May 2001 doc IEEE 802 15 01462 r

  • Slides: 23
Download presentation
May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15 Working

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks™ TG 1 Opening Report November 2001 Austin, TX USA Submission 2 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Contents • Summary •

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Contents • Summary • Motion Planning • Overview of Session #15/Austin – Objectives – Submissions – Session Graphic • Rev. Com Submission – [01462 r 1 a. P 802 -15_WG-P 802. 15. 1 -Rev. Com-Submission. pdf] • Project Planning Status • Next Meeting – Tentative Needs for Dallas – Objectives for Dallas • Drafting History Submission 3 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Summary • • Task

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Summary • • Task Group 1 (TG 1) is deriving a draft standard from the Bluetooth™ specification under IEEE PAR 802. 15. 1 At Session #15, motion SEC, address WG & SEC comments, IF ANY, achieve majority approval from the WG & SEC motions and enter Rev. Com phase. Pre submitted 26 Oct 01. During the Jul 01/Nov 01 between-session-period – busy – – – • • SB 1 ballot & resolution SB 2 ballot & Rev. Com Application for approval of P 802. 15. 1 IEEE-SA, Pat. Com, Rev. Com, and BSIG SB 2 has 2 Disapproving Voters and 19 unresolved comments (comment #7 is resolved as the 3 rd DISAPPROVING Voter changed to a YES w/ comments. The TG 1 will update their Project Plan – 00/375 r 3 [00375 r 3 P 802 -15_TG 1 -Project. Planning. pdf]; once SEC approval is achieved. ETA 17 Nov 01. The 802. 15. 1 submittal will be reviewed by Rev. Com. Preliminary comments will be sent to Project 802. 15. 1 by the middle of November. Scheduled St. B Committee Meetings 4 -6 Dec 01: – – – Submission http: //standards. ieee. org/board/stdsbd/meeting-notice. html 4 Dec 01 Pat. Com - 6. 2 Letter of Assurance from Bluetooth SIG, Inc. for P 802. 15. 1 5 Dec 01 Rev. Com - P 802. 15. 1/D 1. 0. 1 New: "Standard for Information Technology… 4 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Planned Motions • Motions

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Planned Motions • Motions – #1 Wed, 14 Nov 01 to Full WG – #2 Fri, 16 Nov 01 to SEC Submission 5 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Motion

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Motion #1 to the Full WG • Move to submit P 802. 15. 1/D 1. 0. 12001 to 802 SEC for approval of submission to Rev. Com. Non Technical 50% (Procedural) Moved: ? Second: ? Y/N/A: // Note: TG 1 pre-submitted D 1. 0. 1 to Rev. Com on 26 Oct 01. Submission 6 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Motion

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Motion #2 to the 802 SEC • Move that the Ex. Com forward IEEE Draft 802. 15. 1/D 1. 0. 1 to Rev. Com. Non Technical 50% (Procedural) Moved: ? Second: ? Y/N/A: // Note: TG 1 pre-submitted D 1. 0. 1 to Rev. Com on 26 Oct 01. Submission 7 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Objectives

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Objectives • Post Session #14/<Bellevue>17 -21 Sep 01 ü 1. FINALIZE RESOLUTION OF 1 ST (SB 2) IEEE SPONSOR RECIRCULATION BALLOT ü 2. IF IT PASSES, FINALIZE DRAFT 802. 15. 1/D 1. 1 AND PRESUBMIT TO REVCOM – 3. IF IT FAILS OR REQUIRES ANOTHER RECIRC. - APPLY EDITS AND SUBMIT TO 2 ND (SB 3) IEEE SPONSOR RECIRCULATION BALLOT • Session #15/Austin – 4. MOTION FULL WG TO APPROVE FORWARDING P 802. 15. 1 TO SEC – MOTION SEC TO APPROVE FORWARDING P 802. 15. 1 TO REVCOM – 5. PROVIDE PROJECT PLANNING UPDATE -00/375 r 2 – 6. PROVIDE SESSION #16/DALLAS OBJECTIVES, IF ANY. Submission 8 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Submissions

