Scottish Universities Physics Alliance SUPA the Evolving Vision

Scottish Universities Physics Alliance SUPA – the Evolving Vision April 2012 Prof Jim Hough Chief Executive

In the beginning Scottish Universities Physics Alliance SUPA I Scottish Universities Physics Alliance: (Scottish Universities Physics Alliance) A Partnership for Excellence • SUPA l will • pool and enhance Scotland's strongest physics research to develop international leadership • provide a magnet for researchers and sponsors worldwide

SUPA I Scottish Universities Physics Alliance SUPA l – funded for a start in 2005 £ 14. 1 M (58% from Scottish Higher Education Funding Council) ending 2010 then extended to 2011 SUPA l – 6 Universities: Edinbugh, Glasgow, Heriot-Watt, St Andrews, Strathclyde, University of West of Scotland 5 funded themes + Graduate School • Astronomy and Space • Condensed Matter and Materials Physics • Nuclear and Plasma Physics • Particle Physics • Photonics • Plus subtheme of PP and Astro – TEOPS (Technology for Experimental and Observational Physics in Scotland) which involved the Astronomy Technology Centre in Edinburgh.

Vision of SUPA Scottish Universities Physics Alliance Aim: SUPA 1 will place Scotland at the forefront of research in physics in the UK 2008 UK Research Assessment Exercise • Three departments in Scotland were ranked 7 th equal or better (out of 42), led by St Andrews standing at equal 2 nd with Cambridge and Nottingham, • Edinburgh 6 th and Glasgow equal 7 th. • Heriot-Watt Physics improved significantly, rising to equal 15 th place, on a par with Oxford and Southampton. • Collectively, SUPA has more high quality activity than Cambridge.

SUPA II Scottish Universities Physics Alliance SUPA ll – funded to start winter 2009 £ 48 M (33% from Scottish Funding Council), for 7 years, so overlap with SUPA l. I – Two More Universities: Aberdeen and Dundee • extra themes • Physics and Life Sciences (Pa. LS) • Energy • Plus extension of TEOPS subtheme, renamed SPARK (Scottish Physics and Astronomy for Research and Knowledge exchange) More investment in people overall but particularly in • Pa. LS and • Nuclear (SCAPA: The Scottish Centre for the Application of Plasma-based Accelerators)

Current SUPA network Scottish Universities Physics Alliance

Now SUPA 11 - VISION Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • Strong International Profile • Recognised Research Excellence As determined by – REF performance – grant income – international collaborations • Long term sustainability

Progress to date 1 Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • Currently we have – > £ 150 M research grant portfolio – approx. 60 prestigious appointments/fellowships including • 8 Leadership professorial appointments made across themes and schools (4 in Pa. LS, 2 in condensed matter and 2 in Photonics) • 2 leadership professorial positions in Nuclear/Plasma Physics theme offered • 7 holders of ERC awards, • 14 RS/RAE Fellowships etc – 5 new Wolfson Merit Awards – 8 new electees to the RSE – 1 Royal Society Professor

Publications in SUPA II to date Scottish Universities Physics Alliance Astro CMMP En’rgy N/PP Pa. LS Phot. P’rticle 697 447 81 268 232 383 374

Progress to date 2 Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • Prizes include – – 2011 Charles H Townes award holder (Sibbett) 2011 Royal Medal of the RSE (Smith) 2011 Occhialini Medal holder (Oppo, Strathclyde), 2011 Io. P Particle Physics Group Prize (Davies, Glasgow), – 2012 Edinburgh Award (Higgs) – 2012 RAS Gold Medal (Brown) • JUNO Champion Status for Glasgow.

Themes Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • All 7 themes (Astro, CMMP, Energy, Nuclear/Plasma, Particle, Pa. LS and Photonics) are progressing well with clearly laid out strategies for their future development – Strategies will be discussed later by theme leaders or representative • Graduate School has ever increasing number of applications for prize studentships • SUPA 11 has a Director of Knowledge Transfer and he will report on the growing activities in this area.

REF – see papers attached Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • 3 Meetings of REF Champs since May – Looking at impact statements – Will cross read selection of papers – Will collaborate on wording on overall applications • Currently – Edinburgh/St. A. intending to submit jointly with high ‘entry’ threshold. Will exclude significant number of staff. – Other Schools/departments undecided as yet • Serious discussions will commence in early summer

International Agenda Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • Invitation to talk at ‘Regional Cooperation in Higher Education’ in Essen, October 2011 • Developing Mo. U with CNISM (Italian National Inter-university Consortium for the Physical Sciences of Matter) • Involvement in Scottish Fraunhofer Centre. • Potential Max Planck Centre in Scotland – (SUPA/MPG)

Max Planck Centres Scottish Universities Physics Alliance The Max Planck Society is one of the world’s most successful research organizations. Since its establishment in 1948, the Society has produced 17 Nobel Laureates, putting it on a par with the most prestigious research institutions worldwide. (10 th in the world and 3 rd in Europe according to http: //research. webometrics. info/top 4000_r&d. asp)

Max Planck Centre Scottish Universities Physics Alliance Measurement and Observation at the Quantum Limit Strategy, Aspiration and Progress • • Propose Max Planck Centre on Measurement and Observation at the Quantum Limit Joint venture between SUPA (Glasgow, Strathclyde and St Andrews in the first instance until set up) with AEI Hannover and Golm, MPL Erlangen, MPQ Garching, MP for Chemical Physics Dresden, and MP for Solid State Physics Stuttgart • promote international collaboration with the Max Planck Society and beyond • success will be measured in terms of jointly authored papers and grants • international recruitment programme • visitors exchange programme • international workshops/sandpits • pump-priming of projects

Max Planck Centre Scottish Universities Physics Alliance Measurement and Observation at the Quantum Limit • Five Year life in first instance • Being led by Danzmann (AEI) and Hough (initially) • Strong support from the Universities with interest from STFC, EPSRC and SFC. • Negotiations are ongoing. The Max Planck Society delivers science at the highest of international standards, making the Centre a magnet for the world’s leading researchers, students, fellows and full professors • Fully consistent with the original SUPA Vision

Challenges to be met Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • Keeping researchers motivated towards collaboration and the work required, when they have received their share of funding – Prize Studentship contest helps but future carrots are needed – hence internationalisation and other activities. • Matching collaborative priorities to competitive individual institutional priorities when bidding for funds – requires care – the pool has to be able to add value to each institutional bid – Would be helped if collaborative proposals specifically invited • Long Term Sustainability

Opportunities Scottish Universities Physics Alliance • SFC imposed a funding cut of 16. 4 % for 2011/12 but ongoing funding has been restored • Amount cut will also be restored provided it is used to place early career researchers in industry or an entrepreneurial environment. – Real opportunity here to get young researchers out to Silicon Valley for a period using our SU 2 P connections • Extra funding has also been provided for helping with EC grant applications involving SMEs, and for early career exchanges to improve internationalisation. • Funding of a number of Innovation Centres recently announced • Last two points will be discussed under KT and Graduate School.