Greater Manchester Strategy performance report update final October

Greater Manchester Strategy: performance report update – final October 2018

Performance Report update • • This version of the dashboard provides the second assessment of performance against headline Greater Manchester Strategy (GMS) targets compared to the baseline position. It follows the first Performance Report, produced in April 2018 – note that since the previous report was published, new data have not been released on all reported measures; where the data have not changed, reporting remains as in the April 2018 version. The annexed tables indicate whether a measure has been updated or not in this version – where new data have been released, RAG ratings for the headline indicators report on progress towards the 2020 targets, assessing whether we are on track against projected trajectory – the majority of the secondary indicators, which do not have targets associated with them, are RAG rated based on comparison with the national average (see the key on slide 5). There a small number of headline measures where the baseline data have not yet been updated, in which case the RAG ratings are either based on comparison with the national average (Priority 7: visits to the natural environment; Priority 8: indicators populated from Understanding Society) or comparison with the previous year (Priority 7: waste recycled / diverted) Few significant changes have been made to the indicator set. However, the following revisions should be noted … – Priority 4: the GVA per job target and baseline data have been revised due to methodological changes in the way that the Office of National Statistics (ONS) calculates GVA, reflected in the approach adopted for the 2018 Greater Manchester Forecasting Model (GMFM). The scale of ambition defined in the original GMS target remains unchanged, but is now expressed as a percentage uplift, with the 2015 baseline revised and quoted at constant 2015 prices – Priority 4: the definition of the indicator on GVA generated from inward investment has been clarified – the data refer to GVA generated from inward investment (domestic and foreign direct investment) job creation and safeguarding – Priority 5: the headline indicator related to digital infrastructure now provides the median download speed across fibre, cable, mobile and wireless (sourced from Ofcom), as opposed to the mean data previously reported – Priority 8: the Police and Crime Plan outcomes framework has moved forward over recent months, and although it is too early to finalise aligned GMS Dashboard measures at this point in time, we should be able to do so for the next iteration of the performance report in April 2019

GMS Outcomes Framework

Greater Manchester Strategy vision Our vision is to make Greater Manchester one of the best places in the world to grow up, get on and grow old • A place where all children are given the best start in life and young people grow up inspired to exceed expectations • A place where people are proud to live, with a decent home, a fulfilling job, and stress -free journeys the norm. But if you need a helping hand you’ll get it • A place of ideas and invention, with a modern and productive economy that draws in investment, visitors and talent • A place where people live healthy lives and older people are valued • A place at the forefront of action on climate change, with clean air and a flourishing natural environment • A place where all voices are heard and where, working together, we can shape our future … underpinned by these enablers … delivered through these priorities Children starting school ready to learn Communities in control Young people equipped for life Good jobs, with opportunities to progress and develop People at the heart of everything we do An integrated approach to placeshaping Leadership and accountability Taking control of our future A thriving and productive economy in all parts of Greater Manchester World-class connectivity that keeps Greater Manchester moving Safe, decent and affordable housing A green city region and a high quality culture and leisure offer for all Safe and strong communities Healthy lives, with quality care available for those that need it An age-friendly city region … leading to these shared outcomes • All GM children starting school ready to learn • Reduced number of children in need of safeguarding • All young people in education, employment or training following compulsory education • Increased number of GM residents in sustained, 'good' employment • Improved skills levels • Improved economic growth and reduced inequality in economic outcomes across GM places and population groups • Increased business start-ups and inward investment, and improved business performance • Improved transport networks and more sustainable GM neighbourhoods • Reduced congestion • Future-proofed digital infrastructure that fully supports commercial activity, social engagement and public service delivery in GM • High quality housing, with appropriate and affordable options for different groups • No one sleeping rough on GM’s streets • Reduced carbon emissions and air pollution, more sustainable consumption and production, and an outstanding natural environment • Increased local, national and international awareness of, pride in, and engagement with GM's culture, leisure and visitor economy • People feeling safe and that they belong • Reduced crime, reoffending and antisocial behaviour, and increased support for victims • More sustainable GM neighbourhoods • More people supported to stay well and live at home for as long as possible • Improved outcomes for people with mental health needs • Reduced obesity, smoking, alcohol and drug misuse • People live in age-friendly neighbourhoods • Inclusive growth and reduced inequality across GM places and population groups • Reduced social isolation and loneliness … impacting on wider conditions (GMS targets). By 2020 … • Meet or exceed the national average for the proportion of children reaching a ‘good level of development’ by the end of reception • 1, 000 fewer looked-after children • Meet or exceed the national average Attainment 8 score per pupil at the end of Key Stage 4 • 16 -17 year old NEETs below the national average • Median resident earnings will exceed £ 23, 000 • 70, 000 more residents with Level 4+ qualifications • 50, 000 fewer residents with sub-Level 2 qualifications • GVA per job will have increased by at least 6% • 60, 000 more GM employees will be earning above the Real Living Wage • 21, 500 more residents will be in employment • At least 5, 000 more business start-ups pa • 32% of journeys to work will use modes other than the car • The median download speed across fibre, cable, mobile and wireless will exceed 44 Mbps • More than 10, 000 net new homes will be built pa • End rough sleeping • Reduce CO 2 emissions to 11 mt • Average NO 2 concentrations below 30 ug/m 3 and no monitoring sites exceeding 10 ug/m 3 for PM 2. 5 • Halve the gap with the national average for visits to the natural environment • 5% pa growth in participation at cultural events • Victimisation rates (household and personal crime) in line with or below the England & Wales average • Meet or exceed the national average for the % of service users who have enough social contact • Improving premature mortality will result in: (i) 160 fewer deaths due to cardiovascular disease pa; (ii) 350 fewer deaths from cancer pa; (iii) 150 fewer deaths from respiratory disease pa • 33, 600 more people pa will be supported with evidence-based psychological therapies • 90% of people aged over 50 will identify their neighbourhood as ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ age-friendly • 5, 000 more 50 -64 year olds will be in employment

GMS Performance Dashboard October 2018 performance report update All figures are accurate as of 25 October 2018 New data have not been released on all reported measures; where the data have not changed, reporting remains as in the April 2018 version. The annexed tables indicate whether a measure has been updated or not in this version.

