Vanderbilt Rutherford Hospital Williamson Medical Centers Opposition to
Vanderbilt Rutherford Hospital Williamson Medical Center’s Opposition to CON Application No. CN 2004 -012 www. bakerdonelson. com
FINANCIAL DATA FROM JARs FOR RESPECTIVE YEARS: Profit/(Loss) for Rural Hospitals in VRH Service Area 2018 2017 2016 Bedford County ($8, 122, 341) ($5, 778, 101) ($4, 388, 783) Cannon County ($2, 737, 367) ($2, 820, 099) ($1, 481, 406) Warren County ($3, 012, 668) $836, 553 $652, 902 www. bakerdonelson. com © 2020 Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 2
Licensed bed occupancy rates at all six service area hospitals declined from 2017 to 2018, and three service area hospitals had lower occupancy rates in 2018 than in 2016. Three service area hospitals had 2018 occupancy rates of 26% or lower, and another occupancy rate was only 46% in 2018. www. bakerdonelson. com © 2020 Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 3
Vanderbilt Rutherford Site’s Distance from Nearby Hospitals* Distance Drive Time St. Thomas Rutherford Main Campus 6. 2 miles 10 minutes Stonecrest Medical Center 12 miles 13 minutes Williamson Medical Center 20. 8 miles 24 minutes *Data from Map. Quest; address used for VRH site (currently unaddressed) was 1307 West. Lawn Boulevard, the address of the Annandale Apartments, which are across Veterans Parkway from the Vanderbilt Rutherford Hospital site. The Vanderbilt Rutherford Hospital site plan shows that it will have a campus entrance driveway directly across Veterans Parkway from its intersection with West. Lawn Boulevard. www. bakerdonelson. com © 2020 Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 4
From page 30 of the St. Thomas Rutherford satellite hospital CON application. The area in orange is within a 12 minute drive from the proposed St. Thomas Rutherford satellite hospital. The Williamson County line is the heavy dark blue line east of Highway 31 A. Williamson Medical Center is located just east of I-65 and west of Carothers Parkway, near where the 37067 zip code boundary ends its overlay on I-65. www. bakerdonelson. com © 2020 Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 5
The dark, vertical, uneven line through the middle of the above map is the county line between Williamson (on the left) and Rutherford (on the right) Counties. www. bakerdonelson. com © 2020 Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 6
Aerial view of Veteran’s Parkway/I-840 intersection; the VRH site is at the right of Veteran’s Parkway, as it approaches I-840 from the south. St. Thomas Rutherford’s proposed satellite hospital site is at the bottom right of the picture, left of Veteran’s Parkway as it approaches the last intersection at the bottom right of the image. www. bakerdonelson. com © 2020 Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC 7
- Slides: 7