NEEA XMP PUMPS RESEARCH Proposed Changes to Research

NEEA XMP PUMPS RESEARCH Proposed Changes to Research Sample Frame November 30, 2018

RECAP: EFFICIENT C&I PUMPS Summary Sample frame updated to reflect changes proposed Application Constant Speed Commercial Cooling Tower Commercial Cooling Commercial Heating Commercial Domestic Hot Water Circulation Commercial Pressure Boost Agricultural Irrigation 2 5 3 Pumps Identified: 171 Goal: 220 Current status: Variable Speed Constant Speed Baseline 10 0 30 5 23 0 76% Primary Data Collection Total Confirmed 9 20 4 21/30 60/30 30/30 0 5 5/15 4 2 0 6 3 0 5 N/A 12/20 8/30 Industrial - Boiler feedwater 0 3 0 0 3/15 Industrial - Cooling Municipal Water Distribution Treatment 1 2 0 2 5/15 9 10 8 0 27/35 2

RECAP: PATH FORWARD – C&I PUMPS Commercial Cooling Tower Commercial Heating Targeted Outreach • Target PG&E, PGE, and Avista for retrofit projects • Target OSU Facilities, City of Portland, and Montana State University IDL for Constant Speed Changes to Sample Frame • Decrease the Variable Speed: Constant Speed Baseline to 5 Targeted Outreach • Target City of Portland Snohomish County Office of Energy and Sustainability Changes to Sample Frame • Decrease the Variable Speed: Constant Speed Baseline to 5 Commercial Cooling Commercial Domestic Hot Water Recirculation Targeted Outreach • Leverage OEM Data Changes to Sample Frame • Decrease the Variable Speed: Constant Speed Baseline to 5 Targeted Outreach • University of Washington • Tacoma Power • Bozeman School District Changes to Sample Frame • Increase the Primary Data Collection quota to 10 • Decrease the overall Quota to 15 3

RECAP: PATH FORWARD – C&I PUMPS Commercial Pressure Boost Industrial Targeted Outreach • University of Oregon IDL • BPA • Washington State University IDL Changes to Sample Frame • Increase the Primary Data Collection quota to 10 • Decrease the overall Quota to 20 Targeted Outreach • Pipe. Flo (modeling) • KCF Technologies and Modeling • OEM Data • PG&E Projects Changes to Sample Frame • Target 2 Industrial sub-applications • Set quota of 15 pumps for each sub-application Agricultural Irrigation Targeted Outreach • Leverage RTF data to characterize performance • Use Chelan PUD data to characterize pumps • Target existing data collection at OSU Farm Sites Changes to Sample Frame • Decrease the Variable Speed: Constant Speed Baseline to 5 • Utilize monthly metered data to validate load profiles and adjustment factors Municipal Water Treatment Targeted Outreach • Work with Snohomish PUD • Case Study with Manufacturers to characterize smaller systems • Target City of Bozeman and City of Pullman for Existing data Changes to Sample Frame • No specific changes to this sample frame 4

RECAP: CIRCULATORS Summary Circulators that have been identified Hydronic Heating Application Pumps Identified: 50 Goal: 95 Current status: Domestic Hot Water Primary Data Single Adaptive Pressure Temperature Collection* Speed Pressure 52% Unknown Learning On. Demand Any Primary Data Collection* 3/5 3/3 Single Family 3/5 3/5 3/3 3/5 Not Applicable Multi-Family 0/5 0/5 0/3 6/5 Not Applicable 8/5 9/3 Commercial 7/5 4/5 0/5 4/5 11/3 0/5 Not Applicable 0/5 0/3 *The Primary Data Collection is incorporated into the 20 identified sites for each sector and application 5

RECAP: PATH FORWARD – CIRCULATORS Domestic Hot Water Recirculation – Circulators Targeted Outreach • Existing data through ACT D’Mand • Existing data from previous research/literature review • Primary data collection through UW and manufacturer reps/distributor contacts Changes to the Sample Frame • Target data collection to control strategies that are found in the field for each sector • Increase the Primary Data Collection quota by 5 pumps Hydronic Heating – Circulators Targeted Outreach • Existing data through EDC • Existing data from previous research/literature review • Primary data collection through UW and manufacturer reps/distributor contacts Changes to the Sample Frame • Utilize extra-regional data • Increase the Primary Data Collection quota by 5 pumps

Thanks for your time! 46