Managing Student Loans in a Changing Landscape Adam

Managing Student Loans in a Changing Landscape Adam S. Minsky, Esq. Law Office of Adam S. Minsky Boston, MA 1 S

The Numbers S Total outstanding student loan debt: $1. 4 trillion S Second-largest type of consumer debt (after mortgages) S Total number of Americans with student loans: 44 million S Approximately 1 in 9 S Percentage of students graduating with debt: 70% S Average 2016 undergrad student debt: $37, 000. S 2015 was $35, 000. 2014 was $33, 000. 2013 was $30, 000. S Percentage of borrowers in delinquency or default: 25% Sources: The Center for Financial Literacy, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, The Institute for College Access and Success, Edvisors, the Government Accountability Office, Market. Watch, Student Loan Hero, New York Fed 2

Types of Student Loans Who is holding the loan: Federal Government Entity Private Lender Direct FFEL Private Perkins Institutional School Stafford Sub PLUS Unsub Grad 3 Parent Traditional

Figuring Out the Type of Loan Private S Pull credit report. S Review note, application, bills, and letters for name of lender, loan program. S Look for a co-signer or option of one (much more likely to be present). S * Few options to manage repayment Federal 4 S Check NSLDS (www. nslds. ed. gov) S Requires FSA ID (different from Federal PIN). S Review note, application, bills, and letters for name of federal loan program (i. e. , “Stafford” or “PLUS”) S *More options to manage repayment

Key Players S Lender: The entity that originates the loan. S S For Direct loans, this is the Dept. of Ed. For FFEL loans, this is a commercial/private lender. S Guarantor: For FFEL and some private loans only, the entity that "insures" the lender. S Servicer: The entity that deals with day-to-day operations of the loan. S Collection Agency: Represents the guarantor or lender when loan is in default (not on NSLDS). *Knowing who is handling the loan is important in understanding your rights and options 5

Possible Loan Statuses S Grace Period S Repayment / Current S Deferment S Forbearance S Delinquency S Default Knowing the loan status is also critical 6

Postponing Repayment Deferments (federal) A delay in repayment. Available deferments include: • Student deferments for at least half-time study • Graduate fellowship deferments • Unemployment deferments (for up to three years) • Economic hardship deferments (granted one year at a time for up to three years) 7

Postponing Repayment Forbearances (federal and private) • The government does not pay interest during the forbearance period (for federal loans) • Economic hardship forbearances available (up to three years) • Significant interest consequences due to capitalization • Can be retroactive to cancel out delinquency • Private loan forbearance available, but very limited 8

Balance-Based Repayment (federal) Monthly payments made based on loan balance and interest rate. The general rule is the longer the repayment term, the lower the monthly payment, but the more you’ll pay in total. S Level: 10 year, 25 year, 30 year (limitations) S Graduated: 10 year, 25 year, 30 year (limitations) Tip: Be wary of graduated plans! (Especially for law grads) 9

Income-Driven Repayment (federal) If borrower cannot afford balance-based payments on federal loans, consider income-driven repayment options S Affordable payments even for large federal loan balances S Better long-term solution than deferments and forbearance (which will run out) S Poverty exemptions S Progress towards loan forgiveness S Interest subsidy on subsidized loans for first 3 years 10

Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) S Direct loans ONLY S 20% of “discretionary income, ” which is the difference between AGI and 100% of federal poverty level. S 25 -year repayment term, then remaining balance is forgiven. *Taxable? S Example: Single borrower, $50, 000 federal loan, AGI = $40, 000. ICR payment = $445. S Joint income of married borrowers, unless they file taxes separately S ICR doesn’t make sense for most borrowers, except certain Parent PLUS borrowers (must first consolidate) 11

Income-Based Repayment (IBR) S Direct or FFEL loans. NO PARENT PLUS loans. S 15% of “discretionary income, ” which is the difference between AGI and 150% of federal poverty level. S 25 -year repayment term, then remaining balance is forgiven. *Taxable? S Example: Single borrower, $50, 000 federal loan, AGI = $40, 000. IBR payment = $280. S Joint income of married borrowers, unless they file taxes separately 12

Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE) S Direct Loans Only. NO PARENT PLUS loans. S 10% of “discretionary income. ” S 20 -year repayment term, then remaining balance is forgiven. *Taxable? S Example: Single borrower, $50, 000 federal loan, AGI = $40, 000. PAYE payment = $190. S Limited to “new borrowers. ” No outstanding fed loan as of Oct. 1, 2007, and new fed loan on or after Oct. 1, 2011. S Joint income of married borrowers, unless they file taxes separately (like IBR, ICR) S Interest capitalization limited to 10% of original PAYE loan balance 13

Revised Pay-As-You-Earn (REPAYE) S Eliminates “new borrower” restrictions placed on PAYE and “New IBR” S 10% of “discretionary income” (just like PAYE) S Some important differences from other plans: S Only Direct Loans. S Joint income for married borrowers regardless of tax filing S 20 -year repayment term for undergraduate loans. S 25 -year repayment term if borrower took out any graduate loans. S Interest benefit – 50% of interest waived during negative amortization 14

