Rita Ryder Becky Hines Ellen Dial Paula Penebaker
Rita Ryder, Becky Hines, Ellen Dial, Paula Penebaker, Linda Baechle June 7, 2013 for every woman Financial Vitality: Our Path Forward
Financial Vitality Overview for every woman Rita Ryder, YWCA USA Director of Association Services June 7, 2013
Our Financial Vitality Study Our Goal: Help local YWCAs be stronger, more sustainable and more effective in fulfilling our mission by improving our financial health and vitality. Study Process, Data Collection Techniques: – – – Regional Meeting Focus Groups 990 Data, Standards and Ratios Disaffiliated YWCAs Successful Mergers Interviews with “Healthier” YWCAs Web survey of all YWCAs FVTF Final Report: included in your thumb drive for every woman • Timeframe: May 2010 -Jan. 2013 • Data Collection, Analysis
Cracking The Code: YWCA Financial Vitality Strong, Sustainable Business Model Robust Resource Development • “In our DNA” • “Move the dial” programs • Major giving • Board/staff ownership • Leadership in field ie. a “go-to” org. • Planned giving • Planning, policies, systems, reporting • Efficient, “to-scale” programs • Accountability • Healthy mix: subsidized, self-supporting programs • Multiple income streams • Adequate admin. support • Large, broad-based constituency • Effective use of assets • Public policy funding focus for every woman Strong, Pervasive Financial Corporate Culture
Strategic Restructuring for every woman Becky Hines, YWCA USA Director of Association Services June 7, 2013
What is Strategic Restructuring? “Collaborative strategy that uses partnerships to enhance mission attainment. ” for every woman -La Piana Consulting
6 for every woman
Why Merger? Increase mission impact Grow the organization Better economies of scale Expand geographic reach Acquire staff and programs to meet strategic objectives Increase market position and market share for every woman • • •
YWCA/PATHWAYS FOR WOMEN MERGER for every woman Ellen Dial, Board Chair, YWCA Seattle-King-Snohomish June 7, 2013
A Story About A DV Agency In Transition and A Visionary Board That Declared Victory, Joined Forces With The YWCA. PATHWAYS Capital Campaign, Building Purchase Gg COMPLEX GRASSROOT COMPLE New Complexities…All of a Sudden: • • • A building to maintain Government grants to manage Larger budget Larger staff, new kinds of positions New client relationship: advocate + landlord Significant ongoing fundraising needs for every woman GRASSROOTS Gg
The “Pathways” Board’s Decision Framework The Pathway’s Board’s Goal: • Serve women and families in their community in the most effective way possible, for the long term • Operate in a manner that meets high standards of excellence, integrity and accountability • Grow the organization: Not realistic or feasible: insufficient resources, funding prospects, community capacity • Merge with a local non-profit Not feasible: local agencies with compatible missions too small to provide necessary infrastructure • Merge with the YWCA: best option: mission synergy, capacity for every woman The Pathways Board’s Options:
Enter The YWCA Seattle-King County Our 3 -Pronged Approach for Analyzing the Opportunity • • • Mission compatibility Strategic interest e. g. geographic, programmatic Culture/fit e. g. values, service philosophy, work ethic Program quality e. g. responsiveness to needs, outcomes Human resource assets e. g. competencies Synergies: whole greater than sum of the parts? for every woman 1) How would the merger further our Mission and Goals?
• • • Annual current and projected operating budget (including reliability of government contracts) Community support e. g. reputation, visibility, donors/constituents Assets/Liabilities—current and potential Likely merger-related expenses e. g. salary equity, office and systems equalization, liabilities Impact on YWCA Seattle-King County Infrastructure e. g. supervision costs, business and human resource systems Efficiencies that could be gained for every woman 2) How would the merger impact our financial vitality?
