Dr Dwayne Winseck Professor School of Journalism and

Dr. Dwayne Winseck Professor, School of Journalism and Communications Carleton University Director, Canadian Media Concentration Research Project www. cmcrp. org

Media + Broadband Use and Rankings in Select OECD Countries, 2012 OECD Country Ranks Canada UK Korea US Japan Italy France Spain Germany Australia New Zealand Chile Mexico Online Min/ IP Traffic/ Smart Phone Tablet Data/ Online Video TV Viewing Facebook (% Wikipedia Overall Rank User/Month Capita (GB) Data/Mo/ Mo/Device Viewing/Mo Min/Day Pop) Rank/Top User (MB) (min) (2011) Websites 2478 2238 1800 2580 1314 1110 1674 1428 1476 1110 1176 1128 36 316 508 26 304 991 48 528 1544 40 201 382 18 232 957 8 61 644 18 315 970 12 306 724 13 72 533 18 141 469 14 174 464 11 78 479 5 104 352 1488 53 7 52 9 21 16 53 6 14 6 38 7 209 39 10 989 243 37 10 1299 216 31 9 49 8 45 8 54 6 33 7 1870 2842 1308 2842 1208 1094 670 666 765 710 Sources: OECD (2013); Cisco Visual Networking Index; Internetworldstats (2013). 248 246 231 293 231 257 193 205 165 1 2 3 3 5 7 4 6 7 8 10 9 11

Household Access to Media and ICTs by Quintile, 2011. 100. 0% 80. 0% 60. 0% Phone Cable/DTH/IPTV Cellphone 40. 0% High Speed Internet 20. 0% Lowest Quintile Second Quintile Third Quintile Fourth Quintile Highest Quintile Sources: Statistics Canada (2012). Survey of Household Spending in 2011.

Share of Spectrum in Active Use (Antenna), 2013 Sask. Tel 3% Public. Mobile 1% Mobilicity. MTS Eastlink 1% 1% 1% Videotron 2% Summary of Spectrum Holdings (PCS, AWS & GBRS), 2012 Eastlink 1% Sasktel Others MTS 1% 2% Mobilicity Shaw 1% 2% 2% Videotron Wind 3% 2% WIND 2% Bell 26% Telus 19% Bell 29% Telus 15% Rogers 44% Rogers 41% Sources: Loxcel (data current as of Nov 14, 2013)

Wireless Service Area Map with Number of Cellcos. Sources: CRTC (2012). CMR 2013, p. 168

Cellcos Subscriber Share by Province, 2012 Province Bell Telus Rogers New Entrants Other HHI BC 18 40 39 3 0 3454 AB 23 50 24 3 0 3614 SK 10 10 9 0 71 5322 MB 5 9 33 0 53 4004 ON 28 20 44 6 1 3157 QC 33 28 29 10 0 2814 NB 58 23 19 0 0 4254 NS 54 29 16 0 0 4013 PEI 58 27 15 0 0 4318 NL 73 25 2 0 0 5958 TER 90 0 10 8200 Average 36 26. 1 23 22 62 4090. 8 Source: CRTC Monitoring Report, 2013 Table 5. 5. 5. Average not including Territories.

Share of Spectrum in Active Use (Antenna) In Canada’s Biggest CMAs, 2012 80 70 60 Rogers Percentage 50 Telus Bell 40 Wind Videotron MTS 30 Mobilicity Public. Mobile 20 10 0 Toronto Montreal Vancouver Ottawa Gatineau Calgary Edmonton Quebec Winnipeg Sources: Loxcel (data current as of Nov 14, 2012) Hamilton

Composite Capital Investment in Wireless Infrastructure (based on OECD + BAML GWR) Wireless Japan Slovak Republic Turkey Czech Republic Austria Mexico Italy Belgium Greece Finland Israel Hungary Korea Chile OECD Estonia Norway Luxembourg France New Zealand Australia Germany Denmark Canada Portugal Ireland US Netherlands Sweden Poland UK Spain Switzerland Iceland Slovenia Composite Rank Mobile Capex (OECD) 1 3 4 6 2 7 9 11 10 16 8 12 23 5 20 14 13 15 18 26 17 31 28 27 34 19 30 25 22 21 33 32 35 29 24 Composite Rank (Bo. A) Mobile Capex Composite Mobile Rank (OECD+Bo. A) 3 3 5 6 11 7 7 7 12 6 14 12 2 20 6 14 16 15 13 5 15 1 8 9 4 19 10 16 19 21 11 18 17 29 24 Sources: OECD Investment in cellular mobile infrastructure in the OECD area Table 3. 9; BAML Global Wireless Report 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 9 10 11 12 12 13 14 15 16 17 17 18 18 19 19 20 20 21 22 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

