Session 55 802 16 Relay TG Closing Remarks

Session #55 802. 16 Relay TG Closing Remarks IEEE 802. 16 Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE 802. 16 j-08/008 Date Submitted: 2008 -05 -15 Source: Mitsuo Nohara Relay TG Chair, KDDI R&D Labs. 3 -10 -10, Iidabashi, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 102 -8460 Japan *<http: //standards. ieee. org/faqs/affiliation. FAQ. html> Venue: IEEE 802. 16 Session #55, Macau, China Base Contribution: None Purpose: TG Meeting organization Notice: Voice: E-mail: +81 3 6678 6128 mi-nohara@kddilabs. jp This document does not represent the agreed views of the IEEE 802. 16 Working Group or any of its subgroups. It represents only the views of the participants listed in the “Source(s)” field above. It is offered as a basis for discussion. It is not binding on the contributor(s), who reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein. Release: The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications thereof, in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication; to copyright in the IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 802. 16. Patent Policy: The contributor is familiar with the IEEE-SA Patent Policy and Procedures: <http: //standards. ieee. org/guides/bylaws/sect 6 -7. html#6> and <http: //standards. ieee. org/guides/opman/sect 6. html#6. 3>. Further information is located at <http: //standards. ieee. org/board/pat-material. html> and <http: //standards. ieee. org/board/pat >. ２

Session #55 802. 16 Relay TG Closing Remarks and Session Summary 13 th Task Group Meeting on Multi-hop Relay in IEEE 802. 16 Relay TG Chair Mitsuo Nohara Vice Chair Peiying Zhu Technical Editor/Secretary Jung Je Son Technical Editor Mike Hart IEEE 802. 16 Relay TG Meeting 12 -15 May, 2008, Macau, China 2

WG Letter Ballot #28 c Result • WG Letter Ballot #28 c on Draft, IEEE P 802. 16 j/D 4 • 248 Approve (248/(248+32)=0. 89 • 32 Disapprove • 21 Abstain • 301 in total (301/350=0. 86) http: //ieee 802. org/16/ballots/ballot 28/ • WG Letter Ballot #28 c on Draft, IEEE P 802. 16 j/D 4 ( http: //ieee 802. org/16/ballots/ballot 28/ ) <- Changes* not reflected to the list • 248+3 Approve (251/(251+28)=0. 90) • 28 (32 -4) Disapprove • 22 (21+1) Abstain • 301 in total out of 336 (301/336=0. 90) *Changes: John Humbert (D->Abs), Phillip Barber, Cai Sean and Jerry Chou (D->A), Thank you!

Comment Resolution Done • WG Letter Ballot #28 c on Draft, IEEE P 802. 16 j/D 4 • 225 Comments submitted • Comment Resolutions • 225 Resolved in Meeting #55 • Results in 802. 16 -08/023 r 2 All Comments resolved 109 48 27 31 10 225 Accepted (10 dis. ) Accept-Modified (10 dis. ) Rejected (8 dis. ) Superceded (4 dis. ) Withdrawn (1 dis. ) Total (33 dis. )

Motions done at Relay TG Opening 1. To approve the meeting agenda, j 08/007 r 1 1. 1 st : Wen Tong, 2 nd: Jeffrey Tao , at 16: 43 result: passed with no objection. 2. To approve Session #54 802. 16 Relay TG Minutes (IEEE 802. 16 j-08/006 r 1) 1. 1 st: Gamini Senarath, 2 nd: Kanchei Loa, at 16: 50 result: passed with no objection. 5

Agenda by Calendar 1. Mon PM & Evening (16: 00 -19: 30) • Opening, agenda and minutes review • Summary of WG Letter Ballot and inputs to meeting • Process for expediting resolutions • Process towards Sponsor Ballot Preparation • Start technical comment resolution 2. Tue (08: 00 -10: 00) • Joint Session with TGm 3. Tue (10: 00 -17: 00) • Batch resolution preparation on Editorial comments • Comment resolution 4. Wed (08: 00 -18: 30) • Comment Resolution 5. Thu (08: 00 -18: 30) • Comment resolution • Batch resolution of Editorial comments • Closing

Disapprove voters with no comments in any ballot stage (progress from #54) • Following people have voted disapprove with no comments across LB 28, LB 28 a & LB 28 b: • • Michael Erlihson John Humbert Thomas Li John Norin Sumeet Sandhu Yingzhe Wu Rongzhen Yang Changed to Approve, Thank you! Changed to Abstain, Thank you! Email address obsolete Couldn’t reach Changed to Approve, Thank you! No Reply. Expecting to hear at Closing Changed to approve Name not found on the member list Changed to Approve, Thank you!