Priority 1 - Children starting school ready to learn GMS targets By 2020, we will meet or exceed the national average for the proportion of children reaching a ‘good level of development’ by the end of reception 68. 0% of children in GM had reached a ‘good level of development’ by the end of reception, as of 2018 3. 5 percentage points below the national average 0. 5 percentage points higher than 2017 By 2020, 70 fewer very small babies will be born every year, narrowing the gap with the projected national average for the number of low birth weight, at-term births A Proportion of children who are school ready at 5 years old (2018) and percentage point change on the previous year Bolton 67. 5 1. 4 Bury 70. 9 2. 2 Manchester 66. 9 0. 7 Oldham 64. 1 0. 4 Rochdale 66. 2 Salford 3. 0% (973) By 2020, all early years settings will be rated ‘good’ or ‘outstanding’ by OFSTED, an increase from 90% in 2016 G Proportion of at term births that were low birth weight (<2500 g) in 2016 of live births at term were low birth weight (<2500 g) in 2016 Bolton 2. 9 Bury 2. 4 Manchester 3. 3 Oldham 3. 7 2. 4 Rochdale 3. 3 67. 4 -0. 2 Salford 2. 8 Stockport 70. 0 -1. 6 Stockport 2. 0 Tameside 65. 7 -0. 3 Tameside 3. 2 Trafford 75. 3 2. 3 Trafford 2. 2 Wigan 68. 6 -0. 7 Wigan 2. 9 GM 68. 0 0. 5 GM 3. 0 England 2. 8 England 71. 5 0. 8 0. 1 percentage points ahead of the expected target trajectory 0. 1 percentage points (16) fewer than 2015 93. 6% of early years settings were rated as ‘good’ or ‘outstanding’ as of March 2018 A 0. 3 percentage points behind the expected target trajectory 2. 0 percentage points higher than March 2017 % of inspected providers rated as good or outstanding as of March 2018, and percentage point change since March 2017 Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England 94. 9% 96. 1% 87. 8% 94. 2% 95. 8% 91. 7% 95. 7% 94. 5% 96. 3% 91. 9% 93. 6% 94. 2% 0. 6 2. 8 3. 1 3. 9 4. 0 1. 8 -0. 7 3. 8 1. 5 1. 0 2. 0 0. 8 Supporting indicators 11. 9% As of Q 1 2018/19, of GM mothers were known to be smokers at the time of delivery, down 0. 5 percentage points compared to the same quarter in the previous year 1. 5 percentage points above the England average The rate of dental extractions with decay as the primary diagnosis amongst GM R 0 -4 year olds was 33 per 10, 000 in 2016 -17, largely unchanged when compared to the previous year R 50% higher than the England average (22 per 10, 000) Context and challenges • • • Greater Manchester has seen an improvement in school readiness from 47. 3% in 2013 to 68. 0% in 2018. However, although the gap with the national average narrowed from 4. 4 percentage points in 2013 to 3. 2 in 2017, it remains significant and has increased slightly over the last year (to 3. 5 percentage points). There is considerable variance both across and within localities, and a strong correlation between lower levels of school readiness and deprivation. In order to meet or exceed the national average by 2020, collective effort across all GM districts will be required. Positive improvement has been seen across the majority of indicators reported, with a significantly higher proportion of early years settings rated ‘good’ or ‘outstanding’ by OFSTED, which should support further improvement in school readiness as these children move into compulsory education. However, GM still lags the national average on all measures, most particularly on smoking in pregnancy and children’s oral health, both of which are priority areas under the GM Population Health Plan. Improved early years outcomes are a fundamental foundation for achieving our ambitions across the GMS priorities. We are producing a comprehensive school readiness plan to deliver the investment and implementation of reforms required to drive improvements in school readiness in every part of GM; as part of this plan, we are engaging with schools to support them to become leaders in early years, and developing a consistent workforce development programme for roll-out to place-based teams and early years settings.

