November 2017 doc IEEE 802 11 171687 r
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 TGax Editor’s Report Date: 2017 -11 -06 Authors: Submission Slide 1 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 Abstract Current status of comment resolution on the TGax draft Submission Slide 2 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 Draft history Draft Page Count Release Date D 0. 1 221 March 2016 D 1. 0 453 December 2016 D 2. 0 596 October 2017 Submission Approval Rate Comments Latest resolution document 1822 15/0535 r 8 58% 7418 17/0010 r 14 63% 3350 17/1682 r 0 Slide 3 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 LB 230 comment breakdown • • • General: Technical: Editorial: Duplicates: Grand total: Submission 100 2325 878 47 3350 Slide 4 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 LB 230 commenters Count of CID Commenter Mark RISON Liwen Chu Dorothy Stanley kaiying Lv Youhan Kim Adrian Stephens Yongho Seok Robert Stacey Yusuke Tanaka Alfred Asterjadhi Albert Petrick SUNGEUN LEE Sigurd Schelstraete ron porat yujin noh Tomoko Adachi James Yee Massinissa Lalam Guoqing Li Abhishek Patil Yasuhiko Inoue Graham Smith Submission Column Labels N E N Total G 134 12 T 6 20 5 27 8 11 71 14 72 1 244 198 33 36 1 1 23 78 19 1 58 85 71 50 73 1 42 78 1 6 11 1 4 2 1 46 12 Y Total G 8 57 12 6 Slide 5 34 19 16 6 1 2 37 3 18 1 24 29 28 28 6 15 Grand Total T 384 210 35 73 Y E 1 2 7 156 53 103 25 107 26 30 47 24 73 44 156 89 122 78 113 27 30 50 24 91 45 54 45 34 25 2 36 24 27 78 74 63 55 2 36 37 42 384 210 156 147 122 113 112 101 100 97 92 87 78 78 75 63 63 59 48 43 42 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 LB 230 commenters Count of CID Column Labels N Commenter N Total E G Y T 5 Y Total E G Carol Ansley 32 2 39 Bin Tian 9 22 31 7 7 38 Yuichi Morioka 8 8 16 19 19 35 Po-Kai Huang 16 17 33 39 33 GEORGE CHERIAN 3 27 30 30 Woojin Ahn 7 23 30 30 28 28 29 25 Zhou Lan 1 Bo Sun 5 Lei Huang 5 1 6 13 20 Tianyu Wu 8 6 8 22 22 Duncan Ho 9 13 22 22 22 13 7 20 21 1 20 21 21 21 19 24 24 Laurent Cariou James Lepp 1 1 Yanjun Sun Chunyu Hu Jarkko Kneckt 3 11 14 7 7 21 Joseph Levy 8 1 9 11 11 20 Rajesh Kumar 20 20 20 Bibhu Mohanty 20 20 20 Simone Merlin 13 7 20 20 Qi Xue 7 13 20 20 11 9 20 20 2 2 15 17 19 7 1 10 11 18 4 13 17 17 1 15 16 17 17 EVGENY KHOROV 14 6 20 Hemanth Sampath Matthew Fischer 2 Peter Loc 3 4 Huizhao Wang Hongyuan Zhang 1 1 20 Patrice Nezou Osama Aboulmagd Submission Grand Total T 1 Slide 6 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 LB 230 commenters Count of CID Commenter Yonggang Fang Jinsoo Ahn Roger Marks Pascal VIGER Chao Chun Wang Lochan Verma John Coffey James June Wang Yunbo Li Qingjiang Tian Jerome Vanthournout Mark Hamilton Geonjung Ko Xiaofei Wang Kazuyuki Sakoda Kiseon Ryu Fei Tong Jianhan Liu Sameer Vermani Jing Ma Jae Seung Lee Jinjing Jiang Xiaogang Chen Stephen Mc. Cann Vincent Knowles IV Jones Submission Column Labels N E N Total G 4 14 7 1 2 Y E T 1 8 1 12 14 5 12 10 1 6 Y Total G 8 5 2 3 15 3 1 12 13 2 11 9 11 11 3 11 7 11 10 4 9 9 9 7 7 8 7 7 2 4 6 1 4 4 4 5 11 9 5 1 2 8 7 1 9 9 1 2 3 1 Grand Total T 7 7 4 6 7 6 6 6 1 Slide 7 6 16 15 14 13 12 11 11 10 9 9 9 8 8 7 7 7 6 6 6 5 5 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 LB 230 commenters LB 230 Count of CID Column Labels Commenter Ming Gan Michael Montemurro Geert Awater Yan Zhang Kazuto Yano Jeongki Kim Li-Hsiang Sun Naveen Kakani Ian Sherlock Andrew Myles Shimi Shilo Eugene Baik Rojan Chitrakar Zhigang Rong Yuchen Guo stephane baron Yanchun Li Zhiyong Huang Erik Lindskog Jian Yu Xiayu Zheng Jia Allert Van Zelst Rui Cao Chittabrata Ghosh Richard Van Nee xun yang Grand Total Submission N E N Total G Y E T Y