Final Composite Wireline Ranking: Penetration, Speed, Price (34 Countries) Country Korea Denmark Germany Estonia Japan Netherlands Sweden France Iceland Switzerland Belgium Finland United Kingdom Slovak Republic Austria Czech Republic Luxembourg Israel Hungary Norway Portugal Canada United States Slovenia Italy Greece Poland Australia Spain New Zealand Ireland Turkey Chile Mexico Penetration per 100 Population (OECD)1 4 3 9 22 17 2 12 5 7 1 10 14 8 31 19 29 13 20 28 6 26 11 15 23 27 24 30 18 21 16 25 34 32 33 Rank by Actual Rank by Mean Cost Rank by Composite Mean Download of Monthly BB of 6 Price Baskets Speeds (FCC)2 Plans (FCC)2 (OECD)1 Final Wireline Rank 1 2 1 1 6 10 6 2 12 1 8 3 7 3 4 4 5 9 5 4 3 16 18 6 2 4 21 6 18 5 20 8 10 8 24 9 4 34 14 10 8 18 18 11 20 7 13 11 24 14 8 11 15 15 2 14 23 13 10 15 13 11 16 16 9 22 26 17 27 12 12 18 21 20 3 19 16 23 31 20 11 24 17 21 19 26 25 22 14 30 27 23 25 31 7 23 31 6 23 25 30 19 15 26 26 21 11 26 22 28 17 27 33 29 28 29 27 30 29 25 30 31 33 17 29 32 32 33 34 34

Final Composite Wireless Ranking: Penetration, Speed, Price (33 Countries) Country Denmark Finland Sweden Norway Poland Korea Austria Japan Australia United States Luxembourg Slovenia Iceland Czech Republic Germany Slovak Republic Estonia Canada Ireland France Italy Turkey Spain Switzerland Greece New Zealand Portugal United Kingdom Netherlands Hungary Israel Chile Mexico Penetration per 100 Population (OECD)1 5 1 2 8 15 4 18 7 3 6 9 30 12 20 27 28 11 25 14 23 21 32 19 17 24 10 26 13 15 33 22 31 34 Advertised Price: Monthly Download Speed Plan and Cost per (OECD)1 GB of Data (FCC)2 Composite Rank 1 4 1 7 12 2 8 10 2 5 15 4 3 11 5 4 22 6 9 7 7 15 15 8 23 12 9 15 17 9 29 3 11 11 2 12 30 1 12 17 8 14 11 8 15 14 5 16 26 14 17 2 27 18 21 22 19 17 18 20 13 25 21 21 6 21 19 21 21 26 18 24 6 32 25 24 28 25 10 30 27 30 24 28 25 31 29 19 20 30 32 26 31 29 29 32 32 32 33

Final Industry Ranking: Wireless + Wireline, for Penetration, Speed, Price Country Denmark Korea Sweden Japan Finland Germany Estonia Iceland Austria Norway France Luxembourg Czech Republic Slovak Republic Poland United States Switzerland Netherlands Slovenia Australia United Kingdom Canada Italy Portugal Hungary Israel Ireland Spain Greece Turkey New Zealand Chile Mexico Sources: OECD, FCC Final Wireless Rank 1 6 2 8 2 15 17 12 7 4 20 11 14 16 5 9 24 29 12 9 28 18 21 27 30 31 19 21 25 32 33 Final Wireline Rank 2 1 6 4 11 3 4 9 15 20 8 17 16 14 26 23 10 6 23 28 11 22 25 21 19 18 31 29 26 32 30 33 34 Final Top-Level Rank 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 7 9 10 11 11 13 13 15 16 17 13 18 19 21 22 23 24 25 25 27 27 29 30 31 32 33

Average Revenue Per User by Country (OECD), 1998 -2012 800 US Canada Linear (Canada) 700 600 500 United Kingdom Linear (OECD) France 400 Canada 300 United States G 7 200 OECD 100 Linear(Canada) Linear(OECD) 0 1998 1999 2000 Sources: OECD (2013). 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Operating Profits, Rogers, BCE and Telus vs Canadian Industry Average, 1990 -2012 25 BCE 20 Rogers 15 Telus 10 AVG All Industries 5 0 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2011 Sources: Corporate Annual Reports + Statistics Canada Summary Table - Operating profit margin by industries 2012

Bell, Rogers, Telus & Canada EBITA vs OECD + G 7 50% 40% OECD Average G 7 Average Canada 30% G 7 Average OECD Avg Bell Wireless Rogers 20% Telus 10% 0% 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012