Priority 2 – Young people equipped for life GMS targets By 2020, there will be 1, 000 fewer looked after children in GM, a reduction of more than 20% on 2016 levels A By 2020, the proportion of GM Key Stage 2 pupils achieving the expected level of attainment in reading, writing and maths (RWM) will continue to meet or exceed the England average G As of March 2017, there were 5, 245 looked after children in GM, up by 135 compared to March 2016 64% of GM Key Stage 2 pupils achieved the expected level of attainment (RWM) in 2018, up from 62% in 2017* 8. 5% behind the target trajectory Equal to the England average Rate per 10, 000 children <18 2017 61 63 60 57 56 61 64 2018 64 63 60 62 60 64 66 Change 4. 9% 0. 0% 8. 8% 7. 1% 4. 9% 3. 1% Tameside 60 63 5. 0% Trafford Wigan GM England (state schools) 72 66 62 75 69 64 4. 2% 4. 5% 3. 2% 62 64 3. 2% Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England 2016 85 72 107 72 95 103 47 87 61 72 82 60 2017 87 82 97 84 89 95 53 105 70 66 84 62 Change 2. 4% 13. 9% -9. 3% 16. 7% -6. 3% -7. 8% 12. 8% 20. 7% 14. 8% -8. 3% 1. 6% 3. 3% Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport * Provisional data, not yet finalised. By 2020, we will meet or exceed the national average Attainment 8 score per pupil at the end of Key Stage 4, with all districts demonstrating significant progress in closing the attainment gap across their schools By 2020, the number of 16 -17 year -olds who are NEET (not in education, employment or training) will be below the national average in all GM districts, as will the number whose activity is not known to the local authority A 3. 4% of 16 -17 year-olds in GM were NEET (not in education, employment or training) at the end of 2017 The average Attainment 8 (A 8) score for GM Key Stage 4 pupils in 2017/18 was 45. 2* 1. 3 below the average score for the statefunded sector in England Down from 45. 5 in 2016/17** A significant attainment gap within districts, with a high proportion of schools below the national average score % of mainstream Average schools below A 8 the A 8 England score* average* Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England (state schools) 44. 5 45. 0 42. 9 42. 6 43. 3 40. 7 47. 1 43. 9 56. 6 45. 1 45. 2 58% 62% 67% 60% 64% 87% 38% 60% 25% 59% 58% 46. 5 * Provisional data ** Note some lack of comparability between the 2016/17 and 2017/18 data, as the maximum A 8 score increased from 87 to 90 over the period R 0. 6 percentage points above the England average The activity of a further 2. 9% of 16 -17 year olds was unknown, 0. 4 percentage points below the England average % of 16 -17 year olds NEET Not Total known Bolton 3. 5% 3. 8% 7. 2% Bury 3. 6% 0. 4% 4. 0% Manchester 3. 4% 5. 3% 8. 8% Oldham 3. 5% 1. 6% 5. 1% Rochdale 3. 6% 2. 1% 5. 7% Salford 5. 9% 1. 8% 7. 7% Stockport 2. 3% 0. 8% 3. 1% Tameside 3. 5% 1. 6% 5. 2% Trafford 2. 3% 3. 7% 6. 0% Wigan 2. 7% 4. 3% 7. 0% GM England 3. 4% 2. 7% 2. 9% 3. 3% 6. 0% By 2020, the number of unemployed 1619 year olds will have fallen from 13, 300 in 2016 to 12, 000, a reduction of 10% over the period G 17. 3% (9, 400) of economically active 16 -19 year olds in GM were unemployed in the year to June 2018, down from 27. 0% (14, 500) for the previous year 6. 1 percentage points ahead of the target trajectory 19. 6% for males 15. 0% for females Supporting indicators 24, 372 bed days for children and young people aged under 18 in CAMHS tier 4 wards in the year to March 2018. This equates to 384 per 10, 000 children <18, up from 252 for the previous year, but below the England average for the year to March 2018 of 392 G The average Progress 8 score for GM Key Stage 4 pupils in 2017/18 was -0. 16*, indicating that pupils made 0. 16 of a grade less progress than the national all schools average This was lower than the average score of -0. 11 in 2016/17 R 36. 6% of 10 -11 year old children in GM were overweight or obese as of 2017/18, above the England average of 34. 3% A An increase of 0. 3 percentage points since 2016/17 * Note: provisional data Context and challenges • • • A survey of Year 10 pupils in GM secondary schools is being rolled out, and will collect data on the proportion with ‘hope and optimism’ for the future. This indicator will be introduced to the dashboard when a full baseline is available, and the wider set of measures will be reviewed in light of developments under the GM life readiness workstream. This aims to support all young people to succeed, particularly in preparation for the transition from compulsory schooling to further educational, training and employment opportunities; the GM Youth Combined Authority is centrally involved, not least in development of a ‘Curriculum for Life’ from primary age to post-16. 2017/18 data on looked after children (LAC) were not available for this update, but are likely to show GM numbers increasing for a second consecutive year, following the reduction seen over the 2014 -16 period. Analysis will be undertaken when the data are published, including comparison with national trends, and understanding key drivers of change and the potential role played by unaccompanied asylum seeking children in inflating the figures. The GMS Implementation Plan includes a strong emphasis on early intervention and prevention, although it will take time before this will have a significant impact on LAC numbers. Educational performance is relatively strong at Key Stage 2. Key Stage 4 outcomes underperform the national average, although GM is in line with other core cities with the exception of London, where exceptional performance is driving the England average upwards. There is significant variance across and within GM districts. The proportion of 16 -17 year olds who were NEET (not in education, employment or training) at the end of 2017 increased slightly compared to the previous year. Conversely, the proportion whose activity was ‘not known’ decreased significantly, although this may be due to local authorities no longer being required to track academic age 18 -year-olds. The life readiness work should also pay dividends in supporting youth employment; despite significant recent improvement, around one in six economically active 16 -19 year olds in GM (i. e. excluding those still in education) were unemployed in June 2018. Significant mental health investment will support achievement of GM’s ambition that no child who needs mental health support will be turned away, and will include a new schools mental health pilot that will provide a rapid response model within schools.

