17

5. 7. CS 101, Conducted Susceptibility, Power Lead, 30 k. Hz to 150 k.

5. 7. CS 101, Conducted Susceptibility, Power Lead, 30 k. Hz to 150 k. Hz • Applicable to equipment and subsystem AC, limited to current draws ≤ 100 amperes per phase, and DC input power leads, not including returns. • If the EUT is DC operated, requirement applicable over freq range 30 Hz to 150 k. Hz. • If the EUT is AC operated, requirement is applicable from the second harmonic of the EUT power freq and extending to 150 k. Hz • Ensures that performance is not degraded from ripple voltages on power source waveforms • Limits are based on MIL-STD-704 • The limit is approximately 6 d. B above typical power quality limits EUT Signal Injection – Three Phase Ungrounded EUT Signal Injection – DC or Single-Phase AC Signal Injection – Three Phase Wye 19

Figure CS 101 -1. CS 101 Voltage Limit For All Applications 20

Figure CS 101 -1. CS 101 Voltage Limit For All Applications 20

Figure CS 101 -2. CS 101 Power Limit For All Applications 21

Figure CS 101 -2. CS 101 Power Limit For All Applications 21

5. 8. CS 103, Conducted Susceptibility, Antenna Port, 15 k. Hz to 10 GHz

5. 8. CS 103, Conducted Susceptibility, Antenna Port, 15 k. Hz to 10 GHz • Intent is to control the response of antenna connected receiving subsystems to in-band signals resulting from potential intermodulation products of two signals outside of the intentional passband of the subsystem • Most applicable to fixed frequency, tunable, superheterodyne receivers. CS 103 General Test Setup The basic concept is to combine two out-of-band signals (one modulated and one CW) and apply to the antenna port of receiver while monitoring it for an undesired response

5. 9. CS 104, Conducted Susceptibility, Antenna Port, 30 Hz to 20 GHz •

5. 9. CS 104, Conducted Susceptibility, Antenna Port, 30 Hz to 20 GHz • Intent of CS 104 is to control response of antenna connected receiving subsystems to signals outside intentional passband of the subsystem. – Most applicable to fixed frequency, tunable, superheterodyne receivers. – Front-end rejection testing can be applied to a variety of receiving subsystems such as receivers, RF amplifiers, transceivers, and transponders. CS 104 General Test Setup No test procedures are provided - The basic concept with this test procedure is to apply out-of-band signals to the antenna port of the receiver while monitoring the receiver for degradation. 23

5. 10. CS 105, Conducted Susceptibility, Antenna Port, 30 Hz to 20 GHz •

5. 10. CS 105, Conducted Susceptibility, Antenna Port, 30 Hz to 20 GHz • Intent is to control the response of antenna connected receiving subsystems to modulation being transferred from an out-of-band signal to an in-band signal. • Results from a strong, out-of-band signal near the operating frequency of the receiver • Should be considered only for receivers, transceivers, amplifiers, and the like, which extract information from the amplitude modulation of a carrier. • Cross modulation testing should be applied only to receiving subsystems such as receivers, RF amplifiers, transceivers and transponders which extract information from the amplitude modulation of a carrier. Receiver CS 105 General Test Setup The basic concept of this test is to apply a modulated signal outof-band to the receiver and to determine whether the modulation is transferred to an unmodulated signal at the receiver's tuned frequency resulting in an undesired response. 24

5. 11. CS 106, Conducted Susceptibility, Transients, Power Leads • Applicable to power input

5. 11. CS 106, Conducted Susceptibility, Transients, Power Leads • Applicable to power input leads on surface ships and submarines that obtain power from the platform’s primary power source that are not part of the EUT. • Primary concern is to ensure that performance is not degraded from voltage transients from shipboard power systems Power Source EUT Connected to Shielded Room Ground 25

5. 11. CS 109, Conducted Susceptibility, Structure Current, 60 Hz to 100 GHz •

5. 11. CS 109, Conducted Susceptibility, Structure Current, 60 Hz to 100 GHz • Specialized test intended for very sensitive equipment (1 u. V or better) such as tuned receivers operating over the frequency range of the test. • Intent is to ensure that equipment does not respond to magnetic fields caused by currents flowing in platform structure A current is imposed across the surface of the EUT to verify its ability to withstand structure currents EUT 26