Public service loan forgiveness S Only Direct Loans S Must make 120 payments (10 years of payments) AFTER Oct. 1, 2007. Not retroactive. S Payments must be made through eligible payment plans (10 - year Standard, ICR, IBR, PAYE, or REPAYE). Can’t be in default. S Full-time, qualifying public service employment for each payment, and when borrower applies forgiveness S Can submit application to “track” payments S Forgiven amount not taxable income 15

Teacher Loan Forgiveness S Right type of loans S Federal Stafford loans disbursed after 1998 S Right type of teaching S Specific type of teacher, specific type of school S For right amount of time S 5 consecutive years of service S Forgiveness is capped at $5, 000 or $17, 500 S Cannot make progress towards TLF and PSLF at the same time 16

Perkins Loan Forgiveness S ONLY available for Perkins loans S Be careful about consolidating! S ONLY available for certain specific full-time professions: S Nurse, medical technician, provider of early intervention services for the disabled, speech pathologists and special ed teachers in certain low-income schools or educational service agencies S Can provide up to 100% forgiveness over 5 years, with no payments required S Complete application through school (lender) or servicer 17

Repayment Assistance S National Health Service Corps (NHSC) S Competitive application process S Must be dedicated primary care provider in medicine (MD, DO, NP, CNM, PA), dentistry (DMD, DDS, RDH), or mental health (HSP, LCSW, PNS, MFT, LPC) S Must serve community in need at an NHSC-approved site with a minimum two-year commitment S Ameri. Corps, Peace. Corps S Employer-based repayment assistance S School-based repayment assistance 18

Refinancing / Consolidating through a private lender S PROS: Potentially lower interest rate, better repayment terms (especially for high-interest private loans) S CONS: If you refinance federal loans through a private lender, you forever lose out on federal student loan program benefits and consumer protections. S Considerations: Interest rate, repayment terms/conditions, origination fees S Rules of Thumb: S S S Refinancing high-interest private loans = Good idea! Refinancing high-interest federal loans = It Depends. Consider life insurance and LTD insurance to mitigate some risks So. Fi, Earnest, Lend. Key, Common Bond, DRB, Credible, some banks 19

Defining Default Private Federal Requires review of the promissory note, as “default” is defined by the terms of each individual loan. “The failure of a borrower and endorser, if any, to make an installment payment when due, or to meet other terms of the promissory note, if the Secretary finds it reasonable to conclude that the borrower and endorser, if any, no longer intend to honor the obligation to repay, provided that this failure persists for 270 days. ” 34 C. F. R. 685. 102 20

Consequences of Private Loan Default S Negative credit reporting. S Collection calls and letters. S Assessment of late fees. S Assessment of collection costs. S Litigation in state court. Aside from bankruptcy restrictions, private default is not much different from defaulting on other unsecured consumer debt 21

Consequences of Federal Loan Default S Negative credit reporting S Denial of new federal aid S Collection fees up to 25%. S “Forced” Administrative Collections – Treasury offset, wage garnishment S Litigation (in a small number of cases) S No statute of limitations applies. 22

Federal Default Resolution S Discharge S Disability, certain types of school misconduct S Rehabilitation S Temporary, 9 -month repayment plan tied to income S Consolidation S New federal consolidation loan – must select IDR plan S Compromise/settlement S Will not get pennies on the dollar 23

New Legislation S Temporary Expanded Public Service Loan Forgiveness (TEPSLF) S Addresses borrowers who were on the wrong repayment plan (but not borrowers who have the wrong loan) S Discretionary fund established S Exceptionally complicated S Tax relief for federal discharge due to disability or death S No longer treated as taxable income – no 1099 -C 24

Proposed Legislation S White House budget proposal S De-fund PSLF and eliminate IDR plans S Would grandfather in current borrowers S Was not included in Congressional budget S PROSPER Act S Repeals PSLF and eliminates IDR plans S Eliminates Stafford and Grad PLUS loan programs S Would grandfather in current borrowers S Rumor is that this bill is effectively dead (for now) S New rules from Dept. of Ed rescinding borrower protections S Gainful Employment S Borrower “Defense to Repayment” 25

Pending Litigation S Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. PHEAA / Fed. Loan S Accuses PHEAA of widespread servicing problems, particularly for borrowers seeking PSLF and IDR plans S American Bar Association v. PHEAA and Dept. of Ed S In response to PHEAA reversing PSLF decisions S CFPB (and others) v. Navient S Alleging widespread systematic servicing problems 26

Other Proposals and Potential Developments S Automatic recertification for IDR plans S Automatic payroll deductions for IDR plans S Elimination of loan forgiveness tax for IDR plans S Changing bankruptcy jurisprudence 27

Resources: S www. studentaid. ed. gov S www. studentloans. gov S www. nclc. org S www. ibrinfo. org S www. nhsc. hrsa. gov 28

Get to know me: S Web: www. minsky-law. com S Blog: www. Boston. Student. Loan. Lawyer. com S Linked. In: /Adam. SMinsky S Twitter: @Adam. SMinsky S Fbook: @Boston. Student. Loan. Lawyer

Questions? Adam S. Minsky Law Office of Adam S. Minsky asminsky@minsky-law. com 30 S