Priority 3 – Good jobs, with opportunities for people to progress and develop GMS targets By 2020, median resident earnings (all employees) will exceed £ 23, 000, up from £ 21, 585 in 2016 G By 2020, there will be 70, 000 more GM working-age residents with Level 4+ (degree level or equivalent) qualifications, an increase from 34. 6% of the working-age population in 2016 to 38. 3% 35. 0% A Bolton Bury Manchester of GM working-age residents £ 1, 733 below the Oldham (620, 000) had a Level 4+ England median of Rochdale qualification in 2017 £ 24, 298 Salford £ 536 higher than in Stockport 1. 6% behind the expected per annum in 2018 2017 (at current prices) Tameside target trajectory Trafford 2018 median % change 0. 4 percentage points Wigan wage from 2017 (9, 000) above the 2016 position GM England Bolton £ 20, 647 0. 1% Bury £ 25, 370 6. 7% Manchester £ 21, 896 6. 5% Oldham £ 20, 281 -0. 7% Rochdale £ 20, 851 2. 5% Salford £ 22, 082 1. 8% Stockport £ 25, 073 3. 4% Tameside £ 21, 936 7. 0% Trafford £ 28, 167 7. 6% Wigan £ 22, 122 -0. 3% GM £ 22, 565 2. 4% England £ 24, 298 2. 3% Median earnings of GM residents (all employees) were 1. 5% ahead of the target trajectory £ 22, 565 By 2020, there will be at least 50, 000 fewer GM workingage residents with qualifications below Level 2, a reduction from 27. 7% of the working-age population in 2016 to 24. 6% 34. 3% 39. 9% 27. 5% 25. 2% 30. 9% 42. 8% 26. 2% 50. 6% 26. 8% 35. 0% 38. 3% 27. 2% A Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England of GM working-age residents (480, 000) had qualifications below Level 2 in 2017 0. 2% behind the expected target trajectory A decrease of 0. 5 percentage points (7, 000) since 2016 By 2020, more than 40, 000 GM residents per annum will start an apprenticeship, and the achievement rate for apprenticeship programmes will reach 75%. This compares to 30, 379 apprenticeship starts in 2015/16, and an achievement rate of 66. 4% 29. 0% 25. 7% 27. 3% 33. 1% 32. 0% 31. 6% 21. 0% 30. 9% 17. 8% 25. 5% 27. 2% 25. 4% There were 28, 426 R A The apprenticeship achievement rate in 2016/17 was 67. 6% , apprenticeship starts in 0. 5 percentage points behind 2016/17, 12. 0% (3, 900) behind the expected target trajectory, and down from but up 1. 2 percentage points 30, 379 in 2015/16 compared to 2015/16 Supporting indicators 18. 2% of working age residents in GM had Level 3 as their highest level of qualification in 2017, above the England average of 17. 3% and up from 18. 0% the previous year G 4. 6% of economically active GM working-age residents were unemployed in the year to June 2018, above the England average of 4. 3%, but down from 5. 6% for the previous year A 3. 1% of GM working-age residents (55, 000) were claiming unemployment benefits* in September 2018, above the England average of 2. 2% and higher than the September 2017 rate of 2. 6% R * Job Seekers Allowance and unemployed Universal Credit claimants Context and challenges • Whilst GM skills levels have improved steadily since 2004, relative performance remains poor. There are identified skills gaps in several key sectors, including construction, digital and hospitality, along with some public service areas such as nursing. Policy is focused on reducing gaps and shortages, especially in ‘technical’ roles (Level 3 and 4 ). • GM will assume responsibility for Adult Education Budget (AEB) commissioning in 2019, providing further opportunity to target development of the skills required by local employers and key sectors, and to reduce the currently significant proportion of ‘second-chance’ provision and lower-level skills. Over time, this will also be supported by further improvements in ‘school readiness’ and subsequent attainment in compulsory education. • The downturn in apprenticeship starts is mirrored in the national data, and is driven by employer uncertainty over the introduction of the apprenticeship levy. An apprenticeship action plan has been developed to increase both quality and volumes, and includes an SME support programme, a public sector apprenticeship approach and a new digital talent pipeline. Dialogue with government as part of the GM Local Industrial Strategy will focus on designing a system to meet local needs and address growth ambitions. • The ILO unemployment rate is at its lowest level for 15 years, although the roll-out of Universal Credit is inflating the claimant count as more people are required to look for work. By August 2018, Working Well had supported more than 3, 200 people into employment, and the new Work and Health programme had received over 3, 000 referrals. The GM Employer Charter is being co-designed with employers and employees, and will support achievement of GM’s ‘good work’ ambitions.

Priority 4 – A thriving and productive economy in all parts of Greater Manchester GMS targets By 2020, GVA per job will have increased by at least 6%, compared to the 2015 baseline* R * Note: the original target and baseline have been redefined due to methodological changes in GVA measurement, but the scale of the targeted increase remains unchanged GVA per job* was £ 44, 072 in 2016 (GMFM-2018) Down from £ 44, 172 in 2015 £ 474 behind the target trajectory, and nearly £ 5, 000 per job below the 2016 UK average of £ 49, 050 * All GVA data quoted at constant 2015 prices By 2020, 60, 000 more GM employees will be earning above the Real Living Wage, an increase from 75. 6% of employee jobs in 2016 to 80% 78. 2% By 2020, 21, 500 more GM residents will be in employment, relative to a 2016 baseline of 1, 273, 000 5. 7% (50, 000) ahead of the target trajectory of employee jobs (>18) working in GM (880, 000) were earning above the Real Living Wage* in 2017 Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England G 2. 6 percentage points (60, 000) higher than in 2016 76. 5% 71. 0% 82. 0% 68. 5% 68. 1% 78. 5% 75. 1% 71. 0% 72. 7% 67. 9% 75. 6% 76. 8% 2017 75. 5% 74. 1% 84. 8% 70. 7% 71. 3% 84. 1% 74. 3% 74. 7% 71. 1% 78. 2% 78. 0% 1, 324, 000 GM residents (16+) were in employment in the year to June 2018 3. 1% (40, 000) ahead of the target trajectory 2. 5% (32, 000) higher than in June 2017 Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England G 56. 2% 59. 6% 61. 6% 54. 1% 56. 9% 64. 0% 63. 0% 58. 2% 63. 4% 60. 0% 61. 0% By 2020, there will be at least 5, 000 more business startups pa compared to 2015 levels, an increase from 90 start -ups per 10, 000 GM workingage residents to 117 or more G The business start 16. 5% (3, 500 up rate was births) ahead of the target trajectory 115 per 10, 000 WAP An increase from 90 in 2015 (4, 600 in 2016 (20, 500 business births pa) additional births) By 2020, GVA generated from inward investment job creation and safeguarding will be £ 310 m, up from £ 290 m in 2016/17 G £ 337 m in GVA was generated from inward investment (domestic and FDI) job creation and safeguarding in GM in 2017/18 14. 3% ahead of the target trajectory, and up £ 46 m from 2016/17 * As defined by the Living Wage Foundation Supporting indicators The employment rate for working age residents in GM from ethnic minority groups was 59. 6% in the year to June 2018, below the England average of 65. 5%, but broadly comparable to the previous year (59. 8%) A The employment rate for working age residents in GM with a disability* was 48. 8% in the year to June 2018, below the England average of 53. 7%, up from 47. 0% in the previous year * Equality Act core or work-limiting disabled A There were 631 enterprises per 10, 000 working age residents in GM in 2016, below the England average of 717, up from 578 in 2015 R Context and challenges • GMFM-2018 outputs show that productivity in GM declined slightly between 2015 and 2016, as it did for the UK as a whole. The GM productivity gap continues, with GVA per job in GM hovering consistently at around 90% of the UK average over the last decade. If GVA per head in GM were the same as the national average, GM’s economy would be a fifth larger. GM’s Local Industrial Strategy will take a deep-dive into productivity performance, and identify key policy levers that could enhance future growth. • Good performance against the other GMS headline targets in part reflects the conservative nature of these targets, which were developed in 2017 and align with the cautious forecasts outlined in the 2017 Greater Manchester Forecasting Model (GMFM) in light of Brexit uncertainty. To date, the GM economy has proved more resilient than anticipated, although Brexit could have a significant dampening effect moving forward – government forecasts suggest that GDP in the North West will be between 2. 5% and 12% lower over the next 15 years, depending on the nature of the trade deal we agree with the EU. • New data for the Real Living Wage, business start-ups and business density (number of enterprises per 10, 000 working-age residents) measures have not yet been released. Employment outcomes for the adult population are positive, and the June 2018 gap of 1. 0 percentage points between the GM employment rate and the England average is the lowest for more than a decade. However, between June 2017 and June 2018 the employment rate decreased in 3 districts, and employment of disabled people and residents from ethnic minority groups is well below national rates, illustrating the need to address distributional variation in growth across GM. Growth in the regional centre, strategic employment sites and town centres will be driven by a range of activity including the Local Industrial Strategy, Productivity and Inclusive Growth programme, and the Town Centre

