Interoperability standards the IVLab Group Martin Zelm CIMOSA

Interoperability standards - the I-VLab Group Martin Zelm, CIMOSA Association martin. zelm@cimosa. de INTEROP-Vlab General Assembly Brussels, June 9, 2011 Date. Brussels, June 9, 2011 Title 1

Objectives Create awareness of I-VLab standardisation efforts and related work in standards organisations, via • Promote EI standardisation results via workshops and conferences • Cooperate with R&D Projects and EI initiatives • Coordinate the standards TF in the FIn. ES Cluster • Participate in SDO working groups Resources: An expert group composed of members of the I-VLab Poles GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 2

Standardisation Concepts • De jure standards - De facto standards • Framework – implementation type • Top down - bottom up development • Areas: ICT, Enterprise, e. Business, Internet, Telecom, Trade, Finance… • Relation ICT Research and Standards, COPRAS Report, Standardisation Guidelines for ICT projects interfacing with ICT standards organizations* (* CEN, ETSI, W 3 C, Open Group, DG Inf. Society 2007) GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 3

EI Standards …in development or implementation with I-VLab contributions (Poles) • CEN/ISO 11354 Part 1 Requirements for establishing manufacturing enterprise process interoperability, status DIS, Part 2: Maturity model for assessing enterprise interoperability, (active: DFI, PGSO) • ISO 22400: Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for manufacturing operations management, status CD (active: DFI) • OMG: Soa. ML Specifications for service modelling language, status CD under review. (active: North. Pole) • Implementation of e. Business standards in SME networks of the Textile/Clothing Industry: specification, conformance testing and implementation support (active: Italian Pole) GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 4

IFIP WG 5. 8 List of EI relevant standards Standard ID Name/Title Status Suggested by CEN/ISO 11354 Requirements for establishing manufacturing enterprise process interoperability DIS K. Kosanke CEN/ISO 19440 Constructs for enterprise modelling IS K. Kosanke ISO 18629 Process specification language (PSL) ISO 10303 Standard for Product data representation and exchange (STEP) ISO 13584 Parts Library (PLIB) R. Goncalvez ISO 15289 Systems and software engineering - Content of systems and software life cycle process information products A. Ortiz, ISO 15926 Industrial automation systems and integration—Integration of lifecycle data for process plants including oil and gas production facilities A. Ortiz, ISO 18876 Integration of industrial data for exchange, access, and sharing (IIDEAS) R. Goncalvez ISO 15745 Framework for Application Integration K. Kosanke ISO 16100 Manufacturing software capability profiling for interoperability K. Kosanke GA Brussels June 9, 2011 K. Kosanke Title IS A. Ortiz, R. Goncalvez 5

CEN/ISO 11354: Requirements for establishing manufacturing enterprise process interoperability Source CEN/ISO 11354 • • Part 1: Requirements for establishing manufacturing enterprise process interoperability Part 2: Maturity model for assessing enterprise interoperability GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 6

KPI in MES standard development Level 4 : ERP Level 3. MES Performance data (KPI) Detailed schedule data Product data Materials data Quality data Work-Time data Process data Level 2 and below Job order data Equipment data Manufacturing automation & control domain data KPIs associoated with manufacturing operations management, Status: in pogress to CD , Source ISO 22400 t GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 7

Service oriented architecture Modeling Language (Soa. ML) • OMG standard for describing services using UML • • • A foundation for further extensions and integration with BPMN, BMM and other metamodels Model Driven Architecture (MDA) Focuses on basic service modelling concepts • Goals • • Bi-directional asynchronous services Composite services Direct mapping to Web services Services architectures where parties provide and use multiple services Mapped to and part of a business process specification Top-down, bottom up or meet-in-the-middle modelling Design by contract or dynamic adaptation of services Service capability and its contract Status. Ongoing in revision GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Source: A, Berre, D. Roman, SINTEF Title 8

FIn. ES Cluster Standardisation Task Force (1) Final Draft Report, dated 6/4/2010 Inter-relation between FIn. ES Research and Standards & Standardisation Task Force Authors A. Dogac, S Pattendon, M. Zelm Content: • • • Standardisation Objectives Cloud Computing • • Conformance and Interoperability Testing of Standards Conclusion: Need correspondence between RTD and standardisation GS 1 and Io. T Semantic Interoperability of Business Documents Semantic Enterprise Interoperability, Frameworks, Standards Analysis of work and requirements for Future User Oriented Standards in FIn. ES (B 2 B, B 2 C, B 2 A Services) GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 9

FIn. ES Cluster Standardisation Task Force (2) Re-start 2011: • Goal: Create ideas, recommendations and proposals to develop usable interoperability standards in the area of Future Internet Enterprise System (FIn. ES). New orientations: • Agree on common definition and understanding of things like Future Internet Resource, Enterprise Service, Interoperability in the context of the FIn. ES domain • Investigate interoperability standards requirements from (selected) industry and state of the art • Explore strategy for the implementation of interoperability standards in internet based Eco systems • Derive recommendations how to encourage and support standardisation of interoperability in FP 8 which could lead to projects proposals Status: Initial Work started on scope, standards to be considered and on key terminology GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 10

Dissemination related to EI Standardisation • IWEI 2011 Conference, • Workshop Standards ensuring enterprise Interoperability – state of the art and perspectives • Four papers from experts inside and outside of I-VLab (March 22, 2011) • XInnovation Event Berlin • Forum ‘e. Manufacturing and Supply’, presentation titled Key Performance Indicators in MES (Sept 13, 2010) • PLM’ 10 Conference Bremen • Session on EI Management, paper Certification of Enterprise Interoperability (July 13, 2010) GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 11

IWEI 2011 Workshop Title: Standards ensuring Enterprise Interoperability and Collaboration - state of the art and the perspectives Papers: • CEN/ISO 11354 – Framework and Maturity Model for Enterprise Interoperability, David Chen, University of Bordeaux, France • Standards and Initiatives for Service Modeling - The Case of OMG Soa. ML, Dumitru Roman, Arne Berre, SINTEF, Norway • Standards for e. Business in SMEs networks: the increasing role of customisation rules and conformance testing tools to achieve interoperability, Arianna Brutti, Piero de Sabbata, ENEA, Italy • Standards ensuring Enterprise Interoperability and Collaboration, Challenges and Alternative Approaches, Martin Forsberg, ECRU Consulting, Sweden Stockholm, March 22, 2011 GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 12

Standardisation Issues • For academia, standardisation seems to only be of interest if it is part of a research project and is required by the scope of the project • For industry, a strong business case must exist • High membership fees in SDOs and cost of standards documents (ISO, OMG…) • To develop and promote EI standards • Funding of activities to be resolved • As a minimum, cost of travel and subsistence must be covered GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 13

Standardisation Action Plan • Contribute to standardisation in upcoming projects MSE • Establish a comprehensive EI standards repository on the I-Vlab site, Sep 2011 • Perform standards promotion at • Workshop I-ESA 12, March 2012 • Promotion events tbd (DFI…) • Continue development on EI Framework and Service languages (Soa. ML) • Produce a Standards TF Report in FIn. ES Cluster (enhanced version), December 2011 GA Brussels June 9, 2011 Title 14