Figure CS 109 -1. CS 109 Limit For All Applications 27

Figure CS 109 -1. CS 109 Limit For All Applications 27

5. 12. CS 114, Conducted Susceptibility, Bulk Cable Injection, 10 k. Hz to 200

5. 12. CS 114, Conducted Susceptibility, Bulk Cable Injection, 10 k. Hz to 200 MHz • Applicable to all electrical cables interfacing with the EUT enclosures. • Concept is to simulate currents developed on platform cabling from electromagnetic fields generated by antenna transmissions both on and off the platform. • Aircraft carrier hangar deck EME test data from 9 aircraft carriers showed significant HF electric field Sig Gen Amp Levels are induced on all wires at connector interface simultaneously Monitor Probe Power Inputs CS 114 alternate test setup, three phase ungrounded power system. EUT 28

Table VI. CS 114 Limit Curves Limit Curve Numbers Shown in Figure CS-114 -1

Table VI. CS 114 Limit Curves Limit Curve Numbers Shown in Figure CS-114 -1 And Limits Platform Aircraft (External or Safety Critical) Aircraft (Internal) All Ships (Above Decks) and Submarines (External)* Ships (Non. Metallic) (Below Decks) ** Submarine (Internal) Ground Navy - - 77 d. Bu. A - - Army 5 3 2 2 2 1 3 3 Navy 5 3 2 2 2 1 2 3 Air Force 5 3 - - 2 3 Army 5 5 5 2 4 1 4 3 Navy 5 5 5 2 4 1 2 3 Air Force 5 3 - - 2 3 Army 5 5 5 2 2 2 4 3 Navy 5 5 5 2 2 3 Air Force 5 3 - - 2 3 Frequency Range 4 k. Hz – 1 MHz 10 k. Hz – 2 MHz – 30 MHz – 200 MHz Ships (Metallic) (Below Decks) Space * For equipment located external to the pressure hull of a submarine but within the superstructure, use SHIPS (METALLIC) (BELOW DECKS) ** For equipment located in the hanger deck of Aircraft Carriers. 29

Table VI. CS 114 Limit Curves CS 114 limits for Navy ships of all

Table VI. CS 114 Limit Curves CS 114 limits for Navy ships of all kinds (black) and extension of limit for power inputs (red dashed) 30

Figure CS 114 -1. CS 114 Calibratio Limit For All Applications

Figure CS 114 -1. CS 114 Calibratio Limit For All Applications

5. 13. CS 115, Conducted Susceptibility, Bulk Cable Injection, Impulse Excitation • Applicable to

5. 13. CS 115, Conducted Susceptibility, Bulk Cable Injection, Impulse Excitation • Applicable to all electrical cables interfacing with EUT enclosures. • Concern is to protect equipment from fast rise and fall time transients that may be present due to platform switching operations and external transient environments such as lightning and electromagnetic pulse. • Replaces "chattering relay" type requirements (RS 06 in MIL-STD -461 C) • The excitation waveform from the generator is a trapezoidal pulse. A pulse generator required by CS 115 is essentially the same as impulse generators used to calibrate measurement receivers except that the pulse width is much longer. A direct current power supply is used to charge the capacitance of an open-circuited 50 ohm coaxial line. The high voltage relay is then switched to the output coaxial line to produce the pulse. The pulse width is dependent upon the length of the charge line. The relay needs to have bounce-free contact operation. 32

Figure CS 115 -1. CS 115 Signal Characteristics For All Applications 33

Figure CS 115 -1. CS 115 Signal Characteristics For All Applications 33

5. 14. CS 116, Conducted Susceptibility, Damped Sinusoidal Transients, Cables and Power Leads, 10