Priority 5 – World-class connectivity that keeps Greater Manchester moving GMS targets By 2020, the proportion of journeys to work by modes other than the car will have reached 32%, up from 29% in 2015 A By 2020, 90% of journeys by road during the morning peak period will be completed within the typical journey time, up from 88. 5% in March 2017 A By 2020, annual average roadside NO 2 concentrations across the GM monitoring network will be below 30 ug per m 3, down from 39 ug per m 3 in 2016 A By 2020, no GM monitoring sites will exceed 10 ug per m 3 for PM 2. 5, down from 75% (3 out of 4 sites) exceeding in 2016 G 29% of people used modes of 88. 4% of GM highway network 37. 6 ug per m transport other than the car to travel to work in 2016 journeys were completed within the “typical journey time” in Q 1 2018/19 0. 6 percentage points behind the target position 0. 6 percentage points below the target position annual average roadside NO 2 concentrations across the GM monitoring network in 2017 Unchanged from 2015 A decrease of 0. 7 percentage points on the same quarter in the previous year 4. 3 Mbps above the target trajectory median download speed 9. 5 Mbps higher as of 2017 than in 2016 32. 8 Mbps 0. 8 ug per m 3 above the target position 40% of GM monitoring sites (2 out of 5)* exceeded 10 ug per m 3 for PM 2. 5 in 2017 16 percentage points lower than the target trajectory 35 percentage points lower than in 2016 *Monitoring sites increased to 5 in 2017 [ RAG ratings for the transport indicators below are based on a comparison to the previous year’s performance ] 38. 7% of all GM journeys were made by walking, cycling or public transport between 2015 -17 0. 5 percentage points lower than 2014 -16 A G *Now refers to the median as opposed to the mean 3 Reduction of 1. 2 ug per m 3 from 2016 By 2020, the median download speed* across fibre, cable, mobile and wireless will exceed 44 Mbps, compared to a 2016 baseline of 23 Mbps Median download speed by local authority (Mbps) as of 2017 and Mbps change from 2016 Bolton 40. 0 16. 7 Bury 25. 0 6. 8 Manchester 20. 8 4. 3 Oldham 40. 0 12. 6 Rochdale 35. 4 15. 6 Salford 31. 4 11. 3 Stockport 40. 0 5. 1 Tameside 23. 2 5. 3 Trafford 40. 0 13. 1 Wigan 40. 0 10. 0 GM 32. 8 9. 5 England 30. 9 7. 9 Supporting indicators 82. 1% of GM residents had Level 4 or above accessibility to the public transport network at peak times, as of May 2018 A decrease of 2. 6 percentage points on February 2017 A 55. 4% of short journeys (under 2 km) in GM were completed by walking or by cycling in 2015 -17 A decrease of 0. 9 percentage points since 2014 -16 A 77. 9% of GM residents had all five basic digital skills in November 2016 An increase of 2 percentage points since November 2014 1 percentage point below the UK average A Context and challenges • The majority of measures have been updated for this version of the Performance Report, with the exception of the proportion of people using modes of transport other than the car to travel to work, and the proportion of GM residents that had all five basic digital skills. The updated transport data confirm the need for GM’s current focus on active travel, with slight reductions in the proportion of journeys made by walking, cycling or public transport, and in short journeys completed by walking or cycling; conversely, congestion on GM’s roads has edged up slightly. In response, a significant investment programme for cycling and walking is being put in place, driven by the GM Cycling and Walking Commissioner’s Made to Move strategy, and incorporating the Mayor’s Cycling and Walking Challenge Fund and development of the cycling and walking network. Implementation of measures under the GM Congestion Plan are ongoing, and significant capital investment is supporting new and renewed transport infrastructure. Plans for bus reform and smart ticketing on Metrolink are progressing and will support development of a more integrated network and better-connected city region. • Tackling poor air quality is a key GM priority. GM local authorities are working with Tf. GM to develop a Clean Air Plan, which will accelerate activity already being taken forward under the GM Low Emission Strategy, Air Quality Action Plan and Congestion Plan. • GM has secured £ 23. 8 m investment to fund full-fibre connectivity to businesses and homes across GM – this is critical to establishing the kind of data-intensive activities that are necessary for a truly world-leading digital city-region, and is one of the key priorities of the GM Digital Strategy. The Strategy also focuses on digital inclusion, and work is ongoing to develop an all-age, place-based digital inclusion programme.

