PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY CHEMOTHERAPY YOU Peter Argenta MD DEFINITION

  • Slides: 31
Download presentation
PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY, CHEMOTHERAPY & YOU Peter Argenta, MD

PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY, CHEMOTHERAPY & YOU Peter Argenta, MD

DEFINITION • The conditions that result when nerves that carry messages to and from

DEFINITION • The conditions that result when nerves that carry messages to and from the brain and spinal cord from and to the rest of the body are damaged or diseased. • What does it mean for patients? • Numbness, tingling (“asleep”), burning, pain, weakness • Drops, falls, trips, disability

NEURO-ANATOMY (IN BOX FORM) Muscle Movement Balance Autonomic Control BRAIN SPINE Heat/Cold Pressure Proprioception

NEURO-ANATOMY (IN BOX FORM) Muscle Movement Balance Autonomic Control BRAIN SPINE Heat/Cold Pressure Proprioception PERIPHER Y

NEURO-ANATOMY (SCHEMATIC FORM) Definition:

NEURO-ANATOMY (SCHEMATIC FORM) Definition:

NEURO-ANATOMY (CELLULAR) – LAST ONE, I PROMISE

NEURO-ANATOMY (CELLULAR) – LAST ONE, I PROMISE

Places things can go wrong Brain • Intoxication • Spine/Junctions Stroke • • Tumor

Places things can go wrong Brain • Intoxication • Spine/Junctions Stroke • • Tumor Stroke • Pressure • Tumor • • Invasion Pressure • Trauma Periphery • Invasion • • Diabetes MS Trauma Other • • Chemo ALS • Alzheimers • Poisons MS • Cold • Age

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) • Agents • Taxol (but not taxotere), Cisplatin (but not

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) • Agents • Taxol (but not taxotere), Cisplatin (but not carboplatin), Vinca • How do they affect • Unknown • Not all equal • Progressive/Cumulative

HOW DOES CIPN HAPPEN Reduce dendrite number or length Metabolic health Insulation problem So….

HOW DOES CIPN HAPPEN Reduce dendrite number or length Metabolic health Insulation problem So…. . Which one(s) is it? And…. . Can it be fixed? Impaired/Absent neurotransmitter

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 1

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 1

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 1 END RESULT Message is “heard” “Phone lines” are

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 1 END RESULT Message is “heard” “Phone lines” are out!

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 2 – nerve withdrawl

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 2 – nerve withdrawl

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 2 – nerve withdrawal • Different areas = different

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 2 – nerve withdrawal • Different areas = different nerve density • Nerve density correlates with neuropathy scores • …. imperfectly • In diabetics

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 3

CHEMOTHERAPY-INDUCED PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY (CIPN) Model 3

SO WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO ABOUT IT? Treatment options with universal success?

SO WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO ABOUT IT? Treatment options with universal success? 1.

TREATMENT OPTIONS– MIXED SUCCESS Pharmacy • Gabapentin (antiepileptic) • Duloxetine (SSRI) • Supplements •

TREATMENT OPTIONS– MIXED SUCCESS Pharmacy • Gabapentin (antiepileptic) • Duloxetine (SSRI) • Supplements • L-glutamine • B 6 • Alternatives • Acupuncture • Light/PBM Gabapentin • Approved for seizure and post-herpetic neuralgia • MOA unknown – “nerve calming” Duloxetine (SSRI) • Only phase III data • Approved for painful neuropathy

WHY IS THERE NO EASY TREATMENT 1. It is hard to quantitate success 1.

WHY IS THERE NO EASY TREATMENT 1. It is hard to quantitate success 1. …. a little less numb? 2. >30 tools for measuring neuropathy 1. 2. No consensus on best Most attempt to objectify the subjective 3. Redundancy makes small changes difficult to detect 4. Hard to control for confounding variables 1. Age, smoking, diabetes, exposures

SO…WHAT SHOULD I USE? Supplements (B-complex or L-glutamine) Duloxetine* 231 pt placebo-controlled 1. Cheap

SO…WHAT SHOULD I USE? Supplements (B-complex or L-glutamine) Duloxetine* 231 pt placebo-controlled 1. Cheap and safe RCT Primary outcome is Pain 2. Used as controls in most studies Score 1 point reduction in 10 Neuromodulating agents (gabapentin, SSRI) point scale vs 0. 3 point reduction in placebo 1. Best studied*, well tolerated*, approved 10% drop-out from toxicity 2. May have beneficial side effects

PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY • Current Treatments • Not disease specific • Not effective • B-complex,

PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY • Current Treatments • Not disease specific • Not effective • B-complex, L-glutamine, Gabapentin, Duloxetine* • 231 pt placebo-controlled RCT • Primary outcome is Pain Score • 1 point reduction in 10 point scale vs 0. 3 point reduction in placebo • 10% drop-out from toxicity • Autonomic dysfunction is also common • Dysregulated sweating • Dysregulated heart rhythms

SO…WHAT SHOULD I USE Acupuncture - “been around”, safe, cheap? - lots of single-arm

SO…WHAT SHOULD I USE Acupuncture - “been around”, safe, cheap? - lots of single-arm data - three RCTs Li. Et al Curr Oncology 4/2019 Needed 1. Accupuncture 2. CIPN 3. A control 4. Results