5. 14. CS 116, Conducted Susceptibility, Damped Sinusoidal Transients, Cables and Power Leads, 10 k. Hz to 100 MHz • Applicable to electrical cables interfacing with each EUT enclosure and also on each power lead. • Concept is to simulate electrical current and voltage waveforms occurring in platforms from excitation of natural resonances. • Intent is to control waveform as a damped sine. • Wide frequency coverage accounts for a wide range of conditions. • Switching Transients within the platform can also result in similar waveforms. • Test Procedure • Common mode test on the cable bundle simulates the EM field coupling mechanisms • Power lead test addresses differential type signals present from switching in the power system • The signal can be applied to wires on individual connector pins or to individual circuits (twisted pairs, coaxial cables, etc. ) EUT 34

Figure CS 116 -1. Typical CS 116 Damped Sinusoidal Waveform 35

Figure CS 116 -1. Typical CS 116 Damped Sinusoidal Waveform 35

Figure CS 116 -2. CS 116 Limit For All Applications 36

Figure CS 116 -2. CS 116 Limit For All Applications 36

5. 15. RE 101, Radiated Emissions, Magnetic Field, 30 Hz to 100 k. Hz

5. 15. RE 101, Radiated Emissions, Magnetic Field, 30 Hz to 100 k. Hz • Applicable for radiated emissions from equipment and subsystem enclosures, including electrical cable interfaces. For Navy aircraft, this requirement is applicable only for aircraft with an ASW capability. • Specialized, intended to control magnetic fields for applications where equipment is present in the installation which is potentially sensitive to magnetic induction at lower frequencies. • A 13. 3 cm loop is specified for the test. • This standard limits measurements to electrical interface connectors. Connections EUT 13. 3 cm loop 37

Figure RE 101 -1. RE 101 Limit For All Army Applications 38

Figure RE 101 -1. RE 101 Limit For All Army Applications 38

Figure RE 101 -2. RE 101 Limit For All Navy Applications 39

Figure RE 101 -2. RE 101 Limit For All Navy Applications 39

5. 16. RE 102, Radiated Emissions, Electric Field, 10 k. Hz to 18 GHz

5. 16. RE 102, Radiated Emissions, Electric Field, 10 k. Hz to 18 GHz • Applicable to electric field emissions from the EUT and associated cables. Test Setup Boundary • Intent is to protect sensitive receivers from interference coupled through the antennas associated with the receiver. Sig Gen • Many tuned receivers have sensitivities on the order of 1 u. V and are connected to intentional apertures (the antenna) that are constructed for efficient reception of energy in the operating range of the receiver. • There is no implied relationship between this requirement and RS 103 Double Ridge Horn or Rod Antenna Shielded Enclosure Frequency Platform 12 MHz – 18 GHz * Ground 10 k. Hz – 18 GHz * Ships, Surface 10 k. Hz – 18 GHz * Submarines 10 k. Hz – 18 GHz Aircraft (Army) 2 MHz – 18 GHz * Aircraft (Air Force Navy) 10 k. Hz – 18 GHz Space Coax Cable Recording Device 40

Figure RE 102 -1. RE 102 Limit For Surface Ship Applications 41

Figure RE 102 -1. RE 102 Limit For Surface Ship Applications 41

Figure RE 102 -2. RE 102 Limit For Submarine Applications 42

Figure RE 102 -2. RE 102 Limit For Submarine Applications 42

 Figure RE 102 -3. RE 102 Limit For Aircraft And Space System Applications

Figure RE 102 -3. RE 102 Limit For Aircraft And Space System Applications 43

Figure RE 102 -4. RE 102 Limit For Ground Applications 44

Figure RE 102 -4. RE 102 Limit For Ground Applications 44

5. 17. RE 103, Radiated Emissions, Antenna Spurious and Harmonic Outputs, 10 k. Hz

5. 17. RE 103, Radiated Emissions, Antenna Spurious and Harmonic Outputs, 10 k. Hz to 40 GHz • Essentially identical with CE 106 for transmitters in the transmit mode. • No requirements for receivers or transmitters in the standby mode. • The test procedure is laborious and will require a large open area to meet antenna separation distances. • Minimum acceptable antenna separations are calculated based on antenna size and operating frequency of the EUT. • Measurements in azimuth and elevation are required. • Preamps may be required to enhance sensitivity. • Coordinate with local frequency allocation authorities. • RE 103 Limits • Harmonics, except the second and third, and all other spurious emissions shall be at least 80 d. B down from the level at the fundamental • The second and third harmonics shall be suppressed 50 + 10 log p (where p = peak power output in watts, at the fundamental) or 80 d. B, whichever requires less suppression Calibration and test setup for radiated harmonics and spurious emissions, 10 k. Hz to 1 GHz. Calibration and test setup for radiated harmonics and spurious emissions, 1 GHz to 40 GHz. 45

