January 2008 doc IEEE 802 11 080060 r

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 BEAM Ad Hoc Status report January 2008 Authors: Submission Date: 2008 -01 -10 1 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 Abstract BEAM Ad Hoc January 2008 agenda and report regarding comment resolution for LB 115 (802. 11 n) Submission 2 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 Beam ad hoc process (Agreed in Orlando) • Assign volunteers to take responsibility for individual comment groups – Volunteers to review comments, and provide submissions on resolution, or recruit other volunteers to provide submissions – If necessary, they can propose to reassign some comments to others • Resolutions require 75% or greater in ad hoc to be brought to motion in TGn • Resolutions that get greater than 50% but less than 75% will be brought to TGn for further discussion and consideration. Submission 3 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 LB 115 Beam Adhoc Comment Status as of Dec 31, 2007 • Current spreadsheet: – 11 -07 -2701 -05 -000 n-TGn-LB 115 -Beam-Comments. xls • Total of 72 comments assigned to Beam ad hoc – All comments currently assigned to volunteers for resolution • We have resolved 34 comments in Atlanta (Nov 2007) and 39 comments to go (one comment is transferred in). Submission 4 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 Current Comment Group Assignments • Calibration: 11 comments (Yuichi) – 07/2975 r 0 -proposed-resolution-to-calibration. doc (presented and will be revised for next week) • Channel sounding: 3 comments (Bjorn) – CID 5390/5393 addressed in 07/2900 r 3 (Hongyuan) and 07/2756 r 1 (Bjorn): presented and deferred for further discussion – CID 5528 transferred in from General adhoc (assigned to Bjorn) • Explicit Quant: 1 comment (Eldad) – CID 5273 is withdrawn. • Explicit Tx. BF: 19 comments – CID 5075 & 5076: Doug Chan– plan to submit a contribution in the main meeting next week – 8 comments (Clause 7): Joonsuk – 08/0059 r 0 -lb 115 -comment-resolution-forexplicit-Tx. BF. doc (covered 3 comments): presented and agreed – 11 comments (Clause 9): Vinko – 08/0025 r 1 -lb 115 -beam-explicit-Tx. BF-commentsresolution. doc (agreed except deferred CID 5682 -5686) • NDP: 1 comment (John K. ) – CID 5487 deferred from 07/2739 r 0 • Tx. BF (misc): 4 comments (John K. ) – 08/0008 r 0 -lb 115 -misc-beam-comment-resolution. doc: presented and agreed Submission 5 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 LB 115 Beam Adhoc Comment Status as of Jan 12, 2008 • Current spreadsheet: – 11 -07 -2701 -07 -000 n-TGn-LB 115 -Beam-Comments. xls • Total of 72 comments assigned to Beam ad hoc – All comments currently assigned to volunteers for resolution • We have resolved 34 comments in Atlanta (Nov 2007) and 9 comments in Taipei adhoc meeting (Jan 2008). We will have 30 comments to go (one comment is transferred in). Submission 6 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 Plan for the main meeting, Taiwan • Tuesday AM 2 – Resolved comments covered in 07/2975 r 1(Calibration, 11 CIDs), 08/0025 r 3(Explicit Tx. BF, 11 CIDs), CID 5528, 5075, 5076. – CID 5487 is rejected (Y/N/A = 7/0/2). – Prepare for the motion on Tuesday EVE with these 26 CIDs and 7 CIDs (08/0008 r 0, 08/0059 r 0) resolved last week. (33 CIDs in total) • Wednesday PM 1 – 08/0129 r 0(Explicit Tx. BF part II, 3 CIDs) and 07/2900 r 4(Channel sounding, 2 CIDs). – Prepare for the motion on Thursday. Submission 7 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom

January 2008 doc. : IEEE 802. 11 -08/0060 r 3 Beam January Pending Motion #1 • Move to approve the 33 comment resolutions contained in the tab labeled “Beam January Motion #1” in 11 -072701 -09 -000 n-TGn-LB 115 -Beam-Comments. xls – 5075, 5076, 5482, 5483, 5484, 5662, 5678, 5171, 5679, 5680, 5681, 5682, 5683, 5684, 5685, 5686, 5487, 5054, 5057, 5056, 5059, 5528, 5492, 5846, 5847, 5670, 5671, 5672, 5673, 5674, 5675, 5170, 5676 Submission 8 Joonsuk Kim, Broadcom