IEEE 802 17 Resilient Packet Ring Request for
- Slides: 7
IEEE 802. 17 Resilient Packet Ring Request for Approval to Forward 802. 17 D 3. 0 to Sponsor Ballot Michael Takefman, Chair 9/8/2021 IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
D 2. 7 Summary • Passed with Approve 62, Disapprove 6, Abstain 2 – Comment resolution on D 2. 7 yielded no changes to the draft – 4 technical binding comments • Commenter explicitly flagged comments as an old issue that he had raised before and did not want to delay start of sponsor, however he wanted them included in the sponsor ballot package • The chair concurs these comments do not represent a new issue • The issue revolves around support for ITU-T X. 87 with RPR as the MAC layer in a non bridged environment causing bridges to flood excessively – 29 editorial comments / 68 technical non-binding comments • No substantive technical issues were raised • Minor improvements that were not significantly impacting understanding or implementation • All comments were rejected or withdrawn with the consent of the commenter 9/8/2021 IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
WG Ballot History Draft Approve Disapprove Abstain Pass Rate D 2. 3 50 16 4 75. 8% D 2. 4 54 12 4 81. 8% D 2. 5 57 10 3 85. 1% D 2. 6 60 7 3 89. 6% D 2. 7 62 6 2 91. 2% • Return Rate 86%, Abstain Rate 5. 7% to 2. 9% 9/8/2021 IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
Disapprove Voters Voter Kshitij Kumar Unresolved TB Rejects 2 Vahid Naragi 2 Nader Vijeh Robert Castellano David James Harmen van As* 1 5 6 Unresolved TB Accept Modify 2 1 * Comment resolved with suggested remedy – commenter does not reply to email 9/8/2021 IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
Plan Moving Forward • Start Sponsor Ballot – late November / early December – CR begins @ January interim • continues in March, April, May, June … • Revcom submittal – June 2004 meeting / September 2004 meeting 9/8/2021 IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
802. 17 WG Motions • Move to rename P 802. 17 D 2. 7 to P 802. 17 D 3. 0 and remove change-bars. M: Alexander S: Lemon – Y: 27 N: 0 A: 0 • Move to request 802 EC to forward 802. 17 D 3. 0 to Sponsor Ballot. M: Alexander S: Lemon – Y: 27 9/8/2021 N: 0 A: 0 IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
EC Motion • Move to forward 802. 17 D 3. 0 to Sponsor Ballot M: Takefman – Y: 9/8/2021 S: N: A: IEEE 802. 17 RPRWG Mike Takefman