5. 18. RS 101, Radiated Susceptibility, Magnetic Field, 30 Hz to 100 k. Hz

5. 18. RS 101, Radiated Susceptibility, Magnetic Field, 30 Hz to 100 k. Hz • Specialized test intended to ensure that performance of equipment susceptible to low frequency magnetic fields is not degraded. • Due to its smaller size, the 4 cm loop sensor provides an accurate measure of the field near the axis of the radiating loop. • Helmholtz coils generate a relatively uniform magnetic field that is more representative of the environment experienced on some platforms, particularly submarines. For this reason, the AC Helmholtz coil test option is preferred for submarine applications. • Prior to initial use, the coils must be tested to ensure they are capable of generating the required magnetic flux densities from 30 Hz to 100 k. Hz. 4 cm loop or Helmholtz coil to Test each EUT connector EUT 46

FIGURE RS 101 -1. RS 101 Limit For All Navy Applications 47

FIGURE RS 101 -1. RS 101 Limit For All Navy Applications 47

Figure RS 101 -2. RS 101 Limit For All Army Applications 48

Figure RS 101 -2. RS 101 Limit For All Army Applications 48

5. 19. RS 103, Radiated Susceptibility, Electric Field, 2 MHz to 40 GHz •

5. 19. RS 103, Radiated Susceptibility, Electric Field, 2 MHz to 40 GHz • Applicable to both the EUT enclosures and EUT associated cabling • Concern is to ensure that equipment will operate without degradation in the presence of electromagnetic fields generated by antenna transmissions both onboard and external to the platform. • Limits for different platforms are based on levels expected to be encountered during the service life of the equipment • Not necessarily worst-case environment to which the equipment may be exposed. • For aircraft and ships, different limits are specified depending on whether the equipment receives protection from platform structure. 49

Table VII. RS 103 Limits Limit Level (Volts/Meter) Platform Aircraft (External or Safety Critical)

Table VII. RS 103 Limits Limit Level (Volts/Meter) Platform Aircraft (External or Safety Critical) Aircraft (Internal) All Ships (Above Decks) and Submarines (External)* Ships (Metallic) (Below Decks) Ships (Non. Metallic) (Below Decks) ** Submarine (Internal) Ground Space Army 200 200 10 50 5 50 20 Navy 200 200 10 50 5 10 20 Air Force 200 20 - - - - 10 20 Army 200 200 200 10 10 10 50 20 Navy 200 200 200 10 10 10 50 20 Air Force 200 60 - - 50 20 Army 200 200 10 10 10 50 20 Navy 200 60 200 10 10 10 50 20 Air Force 200 60 - - 50 20 Frequency Range 2 MHz – 30 MHz – 1 GHz – 18 GHz – 40 GHz * For equipment located external to the pressure hull of a submarine but within the superstructure, use SHIPS (METALLIC) (BELOW DECKS) ** For equipment located in the hanger deck of Aircraft Carriers. 50

5. 20. RS 105, Radiated Susceptibility, Transient Electromagnetic Field • Intended for EUTs to

5. 20. RS 105, Radiated Susceptibility, Transient Electromagnetic Field • Intended for EUTs to withstand the fast rise time, free-field transient environment of EMP. • Applies for equipment enclosures which are directly exposed to the incident field outside of the platform structure or for equipment inside poorly shielded or unshielded platforms. • The electrical interface cabling should be protected in shielded conduit. • The EMP field is simulated in the laboratory using bounded wave TEM radiators such as TEM cells and parallel plate transmission lines. • Since the polarization of the incident EMP field in the installation is not known, the EUT must be tested in all orthogonal axes. 51

