Research Prioritization Abdel Moniem Mukhtar Dr P H
Research Prioritization Abdel Moniem Mukhtar, Dr. P. H. , MPH, BDS, Research Methodology Module, AUW on Septmember 2012
Research Anecdote SEITE 2
Research Opinion SEITE 3
PROBLEM Impact Currentness Size SEITE 4 Other? Distribution
SELECTION Uncertainty Cost Public Interest SEITE 5 Other? Individual Interest
SELECTION Consensus Informal Systematic Literature Review Other? SEITE 6
SELECTION Common Cold Diabetes TB Malaria HIV Other? SEITE 7
Selection Criteria: IQWIG • Common causes of death • Common diagnoses for hospital admission • Common health-related causes of absence from work • Common diagnoses • Common causes of medication prescriptions SEITE 8
Examples of broad research priority areas identified in selected developing countries The Working Group on Priority Setting, 2000 SEITE 9
Newborn health research priorities for Pakistan Abdul Ghaffar, 2007 SEITE 10
Research Options 1. Has an appropriate set of research options been identified? 2. What benefits are important to those who will be affected and which benefits are likely to be achieved with each option? 3. What harms are important to those who will be affected and which harms are likely to arise with each option? 4. What are the local costs of each option and is there local evidence about their cost-effectiveness? 5. What adaptations might be made to any given option and could they alter its benefits, harms and costs? 6. Which stakeholder views and experiences might influence an option's acceptability and its benefits, harms, and costs? Modified after: Lavis, 2009, S. 1 SEITE 11
Study Feasibility: SWOT Humphrey, 2005: cited in wikipedia. org SEITE 12
Checklist • Academic arrangements • Financial arrangements • Design and analysis arrangements • Implementation strategy SEITE 13
Assignments: Small Group Work • Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey: Sudan • Global burden of disease: Sudan • Global Health Observatory: Sudan • Disease Control Priorities Project • CHOosing Interventions that are Cost-Effective (CHOICE) • Canadian Priority Setting Research Network SEITE 14
Materials: Primary and Secondary Health and Health-related Data Primary data Sudan's Household Survey Sudan's Population and Household Census, health facility census) Survey of human resources for health Health facility census National Tuberculosis Program surveillance system National Malaria Program surveillance system National AIDS Control Program Surveillance system Cancer registry Registry of diabetes mellitus Registry of hemophilia National surveillance system for communicable diseases Extended Program for Immunization information system Sudan’s household health expenditure and utilization survey 15 expenditure review SEITEPublic Secondary data Birth statistics Mortality statistics Hospital records Primary care records Prescribing record Emergency service records Pharmacovigilance system Employment records Health facility census Insurance claims data Data on infrastructures Data on socio-economic and socio-demographic variables Data on seasonal variations
Thank you for your kind attention Dr. P. H. Abdel Moniem Mukhtar, MPH, BDS Head of Research Public Health Institute Sahafa, P. O. Box 9099 Khartoum/ Sudan Tel. : +249 -9 -256 001 61 Email: mukhtar@phi. edu. sd moniem. mukhtar@gmail. com Website: www. phi. edu. sd SEITE 16
- Slides: 16