Highway to Hell Fixing Highway Finances in Pennsylvania
- Slides: 35
Highway to Hell Fixing Highway Finances in Pennsylvania Public Expenditure Analysis Miles Mutilator Ingram May 2007 Torrey Bloodthirsty Babson
Outline • Pennsylvania Highway Background – – Stakeholders Background Infrastructure State of Affairs Financial State of Affairs • Penn. DOT/Governor’s Proposal • Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission’s “Modest Proposal” – – Revenue Bond Program Congestion Fees: Regional Mobility Funds Tolling of I-80 Other Revenue Sources • A Closer Look at Some Assumptions – – Discounting Traffic Diversion Secondary Markets Passage of Regional Mobility Fund • Recommendations and Conclusion
Stakeholders • Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (Penn. DOT) • Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission (PTC) • Commonwealth of Pennsylvania • Citizens of Pennsylvania
Background Penn. DOT and PTC are separate, independent agencies, both reporting to and receiving funds from the Secretary of Transportation. Pennsylvania Department of Transportation • Has jurisdiction over all PA roads other than the turnpike and its spurs • Is responsible for 40, 500 miles of state roads and highways & about 25, 000 bridges • Created from the former Department of Highways by the legislature on May 6, 1970 • Employs 11, 000 people
Background Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission • The PTC was created in 1937, and has jurisdiction over I-76 and its various tolled spurs. It officially entered service on October 1, 1940 • The turnpike was financed by a loan from the New Deal's Reconstruction Finance Corporation for almost $41 million at 3. 75 percent. The New Deal’s Works Progress Administration also provided another $29 million in grants • PTC employs around 2, 250 people, or 4 people for every mile of road it oversees, including 480 managers
Infrastructure State of Affairs In February 28, 2005, Governor Rendell convened the nine-member Transportation Funding Reform Commission to study and make recommendations concerning the financing and operations of transportation systems in Pennsylvania. Their November, 2006 report found: • Pennsylvania’s “highway and bridge systems are in crisis…” • “Pennsylvania has more than twice the percentage of structurally deficient bridges than the national average, and more than a third of the 21, 000 miles of state-owned secondary roads are rated “poor. ” Pennsylvania’s state owned bridges are on average 50 years old. ”
Infrastructure State of Affairs • Overdrive, an online trucking magazine, issued its rankings for our country’s “Worst Roads” in December 2006: WORST ROADS 1. Louisiana 2. Pennsylvania 3. California 4. Illinois 5. Michigan WORST ROAD 1. I-10 Louisiana 2. I-80 Pennsylvania 3. I-40 Arkansas 4. I-5 California 5. I-40 Oklahoma • PA is “the state most frequently at the head of the Worst Roads list in its 16 -year history” Overdrive, December 2006 • The American Society of Civil Engineers gives Pennsylvania Roads a grade of “D” in it’s Infrastructure Report Card for the state, entitled “The Keystone is Crumbling”
Financial State of Affairs “The key to a successful infrastructure program is to have funds to support roadway construction, rehabilitation and emergency situations” ASCE Infrastructure Report Card for Pennsylvania The Governor’s Transportation Funding Reform Commission report also found: “Since the last increase in highway and bridge funding in 1997, Penn. DOT has lost approximately $350 million of its purchasing power due to inflation. ” “the Commission believes an annual increased investment of $1. 013 billion is needed with a heavy focus on system preservation and targeted capital investments. ”
Penn. DOT Current Finances Other, PA General Fund, Motor License Fund Federal Funds,
Motor License Fund Revenues Penn. DOT 2006 Annual Report
PTC Current Finances
Benefits of Transportation Direct Transport Supply Direct Transport Demand • • Income from transport • operations (fares and wages) • Access to wider • distribution markets and niches • Improved accessibility Time and cost savings Productivity gains Division of labor Access to a wider range of suppliers and consumers Economies of scale Source: European Conference of Ministers of Transport Indirect Microeconomic Macroeconomic • • • Rent income Lower price of commodities • Higher supply of commodities • • Formation of distribution networks Attraction and accumulation of economic activities Increased competitiveness Growth of consumption Fulfilling mobility needs
Competing Propositions Governor’s Plan • • • Lease or concession of Pennsylvania Turnpike system - $965 million/yr for road and bridge repair Excise tax on oil company gross profits - $760 million/yr for transit projects Total is greater than $1. 7 billion Other Revenue Source Possibilities • New revenue by creating a $1 “congestion fee” in certain urban areas as a way to raise the necessary funds for infrastructure repair • A highly leveraged debt recapitalization of the Turnpike by the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission or another public entity owned by the commonwealth
PTC’s “Modest Proposal” • Part A: Revenue Bonds • Part B: “Regional Mobility Fund” Congestion Fee • Part C: Tolling of I-80 • Part D: Other Revenue Sources
Part A: Special Revenue Bonds • $4 billion bond issuance over 10 yrs • 25 yr Maturity • 5. 5% interest rate
Part B: Congestion Fees $1 increase on turnpike exits around Pennsylvania’s major metropolitan areas Metropolitan Area Number of Taxed Exits Projected Annual Revenue Pittsburgh 8 $50, 000 Philadelphia 14 $83, 500, 000 Harrisburg 5 $13, 000 Scranton/Wilkes. Barre 6 $12, 000 Total $158, 500, 000
Part C: I-80 Tolling Financial Projections • Initial toll of 8 cents per mile on passenger vehicles and 30 cents for commercial vehicles • 3% annual increase in tolls
D Qcurrent Time and Money Costs Average Private Costs Excess Burden Marginal Social Costs Road Tolling: Fixing Market Failure Road Trips
Road Tolling: Fixing Market Failure Time and Money Costs D Marginal Social Costs Social Equilibrium Ptoll Toll Average Private Costs Toll Revenue Qtoll Road Trips
Part D: Other Revenue Sources • PTC projects revenue of over $12. 5 billion between 2008 – 2038 from increase in tolls on I-76 • PTC assumes 25% turnpike toll increase 2010, and 3% annual increases thereafter
Part D: Increases in Projected Turnpike Fees and I-80 Toll Fees
PTC’s Projected Cashflows
A Closer Look at Some Assumptions • Cash flows are NOT discounted • Traffic diversion due to tolls assumed at 20% for cars and 1% for trucks • Secondary markets are not considered • Will the Regional Mobility Fund pass the legislature?
