Competition Festo Didactic Dolang 1 Competition Argumentation Festo

Competition Festo Didactic Dolang 1

Competition - Argumentation Festo Didactic Dolang Workplace ergonomics, adapt to customer specs More expansion possibilities, Mobile Hydraulics, … World Leading Fluid. SIM® Simulation Software for Pneumatics, Hydraulics and Electronics Measuring/Control system available (via Easy. Port®) Safety: 4 mm Safety plugs/sockets Courseware: State of the art curricula, latest standards (EN 81346 -2) Loading devices/loaded drives Safety features for drives Clean: Dripless flat coupling in hydraulics TP 201/610 measuring and diagnostics Less options to adapt workplace No Mobile Hydraulics, Safety in pneu. Systems, etc. Software capability unkown? Control only via PLC? 4 mm plugs, can be plugged to the power grid as well Courseware status unkown? No load situation, realistic training? No safety features? (no drive housing etc. ) Coupling unknown, might be some leakage? No state of the art measuring system available 2

Competition Festo Didactic Mechatronics International Ltd. 3

Competition - Argumentation Festo Didactic Mechatronics International Ltd. Workplace ergonomics, adapt to customer specs More expansion possibilities, Mobile Hydraulics, … World Leading Fluid. SIM® Simulation Software for Pneumatics, Hydraulics and Electronics Measuring/Control system available (via Easy. Port®) Safety: 4 mm Safety plugs/sockets Courseware: State of the art curricula, latest standards (EN 81346 -2) Loading devices/loaded drives Safety features for drives Fluidics and electronics part separated (ERframe), clearer setups Festo Industrial Automation background More than 30 years of Learning Systems experience, profile plate concept since 1993 Less options to adapt workplace No Mobile Hydraulics, Safety in pneu. Systems, etc. Software capability unkown? Control only via PLC? 4 mm plugs, can be plugged to the power grid as well Courseware standards outdated, (DIN ISO 12192) No load situation, realistic training? No safety features? Fluidics and electronics part on the perforated plate mixed, confusing/dangerous No Industrial background Unkonwn? 4

Competition Festo Didactic Amatrol 5

Competition - Argumentation Festo Didactic Amatrol Modular design: simple start, adapt increase of complexity Workplace ergonomics, adapt to customer specs More expansion possibilities, Mobile Hydraulics, … No Mobile Hydraulics, Safety in pneu. Systems, etc. Festo Industrial Automation background No Industrial background Only animations available No Hardware/Software capabilities World Leading Fluid. SIM® Simulation Software integrated Measuring/Control system available (via Easy. Port®) Safety: 4 mm Safety plugs/sockets Clean: Dripless flat coupling in hydraulics 4 mm plugs, can be plugged to the power grid as well Regular coupling in hydraulics, some leakage Newer courseware: IEC 2015/NEMA will be 2016 ? Fixed design: confusing layout, right at the beginning No workplace variation possible, machine stand 6

Competition Festo Didactic Fluid Power Training Institute MF 102 -H-xxx 7

Competition - Argumentation Festo Didactic Mobile Hydraulics Fluid Power Training Institute MF 102 -H-xxx Modular design: simple start, adapt increase of complexity Workplace ergonomics, adapt to customer specs More expansion possibilities; Pneumatics, … Festo Industrial background Full Fluid. SIM® Simulation Software support, all sample solutions according to courseware available Measuring/Diagnostic system available (via Easy. Port®/Fluid. Lab-M) Real Load-sensing capability (most common in MH) Clean: Dripless flat coupling in hydraulics Newer courseware: IEC 2015/NEMA will be 2016 Hydrostatic Steering system Possibility to create a hydrostatic drive system like circuit Fixed design: confusing layout, right at the beginning No workplace variation possible, machine stand No Pneumatics, etc. No Industrial background No suitable Simulation available Only fault switching capabilities Load-sensing pump, but no LS-valves? ? Coupling unknown, might be some leakage? ? Is there a didactical concept to develop knowledge? No Hydrostatic Steering system No possibility to create a hydrostatic drive system like circuit 8

Competition Festo Didactic SMC International Training 9

Competition - Argumentation Festo Didactic SMC International Training Workplace ergonomics, adapt to customer specs More expansion possibilities, Mobile Hydraulics, … World Leading Fluid. SIM® Simulation Software for Pneumatics, Hydraulics and Electronics Measuring/Control system available (via Easy. Port®) Safety: 4 mm Safety plugs/sockets New courseware: IEC 2015/NEMA will be 2016 Loading devices/loaded drives Safety features for drives Fluidics and electronics part separated (ERframe), clearer setups More than 30 years of Learning Systems experience, profile plate concept since 1993 Less options to adapt workplace No Mobile Hydraulics, Safety in pneu. Systems, etc. auto. SIM-200 pneumatics only? Control only via I/O card? 4 mm plugs, can be plugged to the power grid as well Courseware status unkown? No load situation, realistic training? No safety features? Fluidics and electronics part mixed, confusing/dangerous Me-too, without improvements? 10