3) If we proceed with a merger, How do we implement to maximize benefits and minimize disruption/negatives? for every woman • Comprehensive communication plan: All staff; donors, grantors, funders, community, media • Complete and timely integration of the staff • Pathway representation on the YWCA Board
So, what happened? (15 years later)…. • The YWCA: YWCA Seattle|King|Snohomish Counties • 4, 300 clients served annually in Snohomish County • Pathways budget grows to $8. 7 million (12 x) for every woman • 5 Snohomish properties valued at $25 million+ 14
YWCA Northeast Indiana for every woman Linda Baechle, CEO YWCA North Central Indiana June 7, 2013
YWCA of Elkhart Co • Limited presence in community for 5 years • Need for services and desire to fill need • Assets • No physical facility or staff • Active Board of Directors • Shared mission YWCA of St Joseph Co • Serving Elkhart County residents already but not enough grant funds to cover costs • Some contracts for Elkhart County already • Could provide more services to Elkhart, but respectful of sister association • Shared mission for every woman Setting the Stage
YWCA of Elkhart Co. • Loss of identity • Loss of control of assets • Loss of control of what services the YWCA provides in community YWCA of St. Joseph Co. • Loss of name recognition • Loss of financial stability • Loss of control of assets • Spreading management staff too thin for every woman Behind the Scenes?
• Neutral to the operating budget • Community support from leaders and potential partners in Elkhart County • Potential funding for the Elkhart County services • Neutral impact on SJC Services for every woman St. Joseph County Merger Criteria
Elkhart County Merger Criteria for every woman • Assure that Primley Trust was retained • Assure that Elkhart County assets were used to benefit Elkhart County residents • Retain a voice in service structuring in Elkhart
Key Factors for Success for every woman • Shared Mission • Trust between Consultant for Elkhart County and CEO for SJC • Strong Leadership from Board Presidents
Key Factors (cont. ): for every woman • Only one Executive Director so no “Turf Issues” • Only one staff and one work culture • Boards small enough to merge without displacing Board members • Assets provided by EC to minimize risk in establishing YWCA presence
How long did it take? July 2009 Becky Hines began discussions YWCA EC Fall 2009 both Boards began discussions Fall 2010 both Boards unanimously to approve September 2010 filed with Secretary of State for every woman • •
• Spring 2011 New Site established • Providing free sexual assault treatment, domestic violence services and economic empowerment • Served 700 clients in past two years from Elkhart Co. site and increase in EC clients served at SJC site • Partnering with Elkhart hospitals & providers on new sexual assault treatment center for every woman Establishment of Elkhart County Site
• Positive reaction from both counties • Re-establishment and a local presence takes time • Take the services to community if community does not come to you! • Identification an emerging community unmet need makes a critical difference in positioning “new” association for every woman Results
YWCA Southeast Wisconsin for every woman Paula Penebaker, CEO YWCA Southeast Wisconsin June 7, 2013
Racine • River Bend Nature Center • Kid’s Club • Kid’s Camp • Job Placement Services • Dress for Success Affiliate Milwaukee • Unlearning Racism: Tools for Action • Just. Us (Justice Under Simple Terms: Understanding Stereotypes) • Transitional Housing • TANF Case Management • Health Training Institute • Career Opportunity Center • Community Adult Learning Lab • Transitional Jobs • Skills for Success for every woman Racine and Milwaukee YWCAs 26
Racine and Milwaukee YWCAs Milwaukee Did not fit our program mix. Fit perfectly under our Workforce Development programming. for every woman Racine River Bend Nature Center Kid’s Club Kid’s Camp Job Placement Services Dress for Success Affiliate 27
• Late Fall 2011, Racine Board first discussed possible merger with Milwaukee. • Talks between associations began in January 2012. • Racine board votes in late spring to dissolve. • Milwaukee board votes to move forward with due diligence. • Milwaukee board approves the takeover of select programs in August 2012. for every woman Timeline 28
Timeline, cont’d. for every woman • September 2012 - Milwaukee becomes Fiscal Agent for Racine and hires 2. 5 FTEs. • October 29, 2012 - Milwaukee announced name change and expansion to Racine. • November 13, 2012 - Grand Opening! 29
• • • Gift from the S. C. Johnson Family had made annual contribution toward operation for years. Much beloved among City residents Separate board of Trustees Associated programming did not fit the mission. Selling would create a PR nightmare. for every woman Sticking Point: River Bend Nature Center 30
1. Racine and Milwaukee have similar social issues but vastly different city cultures. 2. The nonprofit sector in Racine is weak. 3. Racine is economically depressed. 4. Re-establishing trust among philanthropists is challenging. Bridges were burned. for every woman Key Observations 31
for every woman Questions? 32
- Slides: 33