March 2003 doc IEEE 802 15 03077 r

  • Slides: 11
Download presentation
March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 IEEE P 802. 15

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 IEEE P 802. 15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks IEEE 802. 15. 2 WLAN/WPAN Coexistence Task Group Closing Report Dallas, TX Submission 1 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot • The

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot • The sponsor ballot completed on Sunday March 9. • Results of the sponsor ballot – 66 voters – 38 yes – 2 no – 4 abstain – 95% affirmative • Return ratio 66% < 75% required – Ballot will be kept open for up to 60 days until we reach a 75% return ratio. Submission 2 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot • Ballot

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot • Ballot stayed open. Current tally – 66 voters – 43 yes – 2 no – 5 abstain – 76% return ratio – 95. 6% affirmative • We expect the ballot to close on March 19. • Following pages gives detailed breakdown of voting. Submission 3 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote Tech Edit BRC Jim Allen Reza Arefi Abstain Eladio Arvelo Yes Morris Balamut John Barnet Vilas Bhade Benjamin Chen Todor Cookley Yes Todd Cooper Yes Kenneth Cornet Vern Dubendorf Yes Sourav Dutta Yes Submission 4 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote Tech Avraham Feedman Yes 2 Theo Georgantas Abstain Ian Gifford Yes James Gilb Yes Robert Grow Abstain Raj Gubbi Yes Jose Gutierrez Yes Chris Guy Yes Edit BRC Missing Comments 35 17 30 14 T comments actually E. Remaining T comments: One accepted. Two rejected – both changes would cause error. New vote Zion Hadad Karen Halford Stephen Halford Yes Simon Harrison Yes Submission 5 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote Robert Heile Yes Tech Edit BRC Downing Hopkins Stuart Kerry Yes Srinivas Kandala Yes James Kemerling Yes Pat Kinney Yes Joe Kubler Yes Jim Lansford Yes Ping-Chen Law Yes New vote Dan Levesque Jie Liang Randolph Little Submission Yes 6 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote Greg Luri Yes Tech Edit BRC Roger Marks Peter Martini Yes George Miao Yes Andrew Myles Yes Paul Nikolich No Erwin Noble Yes Tim O’Farrell No Chris Osterloh Yes 1 T comment actually E. Out of scope of TG 2. 1 2 T comment actually E. Rejected. Richard Paine John Pardee Subbu Ponnuswamy Submission Yes 7 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote Tech Edit BRC Hugo Pues Abstain Vikram Puni Yes Mike Rudnick Yes Tom Siep Yes New vote John Sarallo Yes New vote John Sargent Yes New vote Michael Seals Yes Steve Shellhammer Yes Neil Shipp Yes Gill Shultz Yes Kevin Smart Yes Osman Sakr Submission 2 T comments actually E. Rejected both – one change would cause error. Other change is unnecessary, current text clear. 8 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Sponsor Ballot Name Vote Carl Stephenson Yes Larry Telle Yes Tech Edit BRC New vote William Watte Hung-vu Wei Yes Forrest Wright Abstain Oren Yuen Yes Submission 9 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Schedule • Sponsor ballot

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Schedule • Sponsor ballot close on March 19. • Recirculation ballot – Begin on March 24. – End on April 8. • Executive Committee electronic ballot to put TG 2 on Rev Com agenda for June – Begin April 9 – End on April 19 (ahead of May 5 deadline) Submission 10 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Motion • Working Group

March 2003 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -03/077 r 0 Motion • Working Group to empower the TG 2 ballot review committee to apply edits to draft. – Move – Second – Yes – No – Abstain Submission Steve Shellhammer David Cypher 11 Steve Shellhammer, Symbol Technologies