July 2008 doc IEEE 802 11 080797 r

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 LB 129 PHY Ad Hoc Comment Resolution Status Authors: Submission Date: 2008 -07 -16 1 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Abstract • This is running LB 129 PHY ad hoc comment resolution status. • Minutes from the PHY Ad hoc conference calls on June 25, 2008 and July 2, 2008 are included. • Minutes from the Ad hoc meeting in Denver on July 10, 2008 are included. • Minutes from the Ad hoc meeting in Denver on July 1416, 2008 are included. Submission 2 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 LB 129 PHY Comments Summary • There are 83 PHY LB 129 comments assigned to the PHY Ad hoc. • Number of CIDs, comment groups, and assignees are as follows: – – – – – Submission 5 16 2 1 8 38 4 4 3 2 PHY Coding PHY Data PHY Intro PHY MCS PHY PLCP PHY Preamble PHY Regulatory PHY service PHY Spec PHY PLME (Eldad Perahia) (Douglas Chan) (Vinko Erceg) (Eldad Perahia) (Vinko Erceg) (Douglas Chan) (Vinko Erceg) 3 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Conference Call Minutes of June 25, 2008 and July 2, 2008 • Vinko Erceg presented document 11 -08/0743 r 0 and r 1 (18 CIDs) – Resolutions for CIDs 7473, 7474, 7475, 7476, 7477, 8071, 7457, 7458, 7459, 7460, 7469, 7470, 7471, 7472, 7538, and 8072 as shown in document 11 -08/0743 r 2 were accepted unanimously by the Ad hoc group during the conference calls. – CIDs 8097 and 8098 were removed from the document and will be presented as a part of a separate submission. – Revision history is included in the document. Submission 4 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Plans For Denver IEEE Meeting • Following presentations are planned for Denver meeting: – Eldad Perahia: 08 -11/0733 r 0 and 08 -11/0734 r 0 (Coding, Data, Preamble) – Douglas Chan: 08 -11/0785 r 0 (Intro, MCS, Spec) – Raja Banerjea/Matthew Fischer/Adrian Stephens: CIDs 8097 and 8098 Submission 5 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Minutes of Denver Ad hoc Meeting July 10, 2008 (1) • Eldad Perahia presented submission 08 -11/0733 r 0. – Resolutions to all CIDs were accepted unanimously by the Ad hoc group. There was no objection to present CIDs in this document for a motion in the Plenary meeting next week. • Eldad Perahia presented submission 08 -11/0734 r 0. – Resolution to CIDs 7516, 7517, 7520, 7523 were changed to “Accept”. There was no objection from the Ad hoc group. – Resolution to CIDs 7521, 7522 were changed to “Counter”. There was no objection from the Ad hoc group. – Final document is 08 -11/0734 r 1, no objection to be presented for a motion in the Plenary next week. Submission 6 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Minutes of Denver Ad hoc Meeting July 10, 2008 (2) • Douglas Chan presented submission 08 -11/0785 r 0. – Proposed resolution text was changed for CIDs 7047 and 7468. – Final document is 08 -11/0785 r 1, no objection to be presented for a motion in the Plenary next week. • There was no objection to present submission 1108/0743 r 2 for a motion in the Plenary next week. This submission was discussed during the past conference calls. Submission 7 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Minutes of Denver Ad hoc Meeting July 1416, 2008 • Harish Ramamurthy presented submission 0811/0805 r 1. • Adrian Stephens presented submission 08 -11/0817 r 0 • Both submissions deal with remaining CIDs 8097 and 8098. • After many discussions final document is 08 -11/0805 r 5 (includes proposed resolutions submission 08 -11/817 r 0). Submission 8 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Motion # 345 • Move to accept comment resolutions in spreadsheet 1108 -0800 -01 -000 n-LB 129 -PHY-comment-resolutionspreadsheet. xls tab “PHY Motion Set A”. – 81 PHY CIDs were resolved – Resolutions were accepted without objection by the Ad hoc group • TGn vote: accepted unanimously Submission 9 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom

July 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0797 r 2 Motion #354 • Move to accept comment resolutions in spreadsheet 1108 -0800 -03 -000 n-LB 129 -PHY-comment-resolutionspreadsheet. xls tab “PHY Motion Set B”. – 2 remaining CIDs are included: 8097 and 8098 – Resolutions were accepted without objection by the Ad hoc group • TGn vote: 18 Yes/1 No/15 Abs Submission 10 Vinko Erceg, Broadcom