TS0022 Objection for Ratification Group Name Architecture and
TS-0022 Objection for Ratification Group Name: Architecture and Protocols Source: Timothy Carey, Nokia, Meeting Date: TP 24. 1
Summary • Nokia objects to the ratification of TS-0022 in its current state because of the following issues with the TS. – The scenarios for device configuration cannot be achieved using solutions stated in TS 0022 without additional support from other TSs • • • DM scenario – needs updates for mgmt. Obj in TS-0005, TS-0006 In band scenario – lacks solution for security (TS-0003) Interworking proxy – lacks solution for the IPE (TS-xxxx) – TS-0022 introduces a new element called AE configurator which needs to be add to TS 0001 along with its constraints and implications on the CSFs. – TS-0022 uses normative language in a non-normative context – TS-0022 has a many grammatical errors © 2016 one. M 2 M Partners TP-2016 -0246 2
TS-0022 Architecture Needs integration in TS-0001 Needs mappings in TS-0005, TS-0006 Needs security onboarding – TS-0003 Needs IPE specification– TS-xxxx © 2016 one. M 2 M Partners TP-2016 -0246 3
Normative Language and Grammar • The specification gives me great concern in terms of readability/grammar and use of normative language in non-normative contexts. • For one of many, many examples in the document: Clause 5. 2. 1 Introduction: “ The specialized AE which is named ‘Configurator AE’, may takes a role of responsible to configure device in field domain. The setting information shall be set on specializations of one. M 2 M <mgmt. Obj> resource by the Configurator AE, and the data is reflected to the Field Device. ” © 2016 one. M 2 M Partners TP-2016 -0246 4
- Slides: 4