Discount Rates • Currently, future cash flows are not discounted! The sum of non-discounted cash flows to the PTC is $37. 8 billion. • The PTC report assumes an annual interest rate of 5. 5% on issued bonds, and an annual inflation rate on costs of capital of 4% • The following table shows the sum of cash flows at various discount rates: Rate PV of Cash Flows Undiscounted $37, 791. 86 3. 0% $22, 105. 21 3. 5% $20, 447. 83 4. 0% $18, 972. 80 4. 5% $17, 656. 37 5. 0% $16, 478. 20 5. 5% $15, 420. 85 6. 0% $14, 469. 32
Traffic Diversion Rates Passenger Vehicles: • Passenger vehicles currently make up 87% of I-80 traffic. The average length of an I-80 trip is about 30 miles, therefore diversion to secondary roadways will be possible for most trips • Passenger vehicle diversion (20%) will therefore have a significant effect on secondary roadways. Commercial Trucks: • I-80 is the one of the primary highways used for commercial trucks traveling west from New York and New Jersey ports, and is currently the only major east-west highway in the region that is not tolled • Commercial truck diversion (1%) will therefore be significantly lower than passenger vehicle diversion
Diversion Rate Impact on Toll Revenues
Secondary Markets: Secondary Roadway Costs Social Costs in Excess of Private Costs – Dollars/Vehicle Mile Source: Transportation CBA – Roadway Costs, Victoria Transportation Policy Institute • Diversion = 20% car, 1% truck • I-80 = 9, 315, 549 vehicle miles/day, 87% is passenger and 13% commercial • 2. 36 billion passenger miles and 437 million commercial miles in year 1
Secondary Markets: Secondary Roadway Costs
Secondary Markets: Secondary Roadway Costs • Traffic diversion to secondary roadways will result in increased maintenance and construction costs on these roadways • At a discount rate of 4%, the present value of these costs will be $185 million • This money represents a transfer of costs from PTC (I-80) to Penn. DOT (secondary roads), but not an overall increase in spending on road maintenance, therefore there are no price effects.
Secondary Markets: Gasoline Prices The Mackinac Center for Public Policy (Michigan-based public policy research institute) found the long-run price elasticity of demand for gasoline to be. 7 A meta-analysis of many studies in the Energy Journal found the elasticity to be. 58
Regional Mobility Fund Passage Present value of cash flows to the PTC with the Regional Mobility Fund: $18, 972 million at 4% Present value of cash flows to the PTC without the Regional Mobility Fund: $12, 696 million at 4% A difference of $6. 3 billion!!!
Sensitivity Analysis Conclusions What is the PTC analysis MOST SENSITIVE to? ? • Discount Rate (very sensitive) • Passage of the Regional Mobility Fund (very sensitive) • Gas Prices (toll revenues are very sensitive, overall financing is less sensitive, and effects are hard to project) • Traffic Diversion (not so sensitive for cars, more so for trucks)
Recommendations • NPV should be included in all PTC financial projection!!! • Research the political feasibility of the Regional Mobility Fund, exploring options for incremental phase-in of fees. • Research I-80 traffic flows: § Where are commercial vehicles coming from? Where are they going? § How much is in-state and out-of-state traffic? Who is using the road and who is paying for the road? • Research the effects of gas prices on long-term financial outlook. • Leasing of the Turnpike should be considered, but only with strict road maintenance stipulations.
Conclusions • At this time, PA has neither the money nor the political will to fix its roads and bridges • PTC’s report is seriously flawed • For now, we’re on a Highway to Hell
- What is hell like
- Dante's inferno 7th level of hell
- Which progressive reform outlawed price-fixing
- Fixing bnr
- Price fixing definition
- Fixing service failures
- Permanent joining
- Macroprudential intermediation ratio
- Plastering internal
- Double headed rails
- Sentence fixing
- Sentence fragments
- Deepfix: fixing common c language errors by deep learning
- Expanded metal lath fixings
- Price fixing definition
- Nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer
- Bid rigging vs price fixing
- Chapter 4 finances and career planning
- Finance et pedagogie
- Chapter 17 managing business finances
- Chapter 11 finances and career planning
- Source of finance
- Echaustif
- Chapter 17 managing business finances
- Understanding your business finances
- Managing your personal finances textbook answers
- Chapter 11 finances and career planning
- Finances hospitalieres
- Global trade and receivables finance
- What causes stuttering
- Original source
- Pa forest products association
- My uncle from pittsburgh pennsylvania recently bought
- Atlantic coastal plain pennsylvania
- Free radon test kit pa
- Homestead pennsylvania tourism