Priority 6 – Safe, decent and affordable housing GMS targets By 2020, more than 10, 000 net additional dwellings will be built per annum, up from 6, 190 in 2015/16 7, 892 net new additional dwellings in GM in 2016/17 940 dwellings ahead of the target trajectory A further 1, 706 new dwellings compared to 2015 -16 G Number of net additional dwellings, 2016/17, and change compared to 2015/16 Bolton 437 -75 Bury 368 33 Manchester 1, 792 35 Oldham 326 66 Rochdale 315 7 Salford 2, 482 1, 384 Stockport 660 337 Tameside 365 -228 Trafford 330 -31 Wigan 817 178 GM 7, 892 1, 706 England 217, 345 27, 700 R End rough sleeping by 2020, from an estimated 189 rough sleepers in 2016 An estimated 268 rough sleepers in GM in 2017, or 0. 23 per 1, 000 households Above the England average of 0. 20 per 1, 000 households, with individual districts (particularly Manchester and Salford) significantly above Up from 189 in 2016 Rate per 1, 000 households Bolton 0. 14 Bury 0. 12 Manchester 0. 42 Oldham 0. 02 Rochdale 0. 09 Salford 0. 44 Stockport 0. 08 Tameside 0. 44 Trafford 0. 05 Wigan 0. 21 GM 0. 23 England 0. 20 Supporting indicators In December 2017, the ratio of lower quartile house prices to median incomes in GM was 4. 3, compared to the England average of 5. 2 Affordability in GM declined slightly compared to 2016, when the ratio was 4. 1 G In 2016/17, 0. 9% of GM housing stock (10, 827 properties) had been empty for over 6 months, compared to 0. 86% for England as a whole A decrease of 323 properties since 2015/16 A In Q 1 2018, positive action was successful in preventing or relieving homelessness in 4, 871 cases, a rate of 4. 1 per 1, 000 households, compared to 2. 4 for England as a whole Up on the previous year by 116 cases G In March 2018, there were 238, 600 people in receipt of housing benefit or households in receipt of the housing element of Universal Credit, a rate of 85 per 1, 000 of the population, compared to 71 nationally. The gap between GM and the national average closed by 9% when compared to March 2017 R In 2016, 93. 5% of GM residents stated that they “liked the neighbourhood” they live in, compared to 94. 9% nationally, an increase of 1. 0 percentage point from 2013 A Note: this indicator is drawn from responses to Understanding Society, the UK Household Longitudinal Survey. The indicator may be modified to gather more timely data using responses from a proposed GM residents’ survey Context and challenges • The majority of measures that have been updated for this version of the Performance Report show positive progress, including a reduction in the proportion of empty properties, closing of the gap with the national average for the number of people claiming housing benefit (albeit that a significant gap remains), and an increase in the proportion of residents stating that they ‘liked the neighbourhood’ where they lived. • Consultation on the revised Greater Manchester Spatial Framework (GMSF) will take place in autumn 2018, with the aim of ensuring that we have the right land available in the right places to deliver the homes and jobs needed by the city-region up to 2035. The headline measure on net additional dwellings has not updated for this Performance Report, but the significant increase between 2015/16 and 2016/17 indicated that we were on track towards the target of delivering more than 10, 000 new homes by 2020. • The rough sleepers data (which have also not yet updated) are not particularly robust, and local intelligence suggests that there may be as many as 500 rough sleepers across GM, around double the official count. Despite some success in alleviating rough sleeping, there remains an ‘on-flow’ of people onto the streets, negating against a reduction in overall numbers. A three-year strategy to end rough sleeping and reduce homelessness has been agreed, driven by the GM Homelessness Action Network, and our rough sleeping social impact bond had resettled 112 rough sleepers by August 2018. Winter planning is a key focus, and it is imperative to ensure that sufficient cold weather provision is in place across GM so we can provide accommodation for those who need it. Homelessness prevention activity includes the development of pathways for key groups, including young people, ex-offenders and people with mental health needs. Work is also ongoing to improve our intelligence on rough sleeping and homelessness – more robust and timely data is necessary to track the amount of available accommodation and understand how this relates to the number of rough sleepers at a particular point in time.

Priority 7 – A green city region and a high quality culture and leisure offer for all GMS targets By 2020, 50% of waste in GM will be recycled and 90% diverted, up from 46. 7% and 88% respectively in 2016/17 G By 2020, GM will have reduced CO 2 emissions to 11 mt, down from 13. 6 mt in 2014 12. 5 mt of CO 2 emissions in 2016, or 4. 49 t per capita A reduction of 0. 5 mt since 2015 0. 2 mt ahead of the target trajectory of 12. 7 mt By 2020, we will have halved the gap with the national average for the proportion of GM residents reporting that they visited the natural environment at least once during the previous seven days 38% An increase of 3 percentage points compared to 2014 -15, but below the 2015 -16 England average of 42% of GM residents reported that they had visited the natural environment at least once during the previous seven days in 2015 -16* 46. 7% 88% of waste recycled in 2016/17 of waste diverted in 2016/17 An increase of 2. 5 percentage points on the previous year An increase of 5 percentage points on the previous year By 2020, participation at cultural events and venues will be growing by at least 5% pa A * Looking to replace this with a more robust measure, potentially sourced from a new GM residents’ survey G By 2020, the GM visitor economy will be valued at £ 8. 8 bn, up from £ 7. 9 bn in 2015 G 3. 2 m G £ 8. 1 bn engagements by GM residents with cultural organisations supported by AGMA in 2017/18* generated by the visitor economy in 2016 7. 5% increase on 2016/17 levels * This measure only covers participation in cultural provision by AGMA-funded organisations, and counts frequent attenders multiple times. We will use information from the Greater Manchester Resident survey and from analysis of Audience Finder data to set a new benchmark, which will measure successful delivery of the Greater Manchester Culture Strategy, from 2019 onwards. An increase of £ 0. 2 bn since 2015 Supporting indicators 80. 3% of GM residents reported that they had high or very high life satisfaction in 2017/18 1. 7 percentage points below the England average, 0. 8 percentage points above the previous year 94, 000 FTE jobs supported by Greater A 87. 6% of GM lodgements had an energy efficiency rating of D or above (EPC/DEC) in Q 2 2018 6. 5 percentage point above the England average 3. 9 percentage points higher than Q 2 2017 Manchester’s tourism industry in 2016 100 more FTEs than in 2015 G A £ 904 m generated by the conference and business events sector in 2017* A * Note: comparator data cannot be quoted due to methodological changes, therefore the trend indication is not shown. The RAG rating is based on a subjective assessment of performance. 30, 0085 renewable electricity generation installations in GM in June 2018, with a combined capacity of 127, 528 k. W. 22, 675 k. W higher than in June 2017, 52% lower per household than the England average. R GM was ranked 24 th in the Anholt Brand Index in 2017 Up from 27 nd in 2015 944 accredited renewable heat incentives in August 2018 with a combined capacity (non-domestic only) of 53. 8 MW. 2. 5 MW higher than August 2017, 64% lower per household than the England average G R Context and challenges • New data were available for around half of the Priority 7 measures reported above. Performance remains on track in terms of achieving the 2020 target for CO 2 emissions, although much of the carbon reduction reported is due to national measures, decarbonisation of the grid, and warmer weather, which reduces the need for heating. We are now considering longer term ambitions, including progressing actions agreed at the March 2018 Green Summit. • GM still falls significantly behind the national average for local renewable energy production, although again the position has improved since previously reported. Our response includes proposals to create a GM Energy Company, development of a Smart Energy Plan, and piloting smart energy generation systems through an Energy Transition Region. • Reported life satisfaction in GM has seen a significant improvement, but remains below the national average. There is also considerable variance across GM districts. • The key challenge for the visitor economy is to maintain growth in day and staying visits. Business visits in particular have seen little recent growth. We need to remain competitive, increase our profile and introduce new product. Recruitment and retention of staff is an issue, and will be further exacerbated by Brexit. • Under the Great Place initiative, we are developing a new approach to assessing levels of engagement with culture, which will enable us to target our resources more effectively and address significant variation by geography and population group. Under the current methodology, engagement levels have increased, exceeding target expectations.

