Network Formation Games Ofir Geri Price of Anarchy

  • Slides: 77
Download presentation
Network Formation Games Ofir Geri Price of Anarchy Seminar Supervised by Prof. Michal Feldman

Network Formation Games Ofir Geri Price of Anarchy Seminar Supervised by Prof. Michal Feldman Tel-Aviv University 2/4/2014

Introduction •

Introduction •

Outline • General cost-sharing connection games • Fair cost-sharing connection games • Capacitated symmetric

Outline • General cost-sharing connection games • Fair cost-sharing connection games • Capacitated symmetric cost-sharing connection games

General Cost-Sharing Connection Games E. Anshelevich, A. Dasgupta, É. Tardos, and T. Wexler, “Near-Optimal

General Cost-Sharing Connection Games E. Anshelevich, A. Dasgupta, É. Tardos, and T. Wexler, “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”

The Connection Game •

The Connection Game •

Basic Properties of Nash Equilibria • The bought edges form a graph that is

Basic Properties of Nash Equilibria • The bought edges form a graph that is a forest • A player only contributes to the edges they use • Each edge is either fully paid for or not paid at all

A Game Without Nash Equilibrium

A Game Without Nash Equilibrium

A Nash Equilibrium May Require Cost-Sharing •

A Nash Equilibrium May Require Cost-Sharing •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal

Single Source Games: Price of Stability (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”)

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. ,

Single Source Games: Price of Stability • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”)

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Single Source Games: Price of Stability •

Approximate Nash Equilibria •

Approximate Nash Equilibria •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

Single Source Games •

General Connection Games • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design

General Connection Games • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”)

General Connection Games •

General Connection Games •

Stable Payments •

Stable Payments •

Stable Payments •

Stable Payments •

Connection Set: Definition •

Connection Set: Definition •

Connection Sets •

Connection Sets •

Connection Sets •

Connection Sets •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”)

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”)

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium • (Figure taken from Anshelevich et al. , “Near-Optimal Network Design with Selfish Agents”)

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

3 -Approximate Nash Equilibrium •

Fair Cost-Sharing Connection Games E. Anshelevich, A. Dasgupta, J. Kleinberg, É. Tardos, T. Wexler,

Fair Cost-Sharing Connection Games E. Anshelevich, A. Dasgupta, J. Kleinberg, É. Tardos, T. Wexler, and T. Roughgarden, “The Price of Stability for Network Design with Fair Cost Allocation”

The Fair Connection Game •

The Fair Connection Game •

Price of Anarchy and Price of Stability •

Price of Anarchy and Price of Stability •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Concave Cost Functions •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Games with Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Game with Only Delays •

Weighted Players •

Weighted Players •

Weighted Players •

Weighted Players •

Weighted Players •

Weighted Players •

Capacitated Cost-Sharing Connection Games M. Feldman and T. Ron, “Capacitated Network Design Games”

Capacitated Cost-Sharing Connection Games M. Feldman and T. Ron, “Capacitated Network Design Games”

Model •

Model •

The Price of Anarchy • (Figure taken from Feldman and Ron, “Capacitated Network Design

The Price of Anarchy • (Figure taken from Feldman and Ron, “Capacitated Network Design Games”)

Graph-Theoretic Preliminaries s 1 … s 2 t 1 … … s 1 s

Graph-Theoretic Preliminaries s 1 … s 2 t 1 … … s 1 s 2 … t 1 t 2 • t 2

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Anarchy •

The Price of Stability • (Figure taken from Feldman and Ron, “Capacitated Network Design

The Price of Stability • (Figure taken from Feldman and Ron, “Capacitated Network Design Games”)

Questions?

Questions?