Unsatisfied commenters in LB 28 DB • Following people have voted disapprove (in LB 28) and have unsatisfied comments in 802. 16 -07/045 r 5 • Ahn Dong Hyun • Barber Phillip • Boariu Adrian • Cai Sean • Chae Suchang • Chion Hua (Mary) • Choi In-Kyeong • Chow Jerry • Colban Erik • Comstock David • Feng Shulan • Hart Mike • Hu Teck • Huang Cancan • Jeong Moo Ryong • Kang Hyunjeong • Lee Seung Joon • Lin Tzu-Ming • Lin Zhibin • Lu Jianmin • Maggi Giovanni • Mao Ronald • Olszewski Kim • Piggin Paul • Popoli Robert • Qian Nanjian (Jeff) • Qu Hongyun • Senarath Gamini • Song Young Seog • Stanwood Kenneth • Taori Rakesh • Wang Lei • Wang Yanhong • Wu Xuyong • Xie Cheng Jie • Xu Ling • Yang Yunsong • Zhou Yuefeng Changed to approve Cmts file submitted Name not found on the member list

Unsatisfied commenters in LB 28 a DB • Following people have voted disapprove (in LB 28 a) and have unsatisfied comments in 802. 16 -08/002 r 3 • Boariu Adrian • Cai Sean • Chae Suchang • Chion Hua (Mary) • Chow Jerry • Comstock David • Feng Shulan • Huang Cancan • Hui Junhong • Kang Hyunjeong Changed to approve Cmts file submitted • Lin Tzu-Ming • Madihian Mohammad • Olszewski Kim • Qian Nanjian (Jeff) • Qu Hongyun • Senarath Gamini • Tao Jeffrey • Taori Rakesh • Xu Ling • Zhou Yuefeng

Unsatisfied commenters in LB 28 b DB • Following people have voted disapprove (in LB 28 b) and have unsatisfied comments in 802. 16 -08/013 r 3. • Branlund Dale • Senarath Gamini • Xu Ling Changed to approve Cmts file submitted

Way Forward 1. One more WG Letter Ballot 28 d by the next session, targeting the EC approval for Sponsor Ballot then, 2. In parallel, to organize the ad-hoc to review the latest Rev. 2 draft and assess the revisions to come, preparing for further alignment with it. An ad-hoc team to be organized for it. The chair: Gamini Senarath The members are: Hyun Jeong Kang, Jeffrey Tao, Chenxi Zhu, Wei Peng, Yousuf Saifullah, Kanchei Loa Mike Hart, Peiying Zhu, Jung Je Son, Mitsuo Nohara. 11

Motions at Relay TG Closing 1. To authorize the Technical Editors to revise the draft (P 802. 16 j/D 4) to accommodate the comment resolutions in 802. 16 -08/023 r 2. 1. 1 st: Wen Tong, 2 nd: Kanchei Loa at 18: 43 2. Motion passed: 18/0/0 2. To authorize the TG Chair to request the working group approve P 802. 16 j/D 5 as revised draft and to proceed to the 5 th letter ballot recirculation. 3. 1 st: Young Bin Chang, 2 nd: Gamini Senarath, at 18: 45 4. Motion passed: 19/0/0 3. To organize an ad-hoc group to review the latest Rev. 2 draft and assess the revisions to come, preparing for further alignment with it. 4. Chair: Gamini Senarath, Members are: Hyun Jeong Kang, Jeffrey Tao, Chenxi Zhu, Wei Peng, Yousuf Saifullah, Kanchei Loa Mike Hart, Peiying Zhu, Jung Je Son, and Mitsuo Nohara. 5. 1 st: Tzu Ming Lin, 2 nd: Kanchei Loa, at 18: 47 Motion passed: 22/0/0 12

Motion at 802. 16 WG Closing 1. To approve P 802. 16 j/D 5 (to be issued by the Relay TG Editors) as the revised working group draft and to authorize the WG Chair to proceed to the 5 th letter ballot recirculation on p 802. 16 j/D 5 to close about 11 July, 2008 AOE. 1. 1 st: , 2 nd: , at 2. Motion : nn/nn/nn 13

Relay-TG Meeting Calendar This Week 16: 00 -19: 30, Mon. 12 May (Eve. Session Scheduled)*1 08: 00 -10: 00, Tue. 13 Mar. joint with TGm*2 10: 00 -12; 00/13: 00 -*, Tue. 13 May (Eve. TBD) *3 08: 00 -12: 00/13: 00 -18: 00, Wed. 14 May *3 08: 00 -12: 00/13: 00 -18: 00, Thu. 15 May*3 held at: *1: Rm 1001&1101, *2: Rm Ball Room D, E, F *3: Rm 2005, 2006, 2105, 2106 The Venetian, Macau, China 多謝、再見！ *Reference: C 802. 16 -005/013