Summer Seminar Copyright in motion Facult Jean Monnet

Summer Seminar, Copyright in motion Faculté Jean Monnet, 9 -13 juillet 2012 Alexandra BENSAMOUN, Associate Professor, Faculté Jean Monnet (UPS), CERDI

Bienvenus ! Welcome ! Cerdi Seminar : introduction, panellists' contributions, exchanges

Europe : directive « enforcement » USA : PIPA, SOPA World : ACTA Products : music, video, luxury goods, fashion, food, medicinal products, cosmetics, toys, electric equipments…

Change of targets : Not only the counterfeiters, but also : - Some software publishers, - ISP - Internet subscriber Evolution of normative instruments : - Always law, but also : - MOU - Proposals of institutions, even citizens

I/ Normative policy and content : the targets of fight against internet couterfeiting II/ Normative policy and form : the sources of fight against internet couterfeiting

Classic way Always possible : CA Aix-en-Provence, 10 janv. 2012

See Grokster and Kazaa – economic model • Criminal part : inducement to infringe Art. L. 335 -2 -1 IPC : up to three-year imprisonment and a fine of € 300. 000 • Civil part : misuse of the software, power of the president of the court order all the measures required to guarantee copyright Art. L. 336 -1 IPC

3 directions : Ø Liability (directive « e-commerce » , French law « LCEN » ) Hosting provider Ø Incentive to cooperate : Mo. U, UGC Principles, French « Chartes » Ø Filtering measures (art. L. 336 -2 IPC and 6 -I-8 LCEN – CJUE, Scarlet, Netlog – Google Suggest ? )

« Graduated response » and HADOPI : email, registred letter, suspension of Internet access Power of the judge

Progress, for example : punitive damages (art. L. 331 -1 -3 IPC) But insufficient And European authorities don’t want to reform liability of ISP (directive « e-commerce » )

Mo. U, UGC Principles, French « chartes » Ex. : The Mo. U « is not legally binding and does not now nor in the future create any contractual or pre-contractual obligations under any law or legal system. Nothing in this Mo. U shall be construed as creating any liability, rights, waiver of any rights or obligations for any parties or as releasing any parties from their legal obligations. This Mo. U shall not be construed in any way as replacing or interpreting the existing legal framework. This Mo. U is not to be used as, or form part of, evidence in any legal proceedings » . Normative force ? Ø Moral engagement ? Ø Model/standard for the judge ?

France : Conseil National du Numérique, Labs (HADOPI), Conseil supérieur de la propriété littéraire et artistique EU : public consultations, instrumentalization participatory democracy. Risk of

Thanks for attention ! Summer seminar, CERDI, Copyright in motion Policies of fight against internet counterfeiting Alexandra Bensamoun, Associate Professor alexandra. bensamoun@u-psud. fr