Lecture 5 Chapter 11 Unicast Routing Protocols RIP

Lecture 5 Chapter 11 Unicast Routing Protocols (RIP, OSPF, BGP) (How the routers’ tables are filled in) Dr. Clincy 1

Routing Protocols • At this stage, we understand how a router uses a routing table in making a next hop decision • However, what dictates HOW the routing tables are filled in ? • Tables are concerned about the next hop only • What’s responsible for looking across the entire path or route – what makes the decision of the best route ? • Routing Protocols and Algorithms are used • Routing protocols allow routers to share info with one another dynamically - as the Internet makes changes, the routing protocols allow routers to inform other routers • Routers communicate to their neighboring routers - gossip • Routing protocols implement the procedures for combining info received from other routers • Routing Algorithms – decision making analysis – the “brains” – using the info provided Dr. Clincy 2

Autonomous systems • Because the Internet is so large, one protocol cannot handle all of the updating of tables – create groups and networks and routers called Autonomous Systems • Routing within the autonomous system is called “interior routing” • Routing between the autonomous systems is called “exterior routing” NOTE: different interior routing protocols can be used for each autonomous systems HOWEVER, only one exterior routing protocol is used R 1, R 2, R 3 and R 4 use an interior and exterior routing protocol – all other routers only use an interior routing protocol Dr. Clincy 3

Tx How does it work ? • A certain “cost” or “metric” is assigned each network Rx • In figuring out the best route from Tx to Rx, the set of networks with the smallest sum is chosen • More generically, the set of networks best • If #hops was the metric, we would want to traverse meeting the least number of networks in going from Tx to Rx “metric’s” objective is chosen • If max throughput was the metric, a fiber optic network would have a better metric than a coaxial network. Dr. Clincy 4

Explain routing using your street/highway analogy • Autonomous systems • Default routing Dr. Clincy 5

Popular Unicast Routing protocols • RIP – Routing Information Protocol – treats each network the same (assigns the same cost for each network) • OSPF – Open Shortest Path First protocol – assigns a cost for passing through a network based on the type of service required – routes through the network can have different cost – each router would have several tables • BGP – Border Gateway Protocol – is an exterior routing protocol that uses a policy that defines what paths should be chosen Dr. Clincy 6

RIP Algorithm Distance Vector Algorithm built from Bellman-Ford Algorithm Recall: each router sends message to it’s neighbor For the router receiving a RIP response 1 st – add one to hop count for each destination advertised 2 nd – repeat the following steps for each advertised destination 1. If destination is not in table add destination to table 2. Else if destination is in table 1. If next-hop field is the same replace entry in table with advertised one 2. Else next-hop different Dr. Clincy replace entry if advertised hop count is less 7

Example RIP Algorithm • Router receives RIP message for some router C • The RIP message list destination networks, corresponding hop count and next hop (not listed in diagram) • 1 st step: increment hop count • Net 1: no news, don’t change • Net 2: same next hop, so replace 2 with 5 • Net 3: new router, so add • Net 6: different next hop, new hop count less, so replace • Net 8: different next hop, new hop count the same, don’t change • Net 9: different next hop, new hop count larger, do not change Dr. Clincy 8

Initial routing tables in a small autonomous system Initial tables are created from config file (and hop counts are set to 1) – next hop fields are empty initially because all networks are directly connected Dr. Clincy 9

Final routing tables for the previous figure For example, suppose packet hitting Router A first had a destination of Net 66 ? Dr. Clincy 10

RIP message format • Command – 8 -bit field specifying the type of message: response (2) or request (1) • Version – 8 -bit field specifying RIP version • Family – 16 -bit specifying protocol family (TCP/IP=2) • Network Address – address of the destination network • Distance – 32 -bit field defining the hop count from advertising router to destination network NOTE: Request can be issued by a newly added router or by a router seeking certain info NOTE: 2 response types: Solicited – response to request, Unsolicited – periodic updates Gray fields repeated for each destination network Dr. Clincy 11

Example 1 What is the periodic response sent by router R 1 in the figure below. Assume R 1 knows about the whole autonomous system. Dr. Clincy 12

Solution R 1 can advertise three networks 144. 2. 7. 0, 144. 2. 9. 0, and 144. 2. 12. 0. The periodic response (update packet) is shown below Dr. Clincy 13

