July 2009 doc IEEE 802 15 09581 r

July 2009 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -09/581 r 0 802. 15. 3 c Sponsor Ballot Status • Date 2 nd ballot recirculation closed: 7 July 2009 • Vote tally: – – 161 affirmative 7 negative with comments 1 negative without comments 8 abstain • Comments supporting remaining disapprove votes and WG responses in document 15 -09 -0571 -00 -003 c • 3 rd Recirculation began 16 July 2009, • Resolution meeting: 28 July, 2009, 9 am JST, 27 July, 2009, 5 pm PST, 2 hours Submission Robert F. Heile, Zig. Bee Alliance

July 2009 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -09/581 r 0 802. 15. 3 c Sponsor Ballot Summary Initial 1 st recirculation 2 nd recirculation Approve 157 (94%) 159 (95%) 162 (95%) Disapprove 9 8 6 (1 changed after ballot) Abstain 8 8 8 Total 174 175 177 (1 disapprove w/o comments) # comments 207 63 9 (with approve vote) • No new valid disapprove votes in last recirculation. • No new comments from previous disapprove voter • Based on comments from approve voter, 3 small technical changes were needed • 3 rd recirculation began 16 July 2009 Submission Robert F. Heile, Zig. Bee Alliance

July 2009 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -09/581 r 0 Summary of Unsatisfied Comments from Disapprove Voters Ballot Accepted Principle Disagree Out of scope Unresolvable Total Initial 19 12 12 1 0 44 1 st recirc 0 0 0 2 nd recirc 0 0 0 Total 19 12 12 1 0 44 (lost contact with voter) Submission Robert F. Heile, Zig. Bee Alliance

July 2009 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -09/581 r 0 802. 15. 3 c Draft Status Comment Resolution Summary and Detail: • The 12 rejected comments fell into 6 categories, which were more philosophical in character such as “change MAC aggregation scheme”, “delete a particular PHY mode, ” “too many PHY options”, and such • One comment related to the use of “ 48 vs 64 bit addressing”. Given that this is a PHY amendment and the comment concerned a MAC issue it classified as out-of scope • The full comment resolution file can be found at https: //mentor. ieee. org/802. 15/dcn/09/15 -09 -0571 -01 -003 c -combined-sb-disapprove-comments. xls. Submission Robert F. Heile, Zig. Bee Alliance

July 2009 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -09/581 r 0 Motion passed in Working Group Motion: Move that 802. 15 WG request Conditional Executive Committee Approval to forward the P 802 -15 -3 c latest draft to Rev. Com Moved by Shu Kato Seconded by Phil Beecher Yes: 31 No: 0 Abstain: 0 Submission Robert F. Heile, Zig. Bee Alliance

July 2009 doc. : IEEE 802. 15 -09/581 r 0 Motion to the Executive Committee • Motion: The 802. 15 WG requests Conditional Approval from the Executive Committee to forward the P 802 -15 -3 c latest draft to Rev. Com • Mover: Bob Heile • Second: James Gilb Submission Robert F. Heile, Zig. Bee Alliance