Needs Assessment CIVE 4312 Hanadi Rifai Engineering Design

  • Slides: 10
Download presentation
Needs Assessment CIVE 4312 Hanadi Rifai

Needs Assessment CIVE 4312 Hanadi Rifai

Engineering Design Process Implementation Needs Assessment Iteration Analysis Problem Formulation Abstraction And Synthesis

Engineering Design Process Implementation Needs Assessment Iteration Analysis Problem Formulation Abstraction And Synthesis

Establishing Need n n n Concern for health, safety and quality of life of

Establishing Need n n n Concern for health, safety and quality of life of public Redesign existing product Better solution for a particular task

All Problems are not Equal

All Problems are not Equal

Success vs. Failure - inability of engineering solution to p its intended function Error

Success vs. Failure - inability of engineering solution to p its intended function Error - underlying cause for failure

Causes of Failure n n n Concrete level - Specific physical source (O-ring seal

Causes of Failure n n n Concrete level - Specific physical source (O-ring seal in Challenger) Process Level - Invalid assumptions or flawed execution (O-ring gaskets and putty assumed sufficient on Challenger) Perspective Level - Flawed value system (Manufacturer of Challenger boosterrocket overrode engineering recommendations)

Design Proposal Engineers often prepare formal design propo to justify expenditure of time, money

Design Proposal Engineers often prepare formal design propo to justify expenditure of time, money and eff • Why? • Who? • Where? • How? • When? • What? • How much?

Structure of a Proposal n n n Objective (Why? ) Background (Who? Where? )

Structure of a Proposal n n n Objective (Why? ) Background (Who? Where? ) Methodology (How? When? ) Expected Results (What? ) Costs (How much will it cost? ) The design proposal is a plan

Methodology n n Approach Tasks Who will perform tasks Schedule of completion

Methodology n n Approach Tasks Who will perform tasks Schedule of completion

Gantt Charts Tasks Gather Data Conceptual Design Select Alternative Reporting Q 1 Q 2

Gantt Charts Tasks Gather Data Conceptual Design Select Alternative Reporting Q 1 Q 2 Q 3 Q 4