Figure RS 105 -1. RS 105 Limit For All Applications 52

Figure RS 105 -1. RS 105 Limit For All Applications 52

Commercial and Other E 3 Standards · American National Standards Institute (ANSI), Institute of

Commercial and Other E 3 Standards · American National Standards Institute (ANSI), Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) · Federal Communications Commission (FCC) · Radio Technical Commission for Aeronautics (RTCA) DO -160 D · International · - European Union (EU) - International Electro-technical Commission (IEC) - International Special Committee on Radio Interference (CISPR) - Comité Européen de Normalisation Électrotechnique (European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization) (CENELEC) - North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) EPS 0178 - Results Of Detailed Comparisons Of Individual EMC Requirements And Test Procedures Delineated In Major National And International Commercial Standards With Military Standard MIL-STD 461 E · Appendix E - MIL-HDBK-237 53

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COMMERCIAL AND MILITARY STANDARDS • Major differences: – Unique platform requirements because

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COMMERCIAL AND MILITARY STANDARDS • Major differences: – Unique platform requirements because of critical dependence on the reception of certain frequencies – More severe military RE limits due to: • larger concentration high-power emitters • more sensitive receivers in military platforms – The military imposes higher susceptibility (immunity) requirements due to co-located intentional emitters 54

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COMMERCIAL AND MILITARY STANDARDS • Major differences (continued) – Military platforms have

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COMMERCIAL AND MILITARY STANDARDS • Major differences (continued) – Military platforms have grounded conducting surfaces for mounting equipment; civilian items are usually mounted on ungrounded tables – Military’s frequency ranges are more extensive than commercial • No commercial standard equivalent to MILSTD-461 E 55

Differences Between Commercial And Military Standards • Evaluate anticipated EME vs. characteristics of the

Differences Between Commercial And Military Standards • Evaluate anticipated EME vs. characteristics of the CI under consideration • Determine: – Which commercial standards apply to CI? – Their adequacy for the intended use – If additional tests and requirements should be imposed • Decision process illustrated in Figure E-1 (pg 167 of notes) 56

Defining Applicable EMI Requirements Specify Mission Define performance characteristics taking into account mission and

Defining Applicable EMI Requirements Specify Mission Define performance characteristics taking into account mission and safety criticality Determine operational EME N Can MIL-STD 461 E requirements be tailored to meet operational requirements? N Specify additional requirements Are requirements in MILSTD 461 E appropriate? Y Y Tailor requirements Is item produced for military or commercial use? MIL Evaluate risks using EPS recommendations, as applicable N Retest N Is retest necessary? Use EPS, as applicable to assess risks Y Does item meet requirements? N COM Y N Is risk acceptable? Y Is additional testing required? Y Perform tests Modify Y Can equipment or installation be modified? N REJECT ACCEPT 57

58

58

5. 11 External Grounds MIL-STD-464 A Recognizes the impact of EME on the warfighting

5. 11 External Grounds MIL-STD-464 A Recognizes the impact of EME on the warfighting capability of the Armed Forces. Establishes requirements on how system need to interface with each other in the EME. Provides Detailed requirements for: 59

MIL-STD-464 A What it provides: Basic E 3 requirements and guidance. What it doesn’t

MIL-STD-464 A What it provides: Basic E 3 requirements and guidance. What it doesn’t provide: Go/No Go or Pass/Fail test procedures. E 3 Requirements and Guidance Go/No-Go Pass/Fail Procedures A standard to establish requirements on how systems need to interface with each other in the Electromagnetic Environmental Effects (E 3) arena 60

MIL-STD-464 A Format MAIN BODY (Specifies a base line set of requirements) þ Definitions

MIL-STD-464 A Format MAIN BODY (Specifies a base line set of requirements) þ Definitions þ General Requirements þ Detailed Requirements þ Data Item Descriptions APPENDIX þ Requirements (repeats standard in italics) • Rationale • Guidance • Lessons Learned þ Verification • Rationale • Guidance • Lessons Learned 61

MIL-STD-464 A Contents Detailed Requirement Appendix Subject Para. Page Margins Intra-system EMC External RF

