MKUKUTA REVIEW AND EMERGING ISSUES FOR MKUKUTA II
- Slides: 20
MKUKUTA REVIEW AND EMERGING ISSUES FOR MKUKUTA II ANNUAL NATIONAL POLICY DIALOGUE 19 -25 Nov. 2009: Day 2: Friday 20 th Nov. 2009 Ms. A. Mwasha/Prof. A. V. Y. Mbelle 1
STRUCTURE OF PRESENTATION FIVE SECTIONS I: INTRODUCTION II: EMERGING ISSUES FROM REVIEW III: HIGHLIGHTS/ISSUES FOR MKUKUTA II IV: CHALLENGES V: CONCLUDING REMARKS 2
I: INTRODUCTION POVERTY IS THE MAIN DEVELOPMENT CHALLENGE IN TANZANIA. THE FIGHT AGAINST POVERTY IS GROUNDED IN THE FOLLOWING: v NATIONAL REALITIES – SINCE INDEPENDENCE v HUMAN RIGHTS PERSPECTIVE – POVERTY IS DEHUMANIZING v REGIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COMMITMENTS HENCE POLICIES AND STRATEGIES PUT IN PLACE KEY DOCUMENTS: ARUSHA DECLARATION (1967) NATIONAL POVERTY ERADICATION STRATEGY (1998); VISION 2025 (1999); PRSP 2000 -2004; MKUKTA (2005). 3
I: INTRODUCTION EXPECTATIONS ON MKUKUTA OVER POVERTY REDUCTION STRATEGY PAPER: SUBSTANTIAL POVERTY REDUCTION, GIVEN: ü MOVE FROM PRIORITY SECTOR APPROACH TO OUTCOME-BASED APPROACH TO POVERTY REDUCTION ü IMPROVED COORDINATION ü IMPROVED SYNERGIES AND CROSS-SECTOR COLLABORATION ü POVERTY FOCUS INCLUDING BEING MDGs-BASED ü IMPROVED MACROECONOMIC PERFORMANCE MANIFESTING IN RELATIVELY HIGH GDP GROWTH 4
INTRODUCTION … AREAS OF CONSENSUS GROWTH ACHIEVED DURING MKUKUTA IMPLEMENTATION COULD HAVE DELIVERED MORE IN TERMS OF POVERTY REDUCTION (CONTRAST 1991/2 – 2001 AND 2001 -2007 HBSs). WHERE DID ALL THE GROWTH GO? 2. HIGHER GROWTH COULD HAVE BEEN ACHIEVED 3. CONSIDERABLE A CHIEVEMENTS HAVE BEEN RECORDED IN NON-INCOME POVERTY (HUMAN DEVELOPMENT GAINS) AND SYSTEMS FOR RESOURCE ALLOCATION E. G. SBAS 4. REFORM PROCESS HAS BEEN INCOMPLETE CAUTION: MKUKUTA SHOULD NOT TAKE ALL CREDIT NOR ALL BLAME 1. 5
I: CONT’D CONSIDERABLE “INVESTMENTS” IN MKUKUTA Ø DEVELOPMENT OF STRATEGIC BUDGET ALLOCATION SYSTEM (SBAS MACRO AND MICRO) Ø REVIEW OF STRATEGIC PLANS (MDAs, LGAs) Ø MONITORING SYSTEM Ø PRODUCTION OF MAIRs AND PHDRs Ø DESIGN OF MEDIUM TERM STRATEGIC PLANNING AND BUDGETING MANUAL 6
II: EMERGING ISSUES FROM REVIEW �MOST OF THE ISSUES RAISED DURING CONSULTATTIONS TOWARDS MKUKUTA LARGELY STILL VALID �KEY ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE ADDRESSED FOR MORE EFFECTIVE IMPLEMENTATION AND ATTAINMENT OF RESULTS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED (INADEQUATE PRIORITIZATION AND COORDINATION; INCOMPLETE REFORM PROCESS; INSTITUTIONAL CONCERNS, ETC) 7
II CONT’D FINANCING OF MKUKUTA: v MKUKUTA FINANCING TAKES LARGER SHARE (EG. 70. 7% DURING 2008/09 COMPARED TO 29. 3% NONMKUKUTA ACTIVITIES) v SPENDING BY ECONOMIC CATEGORY FAVOURS DEVELOPMENT SPENDING (70%) v CLUSTER II TAKES LARGER SHARE OF MKUKUTA FINANCING (EG. 45. 5% DURING 2008/09; COMPARED TO CLUSTER I, 34. 1%; CLUSTER III, 16. 1% AND XCUTTING ISSUES, 4. 4%) v DEVELOPMENT FINANCING OF MKUKUTA DOMINATED BY FOREIGN SOURCES (57% COMPARED TO LOCAL, 43) 8
Mukuta Vs Non-Mkukuta Allocation 9
Spending by Economic Category 10
Cluster wise Allocation 11
Mkukuta Development Funding 12
III: HIGHLIGHTS/ISSUES FOR MKUKUTA II DESIGN/VALUE ADDITION OVER MKUKUTA I 1. SHARP, FOCUSSED, PRIORITIZED STRATEGY/INTERVENTIONS 2. GREATER EMPHASIS ON GROWTH (INCLUSIVE) 3. TARGETING GREATER DEVELOPMENT IMPACT 4. FLEXIBILITY IN ADJUSTING STRATEGIES 5. INCORPORATING ISSUES THAT WERE NOT PROMINENT IN MKUKUTA (I): HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT PLAN; PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS; EXTENDED EMPHASIS ON CROSS-CUTTING ISSUES -INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES (INCLUDING CLIMATE CHANGE); ENABLING INVESTMENT CLIMATE FOR DOMESTIC ENTERPRISE; POPULATION ISSUES; SPATIAL/GEOGRAPHICAL/LOCATION ISSUES; RAPID URBANIZATION AND IMPLICATIONS 13
