March 2013 doc IEEE 15 13 0227 01

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m Project: IEEE P 802. 15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks(WPANs) Submission Title: TG 4 m 4 TV Closing Report for March 2013 Date Submitted: 21 March 2013 Source: Sangsung Choi(ETRI), Phil Beecher (Wi-SUN Alliance) Contact: Sangsung Choi(ETRI) Voice: +82 42 860 6831, E-Mail: sschoi@etri. re. kr Re: TG 4 m Closing Report for March 2013 Plenary Meeting Abstract: Closing Report for TG 4 m Session in Orlando Purpose: TV White Space Amendment to IEEE 802. 15. 4 Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P 802. 15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein. Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P 802. 15. TG 4 m Slide 1 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m Meeting Goal This Week • Comment Resolutions for LB#87 • Hear and discuss the contribution presentations • Discuss the future efforts and next steps TG 4 m Slide 2 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m Meeting Slots Mtg Tuesday AM 1 • Opening Logistics • Contribution presentations if any • Comment Resolution (General Issues) • Comment Resolution, (General Issues, PHY, and MAC) AM 2 • Comment Resolution (FSK PHY) • Comment Resolution, (Wrap-up) • Discuss future efforts and next steps PM 1 • Comment Resolution (OFDM PHY) • Comment Resolution, MAC PM 2 • Comment Resolution, (NB-OFDM PHY) • Comment Resolution, MAC (cont'd) TG 4 m Wednesday Slide 3 Thursday Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m TG 4 m Closing Report (1) • LB #87 was passed by 88% of Approval in March 2013 - 125 Voters - 97 Voting (Yes 83, No 11, Abstain 3) • Resolve 551 Comments (Editorial 302, Technical & General 249) – Resolved all Technical and General comments • FSK, OFDM, NB-OFDM, Ranging, General PHY, and Coexistence Assurance – Resolved all Editorial comments with the proposed resolutions by assignees – Comment resolution database document #15 -13 -0107 -05 -004 m completed TG 4 m Slide 4 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m TG 4 m Closing Report (2) • Technical Comment related Documents presented – – – – 15 -13 -0131 -00 -004 m-example-encoding-for-tvws-fsk-phy 15 -13 -0138 -02 -004 m-lb 87 -proposed-resolution-bar 15 -13 -0147 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-cids-4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10 -and-11 15 -13 -0148 -00 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-cids-14 -15 -16 -17 -18 -19 -20 -21 -and-22 15 -13 -0149 -02 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-cids-36 -37 -38 -39 -40 -41 -42 -43 -44 -and-45 15 -13 -0150 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-cids-128 -129 -130 -131 -132 -133 -and-134 15 -13 -0151 -00 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-cids-195 -197 -198 -199 -200 -and-201 15 -13 -0152 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-cids-223 -224 -225 -226 -227 -228 -229 -231 -233 and-234 15 -13 -0159 -02 -004 m-proposed-comment-resolution-for-device-location-and-channel-info-ies 15 -13 -0161 -02 -004 m-comment-resolution-for-some-tg 4 m-tvws-fsk-phy-related-commentsspread-sheet 15 -13 -0163 -00 -004 m-Proposed-OFDM-Comment-Resolutions-for-CIDs-379 -through-396 LB 87 15 -13 -0164 -02 -004 m-Proposed-OFDM-Comment-Resolutions-for-CIDs-400 -through-416 LB 87 15 -13 -0166 -01 -004 m-15. 4 m-Coexistence-Assurance-Document TG 4 m Slide 5 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m TG 4 m Closing Report (3) • Technical Comment related Documents presented (cont’d) – – – – 15 -13 -0168 -01 -004 m-Proposed-Resolutions-for-Coexistence-Comments-LB 87 15 -13 -0176 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolution-to-cid-408 -of-lb-87 15 -13 -0177 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-to-general-phy-comments-of-lb-87 15 -13 -0178 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-to-some-fsk-phy-comments-of-lb-87 15 -13 -0183 -04 -004 m-some-comment-resolution-for-tg 4 m-tvws-nb-ofdm 15 -13 -0186 -03 -004 m-comment-resolution-for-some-tg 4 m-tvws-nb-ofdm-phy-related-comments -spread-sheet 15 -13 -0196 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-to-dev-comments-of-lb-87 15 -13 -0197 -00 -004 m-Proposed OFDM RF Requirements 15 -13 -0198 -00 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-to-dev-comments-of-lb-87 -ppt 15 -13 -0200 -00 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-to-comments-related-to-power-saving-and-enabling 15 -13 -0203 -00 -004 m-proposed-resolution-to-pics-comment-of-lb-87 15 -13 -0205 -03 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-for-tmctp-technical-comments-of-lb-87 15 -13 -0208 -01 -004 m-comment-resolution-for-annex-s-cid-514 -547 15 -13 -0209 -01 -004 m-some-comment-resolutions-for-tg 4 m-ranging 15 -13 -0210 -01 -004 m-proposed-resolution-to-misc 15 -13 -0219 -00 -004 m-proposed-resolutions-to-remaining-comments-of-lb 87 TG 4 m Slide 6 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m TG 4 m Motion (1) The motion is to accept the resolutions as proposed in document 15 -13 -107 -04 with additional changes as described in 15 -13 -219 -00 and 15 -13 -197 -00 Editorials will be marked Moved: Gilb Second: Rolfe Motion carried by 85% of approval (Yes 34, No 6, Abstain 1) TG 4 m Slide 7 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m TG 4 m Motion (2) Move that the 802. 15. 4 m Task Group start a WG Letter Ballot Recirculation of Letter Ballot 87 edited in accordance with the instructions in comment resolution database document #15 -130107 -05 -004 m Moved: Clint Powell Seconded: Chin-Sean Sum Motion carried by 93% of approval (Yes 40, No 3, Abstain 3) TG 4 m Slide 8 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m TG 4 m Motion (3) CS Sum, C Powell, Soo-Young Chang, H Harada, B Rolfe, K Waheed, R Salazar, C Seibert, A Petrick, M Gillmore, J Kent, F Kojima, A Liru, M Zhou, K Shah, J Gilb, Mi-Kyung Oh, Recommended Chair: P Beecher Move to recommend to the 802. 15 WG to appoint the above members as a BRC for TG 4 m Moved: Jay Ramasastry Seconded: Matt Gillmore Motion carried unanimously Call time : 3 pm Pacific, Wednesdays TG 4 m Slide 9 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m WG Motion (1) Move that 802. 15 WG approve start of a recirculation of the WG Letter Ballot 87 draft d 0 P 802 -15 -4 m_Draft_Standard, edited in accordance with the instructions in document #1513 -0107 -05 -004 m, to Sponsor Ballot. Moved: Phil Beecher Seconded: Clint Powell TG 4 m Slide 10 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m WG Motion (2) CS Sum, C Powell, Soo-Young Chang, H Harada, B Rolfe, K Waheed, R Salazar, C Seibert, A Petrick, M Gillmore, J Kent, F Kojima, A Liru, M Zhou, K Shah, J Gilb, Mi. Kyung Oh, Recommended Chair: P Beecher Motion: The 802. 15 WG appoint the above members as a BRC for 802. 15 TG 4 m Moved: Ed Callaway Seconded: Phil Beecher TG 4 m Slide 11 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m Future Plan/Timeline (1) • Form a New Task Group - Affirm new officers for TG 4 m 2011 - Prepare the TGD - Finalizing the TGD & Call for Proposal September November, 2011, January 2012 March 2012 • Proposal Effort - Preliminary Proposals & Presentations - Final Proposals - Proposal Presentations - Merge Proposals - Adopt Baseline May 6 2012 July 9, 2012 July , 2012 September 2012 • Drafting - Preliminary draft document - Final draft (ready for WG Letter Ballot) TG 4 m Slide 12 November 2012 January 2013 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)

March 2013 doc. : IEEE 15 -13 -0227 -01 -004 m Future Plan/Timeline (2) • WG Letter Balloting - Initial Release - Comment Resolution - Recirculation I Release - Recirculation I Comment Resolution - Recirculation II Release February 2013 March 2013 April 2013 May 2013 June 2013 • Sponsor Balloting - Initial Release - Comment Resolution - SB Recirculation I Release - SB Recirculation I Comment Resolution - SB Recirculation II release TG 4 m Slide 13 July 2013 September 2013 October 2013 November 2013 December 2013 Sangsung Choi(ETRI)