October 2018 doc IEEE 802 15 18 0491
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15 Supporting Material and Motions for the EC Telecon October 2, 2018 Bob Heile, 802. 15 Chair bheile@ieee. org Submission Slide 1 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 7 Revision 1 to Rev. Com (unconditional) Submission Slide 2 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 7 Rev 1 Sponsor Ballot History Initial Sponsor Ballot Opened: July 8, 2018, Closed: August 7, 2018 Vote results (pool of xx voters) 68 responses (78% response ratio) 48 yes, 4 no (92% approval ratio) 1 abstain (1%) 61 comments from 7 commenters • 6 marked as MBS (Accepted: 1, Revised: 5) Comment resolution database worksheet: https: //mentor. ieee. org/802. 15/dcn/18/15 -18 -0390 -02 -007 a-sb-1 -comments. xlsx Submission Slide 3 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 7 Rev 1 Sponsor Ballot History (cont. ) Sponsor Ballot Recirc 1: Opened: 12 -Sept-2018 Closed: 22 -Sept-2018 Vote results (pool of 68 voters) 54 responses (80% response ratio) 51 yes, 1 no (94% approval ratio) 2 abstain (3%) 4 comments from 1 commenter • 0 marked as MBS Comment resolution database worksheet: https: //mentor. ieee. org/802. 15/dcn/18/15 -18 -0489 -00 -007 a-sb-recirc 1 -comments. xlsx Submission Slide 4 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 Brief Statement of Remaining Comments • MBS comment types that remain unsatisfied: want to include a note in text indicating that at the next revision of 15. 7 PHY II and PHY III will be deprecated • The resolutions to these comments revised the text to say that at the next revision of 15. 7 PHY II and PHY III may be deprecated. • The justification for the revised resolution is we can’t predict what will happen at the next revision of the text. Submission Slide 5 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 7 Revision 1 to Rev. Com • All MBS comments have been recirculated at least once • No changes have been made to the draft submitted to Rev. Com Submission Slide 6 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 EC Motion to Forward 802. 15. 7 Rev 1 to SB Motion: Approve sending P 802. 15. 7 m_D 2 a to Rev. Com. (Note: there was no CSD or 5 C associated with this PAR) WG Vote (21 -0 -0) (M) Heile (S) Gilb Submission Slide 7 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 10 a Routing Tables Amendment to Sponsor Ballot (unconditional) Submission Slide 8 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 10 a Letter Ballot History Initial Letter Ballot (LB 152) Opened: July 26, 2018, Closed: August 25, 2018 Vote results (pool of 70 voters) 41 responses (58. 57% response ratio) 28 yes, 1 no (96. 55% approval ratio) 12 abstain (29. 27%) 21 comments from 2 commenters 13 marked as MBS (Accepted: 21, Rejected: 0) Comment resolution database worksheet: 15 -18 -0435 -02010 a-consolidated-letter-ballot-comments. xlsx Submission Slide 9 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 10 a Letter Ballot History Letter Ballot Recirc 1: (LB 153) Opened: September 11, 2018 Closed: September 27, 2018 Vote results (pool of 70 voters) 45 responses (64. 29% response ratio) 31 yes, 0 no (100% approval ratio) 14 abstain (31. 11%) 25 editorial comments from one person 0 marked as MBS Comment resolution database worksheet: https: //mentor. ieee. org/802. 15/dcn/18/15 -18 -0435 -03 -010 aconsolidated-letter-ballot-comments Submission Slide 10 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 Brief Statement of Remaining Comments • The comments resulted from the commenter using Libre Office instead of Microsoft Word, and one comment resulting from an error in Microsoft Word. The posted. pdf does not exhibit the errors referred to in the comments. • Draft has passed MEC review but with several comments that need to be addressed during sponsor ballot • Draft has been submitted to the RAC for comment during sponsor ballot Submission Slide 11 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 EC Motion to Forward 802. 15. 10 a to SB Motion: – Approve sending P 802. 15. 10 a_D 1 to Sponsor Ballot. – Confirm the CSD for 802. 15. 10 a in ec-18 -004 -00 WG Vote (20 -0 -0) (M) Heile (S) Gilb Submission Slide 12 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 4 x Field Area Network Extensions (FANE) Amendment to Sponsor Ballot (conditional) Submission Slide 13 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 4 x Letter Ballot History Initial Letter Ballot (LB 151) Opened: July 25, 2018, Closed: August 24, 2018 Vote results (pool of 70 voters) 40 responses (57% response ratio) 35 yes, 0 no (100% approval ratio) 5 abstain (12. 5%) 15 comments from 6 commenters (0 marked as MBS) (Accepted: 6, Rejected: 9) Comment resolution database worksheet: https: //mentor. ieee. org/802. 15/dcn/18/15 -18 -0439 -02 -004 x-lb 151 -consolidatedcomments-do-draft. xlsx Submission Slide 14 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 Current Status • Recirculation ballot #154 – Opened September 22 nd – Closes October 7, 2018 at 18: 00 EDT – No comments received to date – No negative votes • MEC review started but not yet completed. This is a short draft so review could complete in same time frame as ballot 154. Submission Slide 15 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 802. 15. 4 x to Sponsor Ballot (conditional) If there any MEC comments that are MBS or if a valid MBS comment(s) is received as part of Ballot 154: • Anticipated Recirculation Schedule – Recirc #2 (if needed): • Start October 10, End October 25 Submission Slide 16 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
October 2018 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -18 -0491 -00 -0000 EC Motion to Forward 802. 15. 4 x to SB Motion: – Conditionally approve sending P 802. 15. 4 x_D 1 (or current draft) to Sponsor Ballot. – Confirm the CSD for 802. 15. 4 x in ec-18 -0083 -00 ACSD-802 -15 -4 x. docx WG Vote (27 -0 -0) (M) Heile (S) Gilb Submission Slide 17 Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance
- Slides: 17