III CONT’D 6. ROBUST ACTORS COORDINATION IN ACHIEVING RESULTS 7. LONG TERM GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN 2010 -2025 (MISSED INTERVENTION IN MKUKUTA) – JUSTIFICATION (EXPERIENCE OF SUCCESSFUL COUNTRIES; INVESTMENTS NEED A LONGER HORIZON TO DELIVER “MULTIPLIER EFFECT”; DOMESTIC RESOURCE MOBILIZATION; INSTITUTIONAL ISSUES; SUSTAINING REDUCTION IN EXTERNAL DEPENDENCE; 14
III CONT’D DESIGN – WHAT WILL NOT CHANGE : BROAD FRAMEWORK: RESULTS FOCUSSED, CLUSTER-BASED. KEY STRATEGIC INVESTMENTS AND POLICY DIRECTION : HIGH AND SUSTAINED GROWTH CLUSTER I: GROWTH AND REDUCTION OF INCOME POVERTY Ø GROWTH –FOCUSSED INTERVENTIONS WITH EXPLICIT AND ELABORATE LONG TERM GROWTH PLAN Ø ANCHORED ON COMPARATIVE AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES Ø DRIVEN BY GROWTH DRIVERS: AGRICULTURE, INFRASTRUCTURE, TOURISM, MINING Ø INCLUSIVE GROWTH Ø INTERVENTIONS FROM CLUSTERS II AND III EMBEDED (E. G. SKILLS, WATER FOR PRODUCTION, PRODUCTIVE INTERVENTIONS IN SOCIAL PROTECTION, ECONOMI GOVERNANCE 15
III CONT’D CLUSTER II: IMPROVEMENT OF QUALITY OF LIFE AND SOCIAL WELL BEING Ø ADDRESSING QUALITY ISSUES IN SERVICE DELIVERY (EDUCATION, HEALTH, WATER, SANITATION) Ø COORDINATED INTERVENTIONS 16
III CONT’D CLUSTER III: GOVERNANCE AND ACCOUNTABILITY Ø ISSUES OF GOVERNANCE IN SUPPORT OF GROWTH 17
IV: CHALLENGES �AREAS AND EXTENT OF REFORMS TO COMPLETE REFORM PROCESS �IMPROVING THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT �ADAPTATION TO DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT (ATITUDES, WORK CULTURE, ETC) �CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS FOR STUDIES THAT HAVE BEEN APPROVED INORDER TO INFORM REVIEW/DRAFTING OF MKUKUTA II �DEVELOPMENT OF MKUKUTA II AND LONG TERM GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN CONCURRENTLY �POLITICAL CONSENSUS AND STEWARDSHIP 18
V: CONCLUDING REMARKS MKUKUTA II IS ABOUT CHOICES: v SUBSTANTIAL POVERTY REDUCTION VERSUS INCREASED GROWTH IN THE SHORT TERM v WHAT SHOULD SPUR GROWTH IN THE SHORT TO MEDIUM TERM AND IN THE LONG RUN v FACING THE FINANCIAL RISK: SIGNIFICANT SCALEUP OF ODA (INCLUDING GLENEAGLES SCENARIO) VERSUS DOMESTIC RESOURCE MOBILIZATION AS ENVISAGED ALSO IN VISION 2025 v RESOURCE ALLOCATION IN MKUKUTA – ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR CLUSTER I WITHOUT DEPRIVING CLUSTERS II AND III 19
END NOTE THANK YOU FOR YOUR KIND ATTENTION AHSANTENI SANA 20
- Emerging issues in community development in kenya
- Emerging issues in industrial relations
- Emerging issues in taxation
- Mkukuta ni nini
- Mkukuta 2
- Kontinuitetshantering
- Typiska drag för en novell
- Tack för att ni lyssnade bild
- Returpilarna
- Varför kallas perioden 1918-1939 för mellankrigstiden
- En lathund för arbete med kontinuitetshantering
- Underlag för särskild löneskatt på pensionskostnader
- Tidbok yrkesförare
- Anatomi organ reproduksi
- Förklara densitet för barn
- Datorkunskap för nybörjare
- Boverket ka
- Hur skriver man en debattartikel
- Magnetsjukhus
- Nyckelkompetenser för livslångt lärande
- Påbyggnader för flakfordon