The ecology of the deathwatch beetle Xestobium rufovillosum
The ecology of the deathwatch beetle, Xestobium rufovillosum de Geer Dr Steven R. Belmain Natural Resources Institute, University of Greenwich, Central Avenue, Chatham Maritime, ME 4 4 TB, United Kingdom T: +44 1624 883761; F: +44 1634 883379; E: S. R. Belmain@gre. ac. uk
Socio-economic tools for rodent management research: Recent experience from Africa and Asia Dr Steven R. Belmain and colleagues Natural Resources Institute, University of Greenwich, Central Avenue, Chatham Maritime, ME 4 4 TB, United Kingdom T: +44 1624 883761; F: +44 1634 883379; E: S. R. Belmain@gre. ac. uk
The black box of social science
Philosophy Mathematical proof Deductive reasoning Statistics Empiricism
Increasing complexity Physics Chemistry Biology Economics Sociology Political Science Psychology Geography Archaeology Sociobiology History Linguistics Biological Anthropology
Rodent Management will not work unless the Managers adequately understand the problem and its solutions in sufficient detail. Tools and knowledge need to be appropriate
Rodent Managers Qualified personnel – service providers Pest Control Operators Environmental Health Officers Agriculture Extensionists Everyone else – rural / urban settlements Farmers Households Communities
Understanding the Manager
Tools that we can use to understand the Rodent Manager Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Survey Community meetings
Tools that we can use to understand the Rodent Manager Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Survey Community meetings Resource mapping / survey
Tools that we can use to understand the Rodent Manager Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Survey Community meetings Resource mapping / survey Individual meetings / questionnaires
Tools that we can use to understand the Rodent Manager Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Survey Community meetings Resource mapping / survey Individual meetings / questionnaires Observation
Tools that we can use to understand the Rodent Manager Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Survey Community meetings Resource mapping / survey Individual meetings / questionnaires Observation It’s all about asking the right questions and interpreting the answers
Designing your survey Culture Gender Education Language Consultation Pre-testing Experience
Synthesising the data Decision trees, Flow charts, Matrices, Problemcause diagrams, Bayesian belief networks Taken from: Aplin, K. A. , Brown, P. R. , Jacob, J. , Krebs, C. J. and Grant R. Singleton (2003). Field methods for rodent studies in Asia and the Indo-Pacific. ACIAR Monograph 100; ACIAR, Canberra, AU. 223 pp.
Are there generalisations we can make about Rodent Managers? • • People like to see dead bodies Poison should act fast Underestimation of the damage caused Limited microbiological knowledge Anthropomorphism “Trap shy dogma” The technology gap
Just a bunch of surveys?
Participation of the Rodent Managers in their own KAP assessment
Farmer Diaries • Five farmers in a group • Male and female groups • Six groups in a village • Four villages • Group leaders to manage • Meeting once a week • NGO staff to oversee process
Farmer Diaries Recording information on time and money spent related to rodent damage, repairs and rodent management activities
No intervention { { Intervention
No intervention { { Intervention
Households in Jakunipara (intervention village) involved in recording various repair activities within a farmer diary. Activities coincided with the commencement of village-wide intensive trapping of rodents
Households in the village of Anandapur (non-intervention village) involved in recording various repair activities within a farmer diary
No intervention { { Intervention
No intervention { { Intervention
Tracking tiles as a socio-economic tool
Tracking tiles as a socioeconomic tool
Tracking tiles as a socioeconomic tool Rodents are too clever to be controlled and become trap shy / poison shy • Allows easy understanding of changes in rodent population dynamics • Reduces need for dead bodies • Efficacy of chronic poisons observed • Encourages monitoring & evaluation
Yes “New” management technology can • Inform the research process • Educate rodent managers • Change human behaviour
Future challenges for the social sciences in rodent management research
Human behaviour and disease Damage remains hidden, impact on people’s lives is unclear, economic cost is unknown Disease mechanisms and transmission Social stigmas and family decision making processes – late treatment Self-medication with inappropriate treatments Community cohesion levels - acceptance, apathy, dependence Social conservatism – traditional treatments and behaviour
Witchcraft and traditional medicine • Belief in witchcraft, and that illnesses are derived from bad luck, spells and curses is widespread throughout many countries • Traditional healers can have supernatural powers (for good and bad) through spells and potions that go beyond their administering of herbal remedies to the sick. • Rats are implicated in the spread of witchcraft in many cultures. Because rats are fast, they are believed to be used to bewitch others and make them ill - as a vessel of the curse sent by the witch.
Rats, Hygiene and Sanitation Concepts and socio-economics of disease Traditional beliefs of hygiene can vary among cultures and differ from modern scientific views, e. g. internal dirt, not external dirt Emphasis on tidiness rather than removal of environmental dirt Among young hygiene may relate to keeping one’s body clean and among older people to keeping a tidy kitchen Food and water borne diseases – e. g. river water always clean, wild animals are clean
Thanks to all my collaborators and Thank You for listening
- Slides: 50