RIP timers • Periodic Timer – each router has timer set to 25 -35 secs and when the timer counts down, an update message is sent • Expiration Timer – governs the validity of the next-hop – when router receives next-hop update, timer is set to 180 sec. If there is a problem and the router doesn’t receive it’s 30 sec update, the route info expires (invalid) after the 180 sec count down – then the hop count is set to 16 (infinity) • Garbage Collection Timer – once the route expires, this timer is set to 120 sec and counts downs – allows neighbors time to become aware of invalidity – after count down, info is purged Dr. Clincy 14

Problems with RIP • Slow Convergence – the time it takes a change in the Internet to propagate through the rest of the Internet – recall the periodic updates with neighbors. DEPENDING ON THE DATA RATE, millions or billions of bits could be sent in that time – therefore possibly lost nx 15 s Dr. Clincy 15

RIP Problem - Instability • RA and RB has hop counts 1 and 2, respectively for Net 1 • Net 1 goes down – RA can update fast due to direct connection – sets hop count to 16 • RA has to wait 30 sec to update RB (this is the problem) • In meanwhile, RB sends update to RA with hop count 2 for Net 1 (incremented to 3) • Now when RA finally send the update to RB, it sends a hop count of 3 (incremented to 4) – RA thinks it’s another route to Net 1 • This INSTABILITY (back-andforth) continues until both set hop count to 16 Dr. Clincy 16

Popular Unicast Routing protocols • RIP – Routing Information Protocol – treats each network the same (assigns the same cost for each network) • OSPF – Open Shortest Path First protocol – assigns a cost for passing through a network based on the type of service required – routes through the network can have different cost – each router would have several tables • BGP – Border Gateway Protocol – is an exterior routing protocol that uses a policy that defines what paths should be chosen Dr. Clincy 17

OSPF: Open Shortest Path First • Similar to RIP however, divide autonomous system into areas • Routers with in an area floods the area with routing info – router sends to all it’s neighbors and each neighbor sends to all it’s neighbors and etc. . • At the border of an area, special routers called area border routers are used to (1) summarize info about an area and (2) send info amongst areas • A special area called the backbone is used to tie together all of the areas – backbone is primary area and all other areas are secondary areas – backbone area uses backbone routers • Note: backbone router can also be an area border router • Each area has an ID (backbone’s Id is 0) Explain Current Real World Practices relating to this topic Dr. Clincy 18

Recall OSPF: Open Shortest Path First • The OSPF is similar to RIP however, it allows the admin the ability to assign a cost or metric to each route. • The metric can be based on a type of service (ie. Min delay, max throughput, etc. . ) • For OSPF, a router will have multiple routing tables – one for each TOS • Unlike RIP, sharing or updating is done when there is a change (not periodically) • For OSPF, the objective is for the routers to contain the full picture or topology of the Internet – by having this, the router can figure out the “shortest path” or “least cost” route between itself and each network • To do this, the Internet is represented by a graph – set of edges and nodes Dr. Clincy 19

Defining edges or connections/links Point-to-point link Virtual link Direct connection between two routers, no IP address needed Bi-directional Edge When link between two routers are broken, admin creates a new route across multiple routers Transient link Stub link Represents the network Dr. Clincy Connects to only one router – packets enter and leave through this same router 20

Graphical representation of an internet Dr. Clincy 21

OSPF uses Dijkstra’s Shortest Path Algorithm Dr. Clincy 22

Dijkstra’s Algorithm Cont. . Dr. Clincy 23

Dijkstra’s Algorithm Continued At this point, we would have the least cost path from A to all other nodes Note: to find the least cost paths from E to all other nodes, Disjkstra’s algorithm has to run again Dr. Clincy 24

Answer in Hyphen Format A-D-N 3 -F-N 5 A-N 1 -B-E-N 4 A-N 1 -C-N 2 A-N 1 Dr. Clincy A-N 1 -B 25

A re-occurring theme How do the OSPF packets travel across the network(s) ? ? ? ? Dr. Clincy 26

OSPF packets are encapsulated in IP datagrams. Dr. Clincy 27

BGP: Border Gateway Protocol BPG is an interautonomous system routing protocol that makes use of path vector routing For BPG, each routing entry contains (1) destination network, (2) next router (hop) and (3) entire path to reach destination Path is an ordered list of autonomous systems that the packet should travel through to make it to the destination Dr. Clincy 28