ACUPUNCTURE Lu et al. , 201731 Rostock e 59 40 Women t al. ,

ACUPUNCTURE Lu et al. , 201731 Rostock e 59 40 Women t al. , 201329 Definition: Men and Not Taxanes, Electroac Breast Not Acupunc Low- • Three 2– 3 Times 1– 2 women specified platinum upuncture groups: ■ weekly for cancer, specified derivative ture dose Hydroele Times 3 weeks Times stages I acupunc ctric weekly(totalweekly s, or of 8 vinca –III ture, baths for 8 sessions) for 8 alkaloids delayed • ■ Vitamin weeks B 8 weekscomplex (total of after capsules 18 9 • ■ intervent sessions ion Placebo) ) Outcomes assessed: Degree of CIPN using the PNQ, (lactose) c, QLQ-CIPN 20 b capsules FACT-Ntx • Outcomes assessed: ■ patient-reported CIPNfor severity on the Results: Acupuncture better than. Primary: low-dose acupuncture CIPN: (score significant numerical rating scale for neuropathic symptoms) improvement • ■compared control on the PNQ (p=0. 02), the FACT-Ntx (p=0. 002), a, Secondary: with neuropathy score, electroneurography, Common Toxicity Criteria and the QLQ-CIPN 20 QLQ-C 30 b (p=0. 006) Results: Acupuncture no more effective than control treatments: no significant difference in outcome improvement (primary or secondary) between acupuncture group and control groups.

ACUPUNCTURE Han et 104 Definition: al. , 201730 Men and Multiple All Acupunc Methylco

ACUPUNCTURE Han et 104 Definition: al. , 201730 Men and Multiple All Acupunc Methylco women myeloma, chemoth ture and balamin all erapy methylco stages treatmen balamin ts Approxi Every mately 3 other day times or daily weekly for 12 weeks Outcomes assessed: Degree of CIPN using VAS pain scores, score on the FACT/GOG -Ntxc , and nerve conduction velocities Results: Compared with methylcobalamin, acupuncture was effective for CIPN: significant decrease in VAS pain scores (p<0. 01), and FACT/GOG-Ntx scores (p<0. 05); no significant difference in nerve conduction velocities between acupuncture and controls (p>0. 05)

ACUPUNCTURE Rostock e 59 Definition: t al. , 201329 Men and women Not specified

ACUPUNCTURE Rostock e 59 Definition: t al. , 201329 Men and women Not specified Taxanes, Electroac • Three 2– 3 Times platinum upuncture groups: ■ weekly for derivative Hydroele 3 weeks s, or ctric (total of 8 vinca baths sessions) alkaloids • ■ Vitamin B complex capsules • ■ Placebo (lactose) capsules • Outcomes assessed: ■ Primary: patient-reported CIPN severity (score on the numerical rating scale for neuropathic symptoms) • ■ Secondary: neuropathy score, electroneurography, Common Toxicity Criteria a, QLQ-C 30 b Results: Acupuncture no more effective than control treatments: no significant difference in outcome improvement (primary or secondary) between acupuncture group and control groups.

ACUPUNCTURE Conclusions: “Although two of three included studies showed efficacy, it is difficult to

ACUPUNCTURE Conclusions: “Although two of three included studies showed efficacy, it is difficult to offer a strong recommendation for the use of acupuncture in CIPN because of limited data and sample sizes…. Given that the quality and quantity of the literature concerning this topic are limited, a potentially beneficial effect might exist, but future rigorous RCTs with appropriate controls should be conducted. ”

PHOTOBIOMODULATION • Low level, non-ionizing laser light therapy • Preclinical – increases cellular/mitochondrial respiration,

PHOTOBIOMODULATION • Low level, non-ionizing laser light therapy • Preclinical – increases cellular/mitochondrial respiration, increases NO, ATP production • Animal models • Reduces oxaliplatin-induced mechanical and cold allodynia • Improves neural regeneration and conduction post crush injury • Increased microcirculation • Human (sham-controlled) • improved weekly pain scores among patients with diabetic sensory-motor polyneuropathy • Improved carpal tunnel associated neuropathy

OUR TRIAL

OUR TRIAL

OUR TRIAL

OUR TRIAL

OUR TRIAL • Patients • Any patient with self-identified peripheral neuropathy, not in active

OUR TRIAL • Patients • Any patient with self-identified peripheral neuropathy, not in active treatment • Treatments • PBM vs placebo 3 x/week for 6 weeks • No new treatment (but could continue any you were on) • Measures/Outcomes • Modified Total Neuropathy Score (m. TNS) • Primary outcome - ∆m. TNS at 8 weeks

OUR TRIAL • Outcomes: Primary • Primary - -6. 8 points drop in m.

OUR TRIAL • Outcomes: Primary • Primary - -6. 8 points drop in m. TNS (-53%, p<0. 001) vs +0. 2 (+1. 5%) in placebo arm (p=. 44) • Cross-over patients (38/40) - -6. 9 points (-51%, p<0. 001) • Outcomes: Secondary • Rapid and sustained improvement , but with some regression* • Unequal distribution within the m. TNS* • Outcomes exploratory • No difference in outcomes between early (<7 Bmonths post chemo) or late exposure (-6. 7 – motor, strength and -6. 9 respectively) C - sensory symptoms • Patients with greater (> mean baseline m. TNS) more improvement D had - reflexes E – motor symptoms F - sensory detection

WHAT’S NEXT • PBM • How does it work? • What is optimal dosing?

WHAT’S NEXT • PBM • How does it work? • What is optimal dosing? • How much, how long, maintenance? • Can it be used as a preventative?