MIL-STD-464 A Contents Detailed Requirement Appendix Subject Para. Page Margins Intra-system EMC External RF EME Lightning Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Subsystems & equipment EMI Electrostatic charge control Electromagnetic radiation hazard Life cycle, E 3 hardness Electrical bonding Electrical grounds TEMPEST Emission control EM spectrum compatibility 5. 1 5. 2 5. 3 5. 4 5. 5 5. 6 5. 7 5. 8 5. 9 5. 10 5. 11 5. 12 5. 13 5. 14 5 5 6 9 9 9 11 11 13 13 14 14 14 15 A 5. 1 A 5. 2 A 5. 3 A 5. 4 A 5. 5 A 5. 6 A 5. 7 A 5. 8 A 5. 9 A 5. 10 A 5. 11 A 5. 12 A 5. 13 A 5. 14 33 36 44 54 60 65 72 79 86 91 106 107 110 62

MIL-STD-464 A Contents Each section has overall requirements similar to the one below for

MIL-STD-464 A Contents Each section has overall requirements similar to the one below for Intra-System EMC 5. 2 Intra-System Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) The system shall be electromagnetically compatible within itself such that system operational performance requirements are met. Compliance shall be verified by systemlevel test, analysis, or a combination thereof. MIL -ST D-4 64 A 63

EMC Requirements EMP Lightning External RF EME External to System Cross coupling of electrical

EMC Requirements EMP Lightning External RF EME External to System Cross coupling of electrical currents EME issues Self-generated RF transmissions from antennas Unintentional conducted and radiated EM emissions Internal to System 64

EMC Requirements (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format In addition to design requirements, MIL-STD-464 A

EMC Requirements (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format In addition to design requirements, MIL-STD-464 A provides verification requirements Costly Delays during system development Mission Aborts Reduced system and equipment operational effectiveness Identify assets for E 3 requirement verification early! 65

5. 2 Intra-System EMC: 5. 2 Intra-System EMC MIL-STD-464 A Format Verification Rationale The

5. 2 Intra-System EMC: 5. 2 Intra-System EMC MIL-STD-464 A Format Verification Rationale The most basic element of demonstrating that E 3 design efforts have been successful is verification of intra-system EMC through testing, supported by analysis. EMC Testing EMC Analysis 66

5. 3 External RF EME MIL-STD-464 A Format The system shall be electromagnetically compatible

5. 3 External RF EME MIL-STD-464 A Format The system shall be electromagnetically compatible with its defined external RF EME such that its SOP requirements are met. 67

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format TABLE 1 A. External

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format TABLE 1 A. External EME for deck operations on ships TABLE 1 B. External EME for shipboard operations in the main beam of transmitters 68

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format 69

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format 69

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format TABLE 1 E. External

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format TABLE 1 E. External EME for Army rotary wing aircraft 260 70

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format TABLE 1 F: External

5. 3 External RF EME (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format TABLE 1 F: External EME for fixed wing aircraft, excluding shipboard operations 71

5. 4 Lightning MIL-STD-464 A Format • The system shall meet its operational performance

5. 4 Lightning MIL-STD-464 A Format • The system shall meet its operational performance requirements for both direct and indirect effects of lightning • Ordnance shall meet its operational performance requirements after experiencing a near strike in an exposed condition and a direct strike in a stored condition. • Ordnance shall remain safe during and after experiencing a direct strike in an exposed condition 72

5. 4 Lightning (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format Direct effects of lightning are: •

5. 4 Lightning (cont. ) MIL-STD-464 A Format Direct effects of lightning are: • Burning • Eroding • Blasting • Structural deformation • High pressure shock waves • Magnetic forces produced by the associated high currents Indirect effects are those resulting from the electromagnetic fields associated with lightning and the interaction of these electromagnetic fields with equipment in the system. 73

5. 5 Electromagnetic Pulse MIL-STD-464 A Format (EMP) The system shall meet its operational

5. 5 Electromagnetic Pulse MIL-STD-464 A Format (EMP) The system shall meet its operational performance requirements after being subjected to the EMP Environment. 74

5. 5 Electromagnetic Pulse MIL-STD-464 A Format (EMP) The following are elements of an

