Poetry as a Lie Poetry as Truth Poetry

  • Slides: 13
Download presentation
� Poetry as a Lie � Poetry as Truth � Poetry as Prophecy �

� Poetry as a Lie � Poetry as Truth � Poetry as Prophecy � Poetry as Emotion � Poetry as ‘Substance'. � Poetry as Language � Poetry and Sublimity � Poetry as a ‘signboard‘ � Poetry as Dramaturgy � Review Questions

� According to Plato: life is an imitation of the true 'reality' that lies

� According to Plato: life is an imitation of the true 'reality' that lies within man. The poets imitate life in their poetry, thus their work is 'twice removed from reality, ' as such they are liars.

� Aristotle on the other hand sees poetry as 'notation of an action' and

� Aristotle on the other hand sees poetry as 'notation of an action' and a 'truth higher than history. ' According to him, while history deals with particular facts, poetry deals with the universal and is capable of a higher philosophical value than history.

� T. S Eliot furthering this argument observes that a large part of any

� T. S Eliot furthering this argument observes that a large part of any poet's inspiration must come from his reading and knowledge of history, and his acquaintance with his past yet the fact remains “Unlike the historian, (poetry) uses not only actual happenings as motif but also creates situations and influences by his work the course of events. In the process, he is sometimes prophetic. ”

� The Romantic poet, William Wordsworth, observed that “poetry is that spontaneous overflow of

� The Romantic poet, William Wordsworth, observed that “poetry is that spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings which takes its origin from emotion recollected in tranquility. ”

� John Stuart Mills extends this definition to note that poetry is “the delineation

� John Stuart Mills extends this definition to note that poetry is “the delineation of the deeper and more secret working of human emotion. 'It is feeling confessing itself to itself in moments of solitude and embodying itself in symbols which are nearest possible representative actions of the feeling in the exact shape in which it exists in the poet's mind. '

� Edmund Burke says that 'poetry is the art of substantiating shadows, and lending

� Edmund Burke says that 'poetry is the art of substantiating shadows, and lending existence to nothing. � This idea stems from the ability of the poet to lend expression and make real 'nebulous' feelings that have been lurking in the fringes of the mind.

� According to Romanus Egudu 'poetry is a method of expression by suggestion through

� According to Romanus Egudu 'poetry is a method of expression by suggestion through invented or created imagery, beat or rhythm and sound. ' � Alexander Pope sees poetry as 'what oft was thought, but never so well exprest' (which means that no language can capture exactly that which is in the poet’s mind). � A. E Housman insists that 'poetry is not the thing said but a way of saying it. '

� According to Bailey, 'poetry is itself a thing of God. . . and

� According to Bailey, 'poetry is itself a thing of God. . . and the more we think of poetry, the more we do become like God, in love and power. ” � Senanu and Vincent also note that the poet seeks to communicate his vision. Its full impact is realised in our experience of the poem as a whole through our understanding of the techniques that the poet uses to create this sense of identification and universalisation. 3

W. H Auden, perceives poetry as something immortal: For poetry makes nothing happen. .

W. H Auden, perceives poetry as something immortal: For poetry makes nothing happen. . . » it survives In the valley of its saying where executives Would never want to tamper; it flows south From ranches of isolation and the busy griefs Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives, A way of happening, a mouth ('In Memory of W. B Yeats”)

� Simply put poetry makes a comment upon the world and involves 'truths' that

� Simply put poetry makes a comment upon the world and involves 'truths' that the poet has discovered about all human nature. Although poetry often makes use of abstract concepts, poems are incorrigibly concrete. By this we mean that poetry is concerned with man and life. � As Ebenezer Eliot puts it, poetry is “'impassioned truth, man's thoughts tinged by his feelings. ' � Oscar Wilde observes in 'the Truth of Masks': 'Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask and he will tell you the truth. '

 • What in your own view is the reason for the various definitions

• What in your own view is the reason for the various definitions of poetry? • How does Plato's reception of poets differ from that of other literary scholars? • Compare and contrast Wordsworth's definition of poetry with that of Burke. Use poems to illustrate your answers.

Thank You

Thank You