Three mysteries Inflation Dark Energy Dark Matter String

  • Slides: 37
Download presentation

Three mysteries: Inflation, Dark Energy & Dark Matter String Theory? The Cosmic Uroboros by

Three mysteries: Inflation, Dark Energy & Dark Matter String Theory? The Cosmic Uroboros by Sheldon Glashow

String theory until 2002 Bad thing • No 4 -dimensional de Sitter solution with

String theory until 2002 Bad thing • No 4 -dimensional de Sitter solution with stabilized moduli. • No-go theorem! • Contradict with inflation and dark energy? • No way to reconcile with cosmology? ? ? Three mysteries: Inflation, Dark Energy & Dark Matter String Theory? ? The Cosmic Uroboros does not close?

Recent Progress • In 2003, a 4 -dimensional de Sitter solution was finally found!

Recent Progress • In 2003, a 4 -dimensional de Sitter solution was finally found! Kachru, Kallosh, Linde and Trivedi (KKLT) • In the previous no-go theorem, non-perturbative effects and branes were not taken into account. d. S 4 D Ad. S 6 D Volume stabilization (KKLT) Compactification (GPK) Fluxes NS-NS R-R Warped throat (KS) Anti-D-branes (KKLT)

3 models of stringy brane inflation • Wrapped DBI inflation ar. Xiv: 0708. 4285

3 models of stringy brane inflation • Wrapped DBI inflation ar. Xiv: 0708. 4285 [hep-th] with T. Kobayashi and S. Kinoshita • Conformal rapid-roll inflation ar. Xiv: 0709. 1952 [hep-th] with L. Kofman • Chaotic brane inflation work in progress with L. Kofman

Conformal Rapid-roll Inflation ar. Xiv: 0709. 1952 [hep-th] with L. Kofman

Conformal Rapid-roll Inflation ar. Xiv: 0709. 1952 [hep-th] with L. Kofman

The KKLMMT model Kachru, Kallosh, Linde, Maldacena, Mc. Allister, and Trivedi 2003 = brane

The KKLMMT model Kachru, Kallosh, Linde, Maldacena, Mc. Allister, and Trivedi 2003 = brane inflation (Dvali&Tye 1998) in KKLT D 3 anti-D 3 The inflaton gets the mass inflaton However, inflation with almost scale-invariant spectrum of perturbations requires This can be achieved by considering f-dependent W and fine-tuning it.

KKLMMT fine-tuning • mf 2 = 2 H 2 would stop inflation. • This

KKLMMT fine-tuning • mf 2 = 2 H 2 would stop inflation. • This is due to the conformal coupling -Rf 2/12. • However, people have not yet looked at modification of Einstein equation. • We should take it into account! [Kofman&Mukohyama 2007]

Scalar field with non-minimal coupling to curvature Looks like an additional mass term… Actually,

Scalar field with non-minimal coupling to curvature Looks like an additional mass term… Actually, there are more terms!

Inflation without the KKLMMT fine-tuning! Note that this is NOT a slow roll! RAPID

Inflation without the KKLMMT fine-tuning! Note that this is NOT a slow roll! RAPID ROLL INFLATION!!!

Attractor behavior de Sitter attractor !!!

Attractor behavior de Sitter attractor !!!

Inflation with V(f) Starting with: (3) (1) (2) Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (3’)

Inflation with V(f) Starting with: (3) (1) (2) Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (3’)

Consistency condition I Starting with: (1) Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (1) to (1’) (3’)

Consistency condition I Starting with: (1) Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (1) to (1’) (3’)

Consistency condition II Starting with: (2) Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (2) to (2’) (3’)

Consistency condition II Starting with: (2) Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (2) to (2’) (3’)

Consistency condition III Starting with: Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (3) to (3’)

Consistency condition III Starting with: Goal: (1’) (2’) Definitions: (3) to (3’)

Condition for inflation with conformal coupling • Usual slow roll condition + additional conditions

Condition for inflation with conformal coupling • Usual slow roll condition + additional conditions • The 3 rd condition is not satisfied by powerlaw potentials. • The D/anti-D potential satisfies it!

Chaotic Brane Inflation Work in progress with L. Kofman

Chaotic Brane Inflation Work in progress with L. Kofman

Chaotic Inflation driven by brane motion in progress, with L. Kofman • Large motion

Chaotic Inflation driven by brane motion in progress, with L. Kofman • Large motion of anti-D 3 -brane • In 4 D, V~lf 4 6 D space 4 D universe Anti-D 3 -brane Distance to = Inflaton the bottom

Phase portrait for an anti-D 3 -brane without non-rel. approximation Chaotic Inflation!

Phase portrait for an anti-D 3 -brane without non-rel. approximation Chaotic Inflation!

Length of the throat • Can we have ? • For stack of anti-D

Length of the throat • Can we have ? • For stack of anti-D 3 s, the answer is NO. • Better for stack of wrapped D 5 s and D 7 s.