5. 5 Electromagnetic Pulse MIL-STD-464 A Format (EMP) The following are elements of an iterative process for designing and verifying protection of a system’s electrical and electronic equipment against the effects of EMP. a. EMP coupling analysis b. Identification of relevant subsystems c. Equipment strength determination d. Specification compliance demonstration 75

5. 6 Subsystems and Equipment MIL-STD-464 A Format EMI Intra-system EMC is the most

5. 6 Subsystems and Equipment MIL-STD-464 A Format EMI Intra-system EMC is the most basic element of E 3 concerns. Individual subsystems and equipment shall meet interference control requirements so that the overall system complies with all applicable requirements of this standard 76

5. 6 Subsystems and Equipment MIL-STD-464 A Format EMI (cont. ) Areas of EMI

5. 6 Subsystems and Equipment MIL-STD-464 A Format EMI (cont. ) Areas of EMI requirements Unintentional subsystem emissions Susceptibility to external influences. Each of these areas can have conducted and radiated controls. 77

5. 7 Electrostatic Charge MIL-STD-464 A Format Control The system shall control and dissipate

5. 7 Electrostatic Charge MIL-STD-464 A Format Control The system shall control and dissipate the build-up of electrostatic charges caused by precipitation static (p-static) effects, fluid flow, air flow, exhaust gas flow, personnel charging, charging of launch vehicles (including pre-launch conditions) and space vehicles (post deployment), and other charge generating mechanisms to avoid fuel ignition and ordnance hazards, to protect personnel from shock hazards, and to prevent performance degradation or damage to electronics. 78

5. 7 Electrostatic Charge MIL-STD-464 A Format Control Nature Dust Rain Snow Human Related

5. 7 Electrostatic Charge MIL-STD-464 A Format Control Nature Dust Rain Snow Human Related System Related 79

5. 7. 1 Vertical Lift and In-Flight MIL-STD-464 A Format Refueling The system shall

5. 7. 1 Vertical Lift and In-Flight MIL-STD-464 A Format Refueling The system shall meet its operational performance requirements when subjected to a 300 kilovolt discharge. This requirement is applicable to vertical lift aircraft, inflight refueling of any aircraft, and systems operated or transported externally by vertical lift aircraft. Compliance shall be verified by test (such as MIL-STD-331 for ordnance), analysis, inspections, or a combination thereof. The test configuration shall include electrostatic discharge in the vertical lift mode and in-flight refueling mode from a simulated aircraft capacitance of 1000 picofarad, through a maximum of one ohm resistance. 80

5. 7. 2 Precipitation Static (P MIL-STD-464 A Format -Static) The system shall control

5. 7. 2 Precipitation Static (P MIL-STD-464 A Format -Static) The system shall control p-static interference to antenna-connected receivers onboard the system or on the host platform such that system operational performance requirements are met. The system shall protect against puncture of structural materials and finishes and shock hazards from charge accumulation. Compliance shall be verified by test, analysis, inspections, or a combination thereof. 81

5. 7. 3 Ordnance Subsystems MIL-STD-464 A Format Ordnance subsystems shall not be inadvertently

5. 7. 3 Ordnance Subsystems MIL-STD-464 A Format Ordnance subsystems shall not be inadvertently initiated or dudded by a 25 kilovolt electrostatic discharge caused by personnel handling. 82

5. 8 Electromagnetic Radiation MIL-STD-464 A Format Hazard (EMRADHAZ) The system design shall protect

5. 8 Electromagnetic Radiation MIL-STD-464 A Format Hazard (EMRADHAZ) The system design shall protect personnel, fuels, and ordnance from hazardous effects of electromagnetic radiation. 83

5. 8. 1 Hazards of Electromagnetic MIL-STD-464 A Format Radiation to Personnel (HERP) The

5. 8. 1 Hazards of Electromagnetic MIL-STD-464 A Format Radiation to Personnel (HERP) The system shall comply with current Do. D criteria for the protection of personnel against the effect of electromagnetic radiation. 84

5. 8. 2 Hazards of Electromagnetic MIL-STD-464 A Format Radiation to Fuel (HERF) Fuels