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Submissions • Via flash and http: //ieee 802. org/15/pub/Download. html – 01/420 r 10 [01420 r 10 P 802 -15_WG-SB 1 -SB 2 -802 -15 -1 -Comment. DB. xls] – 01/451 TG 1 -Nov 01 Meeting Objectives and Agenda xls Gifford – 01/457 TG 1 Nov 01 Minutes doc Gifford – 01/462 WG-TG 1 Opening Report Nov 01 ppt Gifford • Appendix A - 01/462 r 1 a [01462 r 1 a. P 802 -15_WG-P 802. 15. 1 -Rev. Com. Submission. pdf] – 01/467 WG-Liaison Report Nov 01 ppt Gifford • Draft Submissions, via http: //ieee 802. org/15/pub/SB 2. html – Draft Std IEEE P 802. 15. 1/D 1. 0. 1 [99001 D 10 P 802 -151__Draft_Standard. pdf] – "Change bar" Draft Std IEEE P 802. 15. 1/D 1. 0. 1[99001 D 10 P 802 -151__Draft_Standard. pdf] Submission 9 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Graphic

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Session #15/Austin – Graphic Submission 10 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15 Working

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks™ Sponsor Ballots (SBs) Summary Report Submission 11 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SBs Summary Report •

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SBs Summary Report • Sponsor Ballot #1, passed @89% – 30 Day Electronic Ballot • 27 Jul 01 Opened • 25 Aug 01 Closed • Sponsor Ballot #2, passed @89% – 10 Day Electronic Recirculation Ballot • 2 Oct 01 Opened • 11 Oct 01 Closed The BRC continues to communicate to the three (3) DISAPPROVING Balloters and we are happy to report that one (1) DISAPPROVING Balloter has reviewed the resolutions and changed his initial and recirculation vote from DISAPPROVING to YES WITH COMMENTS (see – 01/420 r 10 Comment #7) on 12 Oct 01. This 3 to 2 change to the sponsor ballots up the affirmation to 93%. Submission 12 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 1 Summary Report

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 1 Summary Report • • • P 802. 15. 1/D 0. 9. 2 Closing date: 2001 -08 -25 The report is the result from the group: 0000130 • 1. This ballot has met the 75% returned ballot requirement. – – – 33 eligible people in this ballot group. 26 affirmative votes 3 negative votes 1 abstention votes 30 votes received • 90% returned • 3% abstention • 2. The 75% affirmation requirement is being met. – 26 affirmative votes – 3 negative votes – 29 votes • 89% affirmative Source: -01/420 r 10 Submission 13 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 2 Summary Report

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 2 Summary Report • • P 802. 15. 1/D 1. 0. 1 Recirculation Closing date: 2001 -10 -11 This is a recirculation ballot. The report collates the results from the following groups: 0000130 0000169. 1. This ballot has met the 75% returned ballot requirement. – – – 33 eligible people in this ballot group. 26 affirmative votes 3 negative votes 2 abstention votes 31 votes received • 93% returned • 6% abstention • 2. The 75% affirmation requirement is being met. – 26 affirmative votes – 3 negative votes – 29 votes • 89% affirmative Source: -01/420 r 10 Submission 14 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SBs Summary Report (cont.

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SBs Summary Report (cont. ) Source: -01/420 r 10 Submission 15 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 1 Summary Report

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 1 Summary Report (cont. ) • Comment Resolution, as of 24 Sep 01 – 6 Balloters commented (Thanks!) – 95 new comments • 65 Editorial comments, 3 rejected • 30 Technical comments, 19 unresolved • Source for Application for approval of P 802. 15. 1 – 01462 r 1 a. P 802 -15_WG-P 802. 15. 1 -Rev. Com-Submission. pdf – Page 10 -30 of this submission contains the “Unresolved negative comments and rebuttal report” (19 of 95 unresolved) • Unresolved-negative-comments-and-rebuttal-report. pdf Source: -01/420 r 10 Submission 16 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 1 Summary Report

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 SB 1 Summary Report (cont. ) Source: -01/420 r 10 Submission 17 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Comment Status (cont. )

