ML for Nonverbal Behavior Analysis in Schizophrenia Talia
ML for Non-verbal Behavior Analysis in Schizophrenia Talia Tron Prof. Daphna Weinshall, Prof. Abraham Peled Py. Con 2018
Once upon a time… Ph. D in computational neuroscience
How to save the world? Psychiatric Diagnosis I feel very depressed lately Sounds like you suffer from depression
Focus on Schizophrenia Positive signs Non-verbal Behavior Negative signs
Schizophrenia classification 3 D Two Phase SVM based Classifier BUT 88% Accuracy 85% Recall
Schizophrenia classification • We ignore: • Other clinical conditions • Clinical subpopulations • Continuous monitoring • Non communicative • There are better signs
How to become clinically relevant? • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient over time clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural context
How to become clinically relevant? • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient over time clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural context
Facial expression in Schizophrenia Control Patient Ø Flat affect Ø Facial dynamics Ø Facial clusters Ø Emotional content time
Facial expression in Schizophrenia • What is your name? Elsa. Flat affect • How are you today? Sad. Inappropriate affect
Facial expression in Schizophrenia
Facial expression in Schizophrenia • No inappropriate affect when taking flatness into account (Analysis of variance)
Not enough!! • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural natural context
Not enough!! • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural natural context
Continuous motor monitoring • 25 Patients monitored for about a month • 50 Hz Accelerometers • Basic Measures - number of steps, energy square, energy variance (dynamics)
Continuous motor monitoring • Detect abnormal behaviors (ARIMA model) ŷt = μ + ϕ 1 yt-1 +…+ ϕp yt-p - θ 1 et-1 -…- θqet-q p = number of autoregressive terms q = Number of lagged forecast errors
Continuous motor monitoring • Detect abnormal behaviors (ARIMA model) • Compare with clinical conditions & drug usage Symptom severity Lithium Look at the WIDER picture
Not enough!! • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural natural context
Continuous motor monitoring • Look on clinical sub-populations (Patient X Day) Negative Factor Negative Baseline Positive Factor
Continuous motor monitoring • Look on clinical sub-populations • Take context into account (regular daily activities)
Continuous motor monitoring • Look on clinical sub-populations • Take context into account (regular daily activities) • Communicate results Negative Baseline Positive
Continuous motor monitoring • Look on clinical sub-populations • Take context into account (regular daily activities) • Communicate results • Regression & Classification (Precision = 0. 757, Recall = 0. 748 )
Enough? • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural natural context
Enough? • Black box Communication • Schizophrenia vs. Control Single patient clinical sub-population • One time Continuous Monitoring • Context Natural natural context • Beyond basic measures
Beyond basic motor measures • Convert continuous signal to “motor words” Acceleration DEDCBABCDEDBABCDEDBA Time
Beyond basic motor measu • Convert continuous signal to “motor words” NLP! YAY!
Beyond basic motor measu • Convert continuous signal to “motor words” • LDA (Topic modeling)
Beyond basic motor measures • Convert continuous signal to “motor words” • LDA (Topic modeling) How diverse is patient’s motor activity How steady is it in similar context How similar is it to other patients
Beyond basic motor measures
There’s still a lot to do… • Automatic extraction of objective, quantitative and clinically relevant behavioral measures. • Improve the reliability of psychiatric diagnosis • Allow better patients’ characterization which may assist both research and treatment. • Can not yet replace a human care giver. • Far from production • Privacy and voluntary cooperation must be taken into account.
AND THEY LIVED HAPPILY EVER AFTER Data Scientist @ Intuit
Acknowledgments • Prof. Daphna Weinshall • Prof. Abraham Peled M. D. • Mikhail Bazhmin M. D • Prof. Alexander Grinshpoon M. D. • Dr. Yehezkel S. Resheff • Elena Dahan M. D. SHA’AR MENSAHE Mental Health Center
Q&A
- Slides: 33