Total G 1 1 3 3 1 4 4 1 2 3 3 1 4 4 4 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 1443 1 1 1855 2 1 1 1 552 Grand Total T 29 914 1 1495 Slide 8 340 72 4 4 4 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 3350 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 Comment resolution process Identify high level comment groups Assign each comment group to a lead individual Comment group lead can further subdivide and assign individual comments Comment group lead is responsible for coordinating activity • Ensure that all comments are addressed • Address overlap with other topics Each comment group is assigned to an ad-hoc where the resolutions for that group are discussed • We may want to load balance across the ad-hocs Submission Slide 9 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 PHY ad-hoc comment groups Comment group Clauses Assignee Introduction 28. 1, 9. 4. 2. 237. 3 Lochan MU and OFDMA overview 28. 3. 2, 28. 3. 3 Youhan SU and MU beamforming overview 28. 3. 15 Lochan PPDU formats (including NDP formats) 28. 3. 4, 28. 3. 16, 28. 3. 17 Tianyu Transmit block diagrams and encoding procedure 28. 3. 5, 28. 3. 6 Feng Transmit and receive specs 28. 3. 18 -19 Jianhan Transmit and receive procedures 28. 3. 20 -21 Xiaogang Chen? MCS overview and tables 28. 3. 7, 28. 5 Bin Mathematical description (including all fields) 28. 3. 8 -9, 28. {10, 11, 12} Hongyuan Submission Slide 10 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 PHY ad-hoc comment groups Comment group Clauses Assignee HE-SIG-A subfields 28. 3. 10. 7 Lochan HE-SIG-B encoding, mapping, subfields 28. 3. 10. 8 Lochan PHY SAP (including VECTOR tables) 8, 28. 2, 28. 4 Bo Preamble 28. 3. 10 Jianhan Data field 28. 3. 11 Hongyuan Packet extension 28. 3. 12 Youhan TXTIME 28. 4. 3 Youhan Submission Slide 11 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups Comment group Clauses Assignee Sounding protocol and frame formats 9. 4. 1. 62 -65, 27. 6 Alfred Fragmentation 10. 5, 27. 3 Ming Gan Acknowledgement procedures 10. 24, 27. 4, 9 George Cherian A-MPDU content (includes multi-TID) 9. 7. 3, 10. 13, 27. 5, 27. 10. 4 Liwen Chu NAV (including TXOP_DURATION) 27. 2. 2, 27. 2. 4, 27. 11. 5, Po-Kai Huang 10. 3. 2. 4, 9. 2. 5, 10. 3. 2. 1 Duration-based RTS/CTS 27. 2. 1 Yongho Seok MU-RTS/CTS 27. 2. 5, 17 Po-Kai Huang EDCA (including MU EDCA) 10. 22, 27. 2. 6 Laurent Cariou TWT operation 9. 4. 1. 60, 9. 4. 2. 200, 10. 43, 27. 7 Matt Fischer Submission Slide 12 Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups Comment group Clauses Assignee Operating mode (OMI and OMN) 27. 8 Guoqing Li Queue size and BSR operation 9. 2. 4. 5. 6, 9. 2. 4. 6. 4. 5, 9. 3. 1. 23. 5, 27. 5. 3. 6 Zhou Lan BQR operation 9. 3. 1. 23. 7, 27. 5. 2 Zhou Lan Spatial reuse operation 9. 4. 2. 243, 27. 2. 3, 27. 9 Matthew Fischer UL OFDMA random access operation 27. 5. 5, 27. 14. 2 Chitto Ghosh Reverse direction protocol 10. 28 Jarkko NDP feedback operation 9. 4. 2. 244, 27. 5. 6 Laurent Cariou (fast) Link adaptation 9. 2. 4. 6. 4. 4, 27. 13 Frank Hsu HE BSS operation (including BSS color) 9. 4. 2. 241, 9. 4. 2. 238, 27. 16, 27. 17 Submission Slide 13 Alfred Robert Stacey, Intel
November 2017 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -17/1687 r 1 MAC/SR/MU ad-hoc comment groups Comment group Clauses Assignee PICS Annex B Edward Au MIB Annex C Edward Au General and MAC services 4, 5, 27. 1 Guoqing Li MLME SAP 6 Jae Seung Multi-BSS 9. 4. 2. 46, 11. 1. 3. 8 Abhishek Power management 11. 2, 27. 14 Guoqing Li MU operation 27. 5 Abhishek PPDU format and multirate 27. 15, 10. 7 Alfred DFS operation 27. 5. 3. 2. 1, 27. 5. 3. 3 Youhan Submission Slide 14 Robert Stacey, Intel
- Slides: 14