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Comment Status (cont. ) • • • The “C” in the Response Status column indicates that the comment (whether Accepted or Rejected) is considered CLOSED by the letter ballot comment resolution team. In the case of an AC, this means that the comment was accept, changes applied, and the comment is now closed. In the case of an RC, this means that the comment was not accepted, no change applied, decline letter sent, and the comment is now closed. The “U” in the Response Status column indicates that the comment is UNSATISFIED by the letter ballot comment resolution team. The team has not been able to reach final closure on this comment due to a needed response from the Bluetooth Special Interest Group. This is not to be confused with the opinion (i. e. unsatisfied) of the original commenter. The “Z” in the Response Status column indicates that the comment was WITHDRAWN by the original commenter and thus no further consideration by the letter ballot comment resolution team. Source: -01/420 r 10 Submission 18 David Cypher & Ian Gifford

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15. 1

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15. 1 Current Project Planning • Jul 99 – Initial Discussion on Proposals. • Nov 99 – Initial draft ready for WG ballot. • Jan 00 – First Ballot complete, second ballot kicked off. • Mar 01 • Jul 01 – Draft ready for IEEE sponsor ballot. • Sep 01 • Nov 01 • Dec 01 802. 15. 1 Project Target & 802 Sponsor Expectation 26 Oct 01 – Approval by IEEE Standards Board Submission 19 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Tentative Needs for Jan

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 Tentative Needs for Jan 02 Interim • 21 -25 Jan 02 (5 Days) – ~0 People TG 1 leadership is not planning to attend the Jan 02 Interim. Submission 20 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 802. 15. 1 Drafting

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 802. 15. 1 Drafting History • • Draft 0. 0 - Tom Siep 100% Draft 0. 1 - Tom Siep 100% Draft 0. 2 - Tom Siep 100% Draft 0. 3 - Tom Siep 100% • • Draft 0. 4 - Tom Siep 100% Draft 0. 5 - BT-IEEE Editorial Working Group – – – • • Draft 0. 9. 2 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – – 331 Pages 1 Chief Editor/6 Technical Editors 6 Bluetooth Promoter Company Reviewers w/ internal help ~300 Comments • • 617 Pages 1165 Pages 1 Chief Editor/3 Technical Editors 0 comments Draft 1. 1 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – – 803 Pages 1 Chief Editor/11 Technical Editors 1159 Pages 1 Chief Editor/3 Technical Editors 60 comments Draft 1. 0. 1 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – – 308 Pages 1013 Comments 1159 Pages 1 Chief Editor/7 Technical Editors 71 comments 1159 Pages 1 Project Editor 0 comments Draft 0. 7. 2 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – – • • Draft 0. 7. 1 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – • 283 Pages Draft 0. 7 – Tom Siep 100% – Draft 0. 9. 1 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – – Draft 0. 6 - BT-IEEE Editorial Working Group – – • • 773 Pages 1 Chief Editor/11 Technical Editors 412 Comments Draft 0. 7. 3 – Jennifer Longman, IEEE-SA Project Editor 100% Draft 0. 7. 4 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors Draft 0. 8. 0 - IEEE 802. 15 Task Group 1 Technical Editors – – – Submission 1130 Pages 1 Chief Editor/7 Technical Editors 376 comments 21 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15 Future

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 IEEE 802. 15 Future Meetings • January 21 -25, 2002, Dallas, TX USA, Wyndham Anatole, 802. 15 Interim Meeting*. • March 11 -14, 2002 St Louis, MO USA, Hyatt Regency, 802 Plenary Meeting. • May 13 -17, 2002, Sydney, NSW, AU, Wentworth Sydney Hotel, Interim Meeting*. • July 8 -11, 2002 Vancouver, BC Canada, Hyatt Regency, 802 Plenary Meeting. • September 16 -20, 2002, Hyatt Regency Monterey, 802. 15 Interim Meeting*. • November 11 -14, 2002 Koloa, HI USA, Hyatt Regency Kauai, 802 Plenary Meeting. • More Info: – http: //ieee 802. org/15/pub/Meeting_Plan. html – http: //ieee 802. org/meeting/ Submission 22 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 More Info: • IEEE

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 More Info: • IEEE 802. 15 – http: //ieee 802. org/15/ • Standards Process-at-a-Glance – http: //standards. ieee. org/resources/glance. html Submission 23 Ian Gifford, Consultant

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 In conclusion, the Project

May 2001 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -01/462 r 1 In conclusion, the Project 802. 15. 1 would like to leave you with this slide Submission 24 Ian Gifford, Consultant