Scientific Research Institute Federal Research Centre for Project

Scientific Research Institute - Federal Research Centre for Project Evaluation and Consulting Services (SRI FRCEC) PRACTICAL EXPERIENCE ON ORGANIZATION AND CONDUCT OF STATE EXPERT EXAMINATION FOR SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNOLOGICAL PROJECTS Director of State Centre for Expert Examination in the sphere of Science and Innovations of SRI FRCEC Youri L. Rybakov http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC SYSTEM OF STATE SUPPORT OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 2 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Organization of the expert community activity 3 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC How does a state expert examination in the field of science (SRI FRCEC – as an example) work? According to the decree of Council of Ministers of RSFSR 01. 04. 1991, № 182 «On the introduction of state expert examination in the field of science» it was decided to introduce the state expert examination of research and development (R&D) in the field of fundamental and applied science, to be funded from the budget, and to establish the Federal Research Center for Project Evaluation and Consulting Services (FRCEC) with the rights of a scientific research Institute, which was mandated as the head organization for the state expert examination in the field of research and development. 4 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Basic Principles of scientific and technological expert examination http: //www. extech. ru Independence of research Objectivity of Results Validity of results Efficiency of research 5

SRI FRCEC Typical process of scientific and technological expert examination 6 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Basic principles of experts selection ТHEMATIC PANELS Information – telecommunication systems Biotechnologies Medicine and health care New Materials and Nanotechnologies Compliance of areas of knowledge covered by competitive projects with areas of knowledge in which expert specializes Expert should not be involved in implementation of one of the competitive projects or work in the organization, which was the basis for creating one of the competitive projects Transport and Space Systems Rational use of Natural Resources The number of experts in the group not less than three Energy Efficiency Interdisciplinary Socio-Economic Studies and Humanities 7 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Documentation for scientific and technological expert examination APPLICATION FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE CONTEST EXPLANETARY NOTE ТЕCHNICAL ASSIGNMENT QUALIFICATION CARD SCHEDULE PRICE STRUCTURE 8 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Example of system evaluation criteria The validity of solutions to problems and their marketability. Expected benefits in relation to domestic and foreign counterparts Scientific, technological and industrial potential of head contractors and alleged subcontractors Matching of The novelty of Calendar plan proposals and stages to content, their patenting aims and stated protection duration of the project Existing scientific Economic efficiency of and technological Project results. Validity of experience and its Cooperative ties in requested funding relevance to world science, technology and its distribution level of manufacturing sectors. by cost and achievements in the Market potential of co-authors area under products consideration http: //www. extech. ru 9

SRI FRCEC The general diagram of an expert work organization and providing CUSTOMER Conclusion with ranking Conclusion, Express-analysis Methodical materials documentation submitted for examination TOR for expert examination Information Resources Detailed opinion Consolidated conclusion Expert-Curator of SRI FRCEC EXPERTS from THE FEDERAL ROSTER 10 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Results of expert activity The number of projects and programs that have passed the examination in SRI FRCEC in 2001 – 2012 11 http: //www. extech. ru

SRI FRCEC Thank You for Your Attention! 12 http: //www. extech. ru