MAKING EFFICIENT IMPLEMENTATIONOF THE MONITORING MATRIX RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS
methodology
well put theory about what enabling environment is and what are its structural building blocks.
perspective: legislation vs. practice
perceptions
practice legal framework
practice attitudes values expectations media representations legal framework
issue: standardizing how data is structured, sourced and interpreted
mutually agreed theory == agreement on interpretation
standardizing data gathering is paramount to enhance the proficiency of the analyses.
commonly agreed hierarchy of sources which will be applied to all practice-based indicators. Primary data registers Survey Secondary applicable data Focus group Interview
diverging instruments for data gathering and analysis
the information must provide a comprehen-sive answer and not only indicate a state of play
Standard Indicator (s) Data sources Instrume nts Scoring principle Principle careful re-evaluation of what the indicators mean, dispersing them into building blocks and agree exactly what kind of data is needed for each of them
issue with scoring: 1) no detail what scores mean at indicator level
issue with scoring: 2) it is not clear whether current weights are appropriate
issue with scoring: 3) not implemented by all partners
VISUAL PRESENTATION
OPTIMIZING THE REPORTING WORKLOAD
Data gathering Legal Framework + Practice in two areas Final Report Y 2 Analysis and assesments Reporting Y 1 Data gathering Legal Framework + Practice in two areas
invite contributing organizations
NEW POLICY ENVIRONMENT: NEGOTIATIONS
WRAP UP: • Unify approach in research thus increase comparative potential • Implement a two year cycle of reporting • Improve the scoring exercise • Improve presentation