Kerr festival Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch 2004 Reflection

  • Slides: 27
Download presentation
Kerr festival Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch 2004

Kerr festival Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch 2004

Reflection from horizon of black holes Michael Kuchiev School of Physics, UNSW Kerr Festival

Reflection from horizon of black holes Michael Kuchiev School of Physics, UNSW Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Plan: • Reflection on the horizon • Escape effect from under the horizon, information

Plan: • Reflection on the horizon • Escape effect from under the horizon, information extraction • Conclusion RH and EE do exist Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Black holes Impossible What is lost indeed (Что упало то пропало ) (Except for

Black holes Impossible What is lost indeed (Что упало то пропало ) (Except for Hawking effect) And here Escape is Perfect prison possible ! What happens here ? Reflection ! Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Schwarzschild black hole: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Schwarzschild black hole: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Kruskal plane: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Kruskal plane: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Hawking radiation: The event horizon of a (Schwarzschild) black hole has a finite temperature

Hawking radiation: The event horizon of a (Schwarzschild) black hole has a finite temperature Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Classical process – no radiation Quantum process - Hawking radiation Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Classical process – no radiation Quantum process - Hawking radiation Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

New effect – reflection on horizon • Classically there is no reflection on the

New effect – reflection on horizon • Classically there is no reflection on the horizon. • Conventionally this fact is taken as a proof that the incoming particle inevitably goes inside a black hole (and stays thereafter). • Quantum treatment reveals that there is a probability for the incoming particle to bounce from the horizon back, into the outside world. Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Reflection on the horizon Incoming particles Reflection on horizon Black Hole Kerr Festival 2004

Reflection on the horizon Incoming particles Reflection on horizon Black Hole Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch Grey factor

Consider Schwarzschild black hole: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Consider Schwarzschild black hole: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Klein-Gordon equation for scalar massless particle, s- wave Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Klein-Gordon equation for scalar massless particle, s- wave Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Boundary condition on the horizon: Here R is the reflection coefficient. • R=0 is

Boundary condition on the horizon: Here R is the reflection coefficient. • R=0 is the conventional assumption. • |R|>0 means that there is the reflection. Question: HOW to find R ? Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Classically there is no reflection, of course Motion in conventional coordinates In Kruskal coordinates

Classically there is no reflection, of course Motion in conventional coordinates In Kruskal coordinates Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

How to verify that |R>0 ? Idea: use analytical properties of the wave function.

How to verify that |R>0 ? Idea: use analytical properties of the wave function. Im r Consider complex plane r Re r 1 r Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Analytical continuation gives: Im 1 This is fundamentally important, verified below Kerr Festival 2004

Analytical continuation gives: Im 1 This is fundamentally important, verified below Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch Re r r

Miracle: there is the reflection on the horizon ! Probability of reflection on the

Miracle: there is the reflection on the horizon ! Probability of reflection on the horizon: Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

For Kerr black holes When black holes behave as reflectors ! Kerr Festival 2004

For Kerr black holes When black holes behave as reflectors ! Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Kruskal plane: Im 1 Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch Re r r

Kruskal plane: Im 1 Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch Re r r

Escape effect - particle escapes ! Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Escape effect - particle escapes ! Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Hawking process – pair production Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Hawking process – pair production Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Probability of escape Pout is the probability that the particle escapes, Pin is the

Probability of escape Pout is the probability that the particle escapes, Pin is the probability that the particle exists inside. Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Temperature bath Escape effect => radiation with temp T Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Temperature bath Escape effect => radiation with temp T Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

No bath Radiation due to escape effect still exists. However, the information goes out

No bath Radiation due to escape effect still exists. However, the information goes out ! Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Conclusions: • • The horizon reflects particles A particle can escape The information can

Conclusions: • • The horizon reflects particles A particle can escape The information can be retrieved from under the horizon A number of fundamental issues related to black holes are to be affected: • • Black holes at early stages of the universe Primordial black holes – interaction with matter Entropy of black holes Etc, there is a long way to go Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch

Acknowledgments l. Roy Kerr, thank you for the solution and the birthday party l.

Acknowledgments l. Roy Kerr, thank you for the solution and the birthday party l. Some results presented were obtained in collaboration with Victor Flambaum. l. Support of the Australian Research Council is acknowledged. l. Resources and slides from Internet were used. l. Kerr Patience of the listeners is much Festival 2004 Christchurch

References: • • • M. Yu. Kuchiev, Europhys. Lett. 65, 445 (2004). M. Yu.

References: • • • M. Yu. Kuchiev, Europhys. Lett. 65, 445 (2004). M. Yu. Kuchiev, Phys. Rev. D 69, 124031 (2004). M. Yu. Kuchiev, gr-qc/0310008. M. Yu. Kuchiev and V. V. Flambaum, Scattering of scalar particles by black holes, Phys. Rev. D 69, 124031 (2004) M. Yu. Kuchiev and V. V. Flambaum, Phys. Rev D 70, 044022 (2004) M. Yu. Kuchiev, V. V. Flambaum, gr-qc/0407077 Kerr Festival 2004 Christchurch