Priority 8 – Safer and Stronger Communities GMS targets In 2016, 11. 8% of GM households said they had been a victim of household crime in the past 12 months. 3. 9% of GM residents had experienced personal crime. Over the period to 2020, victimisation rates will be in line with or below the England & Wales average 13. 3% of GM respondents said they had experienced household crime in the year to 2. 2% of GM respondents said they had experienced personal crime in the year to March 2018, 2. 8 percentage points higher than the most recent national figure March 2018, 1. 7 percentage points lower than the most recent national figure 1. 4 percentage points higher than March 2017 1. 2 percentage points lower than March 2017 R G Household Personal Crime: theft from the person; snatch theft; stealth theft; other theft of personal property; all Crime Survey for England Wales (CSEW) violence; wounding; assault with minor injury; assault with no injury and robbery. Personal crimes only relate to the respondent's own personal experience, not that of other people in their household. Household Crime: vandalism; domestic burglary; vehicle-related theft; bicycle theft and other household theft. Respondents are asked whether anyone currently residing in the household has experienced any incidents within the last 12 months. G G G 19% of GM respondents 73% of GM respondents agreed 5% of GM respondents agreed or reported feeling ‘unsafe’ in a public location sometime in the past 12 months as of 2015 -16 4 percentage points below the national average or strongly agreed with the statement that ‘I feel like I belong to this neighbourhood’ in 2014 -15 3 percentage points above the national average strongly agreed with the statement that ‘people in this neighbourhood don’t get along with each other’ in 2014 -15 0. 9 percentage points below the national average [ Work is ongoing to develop an outcomes framework to provide insight into the outcomes and commitments made in Standing Together, the new GM Police and Crime Plan (PCP). The PCP outcome measures will draw on a range of data sources including GMP recorded crime, national survey data and locally collected data from across GM. It is anticipated that the framework will receive formal sign-off in Autumn 2018, with baseline data collected before Christmas. A GM residents’ survey on the PCP outcomes is currently going through the procurement process. The PCP framework will complement the GMS Priority 8 outcome indicators; the headline measures used in this dashboard will be updated to align more closely with the PCP outcomes framework once finalised. ] Supporting indicators [ The suite of sub-indicators will be revised to ensure consistency with the PCP outcomes framework. ] Context and challenges • • As noted, the reported indicator set will be revised on finalisation of the PCP outcomes framework. Updated data were only available for the two headline measures relating to household and personal crime: personal crime has reduced over the last year and is significantly below the national comparator, but household crime has increased and the gap between GM and the national position has widened. Whilst some of this increase is explained by improved police recording, the data highlight the increased demand on policing, at a time when Greater Manchester Police (GMP) resources are spread thinly following successive years of funding cuts and reductions in the number of front-line officers. The refresh of the Justice Devolution Mo. U is in progress, with new governance arrangements, focused on the Justice and Rehabilitation Outcomes Framework. More broadly, a GM Resilience Strategy is in development, which will incorporate findings from the Kerslake Review into the 2017 Manchester Arena bombing.