String theorists & Cosmologists must talk to each other! The Cosmic Uroboros by Sheldon

String theorists & Cosmologists must talk to each other! The Cosmic Uroboros by Sheldon Glashow

Wrapped DBI inflation ar. Xiv: 0708. 4285 [hep-th] with T. Kobayashi and S. Kinoshita

Wrapped DBI inflation ar. Xiv: 0708. 4285 [hep-th] with T. Kobayashi and S. Kinoshita

The KKLMMT model Kachru, Kallosh, Linde, Maldacena, Mc. Allister, and Trivedi 2003 = brane

The KKLMMT model Kachru, Kallosh, Linde, Maldacena, Mc. Allister, and Trivedi 2003 = brane inflation (Dvali&Tye 1998) in KKLT D 3 anti-D 3 The inflaton gets the mass inflaton However, inflation with almost scale-invariant spectrum of perturbations requires This can be achieved by considering f-dependent W and fine-tuning it.

KKLMMT fine-tuning • mf 2 = 2 H 2 would stop inflation. • This

KKLMMT fine-tuning • mf 2 = 2 H 2 would stop inflation. • This is based on dynamics of a scalar with canonical kinetic term. • However, the brane position is described by nonlinear DBI kinetic action. • We should take it into account! [Silberstein&Tong 2003]

DBI inflation: model description • Mobile D 3 -brane with relativistic speed • Action

DBI inflation: model description • Mobile D 3 -brane with relativistic speed • Action DBI part r : radial position of the brane • Energy density & Pressure

DBI inflation: good things • A kind of k-inflation with general sound speed: a

DBI inflation: good things • A kind of k-inflation with general sound speed: a new model of stringy inflation! • No need for slow-roll: a remedy to the η problem (KKLMMT finetuning)? • Large non-Gaussianity: signature of stringy inflation?

DBI inflation: bad thing Baumann&Mcllister 2006; Lidsey&Huston 2007 • (UV) DBI inflation with large

DBI inflation: bad thing Baumann&Mcllister 2006; Lidsey&Huston 2007 • (UV) DBI inflation with large non-Gaussianity seems inconsistent with WMAP data. • Can be consistent only in the limit when it goes back to the slow-roll KKLMMT inflation. • The reason: large but not too large |f. NL| (say, 20<|f. NL|<300) large r large Df/MPl i) large Df long throat large V 6 ii) not large MPl not large V 6 confliction

Useful equations to derive constraints

Useful equations to derive constraints

Our attempt: wrapped DBI Kobayashi, Mukohyama and Kinoshita 2007 • The essential reason for

Our attempt: wrapped DBI Kobayashi, Mukohyama and Kinoshita 2007 • The essential reason for the inconsistency of DBI inflation with WMAP data: large Df long throat • For D 3, this is inevitable: • For a wrapped D 5 or D 7, we can get larger Df from the same throat! large volume of 2 - or 4 -cycle • This significantly ameliorates the confliction!

More stringent bound on wrapped DBI inflation • Wrapped DBI inflation with large non.

More stringent bound on wrapped DBI inflation • Wrapped DBI inflation with large non. Gaussianity still requires a long throat. (Not as long as for D 3 but still long. ) • Known Calabi-Yau manifold cannot sustain such a long throat, (let alone for D 3). long throat large background charge large Euler number of CY, exceeding the known maximal value c = 1820448 [Klemm, Lian, Roan&Yau 1997]

Summary of wrapped DBI inflation • Wrapping D 5 or D 7 over a

Summary of wrapped DBI inflation • Wrapping D 5 or D 7 over a cycle changes the relation between the brane position and the inflaton field. • This significantly ameliorates the confliction between (UV) DBI inflation and WMAP data. • However, successful wrapped (UV) DBI inflation requires Euler number larger than the known maximal value.

e-foldings & mass hierarchy • e-foldings: a f ~ const. N ~ ln (

e-foldings & mass hierarchy • e-foldings: a f ~ const. N ~ ln ( fi / fe ) • Mass hierarchy a la Randall-Sundrum : M / Mpl ~ e-N • Enough inflation vs Te. V gravity: N ~ 62 + ln ( M / 1016 Ge. V ) M ~ Te. V These conditions are equivalent!

Summary of conformal rapid-roll inflation • Conformal coupling does NOT necessarily spoil inflation. •

Summary of conformal rapid-roll inflation • Conformal coupling does NOT necessarily spoil inflation. • Brane / anti-brane inflation may work without severe fine-tuning. • E-foldings & mass hierarchy are related. • Modulated reheating can generate scaleinvariant density perturbation.

Summary of this talk • It seems that we can really enjoy cosmology in

Summary of this talk • It seems that we can really enjoy cosmology in the framework of string theory. • Model I: Wrapping D 5 or D 7 over a cycle ameliorates the confliction between the DBI inflation and WMAP data. However, a successful DBI inflation requires large Euler number of CY manifold. • Model II: Conformal rapid-roll inflation is possible without the KKLLMT fine-tuning. The mass hierarchy and e-foldings are related! • Model III: Chaotic brane inflation may be possible with wrapped D 7.