5. 8. 2 Hazards of Electromagnetic MIL-STD-464 A Format Radiation to Fuel (HERF) Fuels shall not be inadvertently ignited by radiated EMEs. The EME includes onboard emitters and the external EME 85

5. 8. 3 Hazards of Electromagnetic MIL-STD-464 A Format Radiation to Ordnance (HERO) Electrically

5. 8. 3 Hazards of Electromagnetic MIL-STD-464 A Format Radiation to Ordnance (HERO) Electrically initiated devices (EIDs) in ordnance shall not be inadvertently actuated during or experience degraded performance characteristics after exposure to the external EME levels… 86

5. 8. 3 HERO: Verification MIL-STD-464 A Format Guidance Stockpile-to-Safe Separation 1 Sequence (S

5. 8. 3 HERO: Verification MIL-STD-464 A Format Guidance Stockpile-to-Safe Separation 1 Sequence (S 4) Transportation Assembly/ Disassembly 2 / Storage Immediate Post Launch 3 6 Staged Handling/Loading Platform. Loaded 5 4 87

5. 9 Life Cycle, E 3 Hardness MIL-STD-464 A Format RIP Retirement Operational Employment

5. 9 Life Cycle, E 3 Hardness MIL-STD-464 A Format RIP Retirement Operational Employment Maintenance, Repair, Corrosion Control, Monitoring Acquisition The system operational performance and E 3 requirements of this standard shall be met throughout the rated life cycle of the system shall include, but not be limited to, the following: maintenance, repair, surveillance, and corrosion control. 88

5. 9 Life Cycle, E 3 Hardness MIL-STD-464 A Format (cont. ) Paint over

5. 9 Life Cycle, E 3 Hardness MIL-STD-464 A Format (cont. ) Paint over spring fingers Missing spring fingers EMI Screens must be intact and good contact at edges. Bonding surfaces must provide conductivity. 89

5. 10 Electrical Bonding MIL-STD-464 A Format The system, subsystems, and equipment shall include

5. 10 Electrical Bonding MIL-STD-464 A Format The system, subsystems, and equipment shall include the necessary electrical bonding to meet the E 3 requirements of this standard. 90

5. 11 External Grounds Equipment to Frame Ground Facility to Earth Ground Frame to

5. 11 External Grounds Equipment to Frame Ground Facility to Earth Ground Frame to Facility Ground The system and associated subsystems shall provide external grounding provisions to control electrical current flow and static charging for protection of personnel from shock, prevention of inadvertent ignition of ordnance, fuel and flammable vapors, and protection of hardware from damage. 91

5. 12 TEMPEST 5. 11 External Grounds National security information shall not be compromised

5. 12 TEMPEST 5. 11 External Grounds National security information shall not be compromised by emanations from classified information processing equipment. 92

5. 13 EMCON 5. 11 External Grounds EMISSION CONTROL! Unintentional electromagnetic radiated emissions shall

5. 13 EMCON 5. 11 External Grounds EMISSION CONTROL! Unintentional electromagnetic radiated emissions shall not exceed -110 d. Bm/m 2 at one nautical mile (-105 d. Bm/m 2 at one kilometer) in any direction from the system over the frequency range of 500 k. Hz to 40 GHz, when using the resolution bandwidths listed in Table 4 93

5. 14 EM Spectrum Compatibility 5. 11 External Grounds Air Expeditionary Force Army Heavy

5. 14 EM Spectrum Compatibility 5. 11 External Grounds Air Expeditionary Force Army Heavy Division Carrier Battle Group XX 3150 SQ KM 45 KM OVER 1, 400 EMITTERS X X X OVER 10, 700 EMITTERS OVER 2, 400 EMITTERS 70 KM VHF UHF SHF 1000 MHz 3000 MHz SHF EHF 10 GHz Federal Spectrum 30 GHz Non-Federal Spectrum 6000 MHz Shared Spectrum 60 GHz “Typical” Battleforce Use Systems, subsystems, and equipment shall comply with the Do. D, national, and international regulations for the use of the electromagnetic spectrum (such as NTIA “Manual of Regulations and Procedures for Radio Frequency Management” and Do. DD 4650. 1). 94