Priority 9 – Healthy lives, with quality care available for those that need it GMS targets By 2020, improving premature mortality due to cardiovascular disease will result in 160 fewer deaths per annum 64. 7 premature deaths per 100, 000 in 2014 -16 18. 0 per 100, 000 above the England average 0. 5 per 100, 000 fewer than in 2013 -15 By 2020, improving premature mortality from cancer will result in 350 fewer deaths per annum R Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England 61. 0 60. 6 94. 9 77. 3 71. 4 69. 7 39. 9 71. 8 41. 5 60. 5 64. 7 46. 7 98. 0 premature deaths per 100, 000 in 2014 -16 17. 3% of people in GM who had depression and/or anxiety disorders entered treatment for IAPT in the year to June 2018, 1. 7 percentage points lower than the 2018/19 target trajectory of 19%, but up from 17. 1% in the previous year R 18. 6 per 100, 000 above the England average 2 per 100, 000 fewer than in 2013 -15 By 2020, access to evidence-based psychological therapies will reach 25% of the population in need, helping a further 33, 600 people each year compared to current levels of provision By 2020, improving premature mortality from respiratory disease will result in 150 fewer deaths per annum Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England 93. 5 87. 3 128. 6 102. 7 102. 5 109. 4 82. 5 97. 9 81. 9 92. 4 98. 0 79. 4 28. 0 premature deaths per R 9. 4 per 100, 000 above the England average 100, 000 in 2014 -16 0. 75 per 100, 000 more than in 201315 Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England By 2020, 72. 5% of GM residents will be active or fairly active, compared to 71% in 2016. This equates to more than 75, 000 more people ‘moving’ by 2020 A 49. 9% of people in GM completing IAPT treatment moved to recovery in the three months to June 2018, below the England average of 52. 3%, but up from 49. 2% in the three months to June 2017 A 72. 9% of GM adults (16+) were ‘active’ or ‘fairly active’ as of May 2018* An increase of 0. 5 percentage points compared to May 2017 1. 9 percentage points below the England average * Note: unlike the target, the reported data refer solely to over-16 activity levels. Physical activity levels for <16 year olds will be incorporated on publication of the ‘Children’s Active Lives’ survey in April 2019 Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England Active 56. 8% 61. 6% 65. 6% 56. 6% 55. 1% 64. 1% 65. 0% 57. 1% 60. 5% 57. 3% 60. 6% 62. 3% 26. 7 21. 6 46. 7 26. 7 30. 1 37. 4 18. 6 27. 7 21. 0 23. 3 28. 0 18. 6 A Fairly Active 14. 4% 12. 7% 10. 6% 13. 5% 12. 5% 11. 8% 11. 5% 13. 7% 12. 3% 12. 5% Inactive 28. 8% 25. 7% 23. 9% 30. 0% 32. 4% 24. 1% 23. 1% 31. 4% 25. 9% 30. 1% 27. 1% 25. 2% Supporting indicators As of 2014 -16, female healthy life expectancy was 60. 6, 3. 3 years below the national average Male healthy life expectancy was 59. 4, 3. 9 years below the national average A A In 2017, 17. 5% of GM adult residents were smokers 2. 6 percentage points above the England average 0. 9 percentage points lower than 2016 R The rate of hospital admissions with alcoholrelated conditions was 679 per 100, 000 of the population in 2016/17 6. 8% higher than the England average 3. 9% below 2015/16 levels A 76% of adult social care locations in GM were rated as ‘good’ or ‘outstanding’ in September 2018 A 6. 6 percentage points below the England average Note: comparable trend data are not available 63. 3% of adults in GM were overweight (BMI >25) in 2016/17 2 percentage points above the England average 0. 6 percentage points higher than 2015/16 A In 2015, one year cancer survival rates in GM were 71. 2% 1. 1 percentage points below the England average 0. 9 percentage points higher than 2014 A 20. 3% of GM residents reported high levels of anxiety in 2017/18 0. 3 percentage points above the England average A 1. 5 percentage points lower than the 2016/17 position Context and challenges • • • Updated data were available for around half of the measures reported above: IAPT access and recovery rates; the proportion of residents who were active or fairly active; smoking prevalence; CQC adult social care ratings; and the proportion of residents reporting high levels of anxiety. There will inevitably be a time lag before the impact of GM activity is demonstrated in the premature mortality data, but smoking prevalence is a good indicator of progress against all three targeted measures. The 2017 data show a 0. 9 percentage point reduction in the proportion of GM adult residents who were smokers, greater than the 0. 7 point reduction for England as a whole (although the gap with the latter remains significant). Positive progress was also evident in the latest reported data on alcohol-related hospital admissions and the proportion of residents who were active or fairly active, both of which should signal shifts in the higher-level outcomes. Core activity under the GM Population Health Plan includes Make Smoking History, GM Moving and the GM Cancer Plan, which should accelerate these early signs of improvement. Local Care Organisations (LCOs) and Single Commissioning Functions continue to be embedded, focused on integration across locality health and social care systems, although there is some variance in progress. These structural changes will support implementation of transformation activity on the ground, including reform of primary care, urgent and emergency care, mental care, adult social care and dementia provision. A health and social care workforce strategy is also being implemented to ensure that front-line staff are better equipped to deliver new models of care. More broadly, a prospectus for the next phase of health and social care devolution is currently being developed.

Priority 10 – An age-friendly Greater Manchester GMS indicators By 2020, 90% of people aged over 50 in GM will identify their neighbourhood as ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ age-friendly, compared to 80% in 2017 80. 6% A of people aged over 50 in eight GM localities identified their neighbourhood as ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ agefriendly, as reported by the Ambition for Ageing programme in the year to July 2018 * 1. 1 percentage points behind the target trajectory, and slightly below the year to July 2017 (81. 2%) By 2020, 5, 000 more 50 -64 year olds will be in employment, relative to a June 2016 baseline of 316, 000 67. 6% of 50 -64 year old GM residents (335, 000) were in employment in the year to June 2018 5. 0% (16, 000) ahead of the estimated target trajectory Up from 66. 6% (325, 000) for the year to June 2017 In 2015/16, there were 10, 426 hospital admissions due to falls amongst GM residents aged over 65. By 2020, we will have reduced this to fewer than 9, 700 falls pa G Bolton Bury Manchester Oldham Rochdale Salford Stockport Tameside Trafford Wigan GM England 65. 1% 71. 0% 62. 3% 61. 8% 63. 5% 73. 0% 75. 1% 65. 4% 71. 6% 68. 5% 67. 6% 71. 4% 2, 398 hospital admissions for falls per 10, 000 GM residents aged >65 in 2016/17 (10, 096 in total) 3. 1% behind the target trajectory Down from 2, 512 in 2015/16 A Admissions per 10, 000 >65 year olds, 2016/17 Bolton 1, 904 Bury 1, 784 Manchester 2, 540 Oldham 2, 478 Rochdale 2, 126 Salford 2, 942 Stockport 2, 546 Tameside 2, 143 Trafford 2, 421 Wigan 2, 820 GM 2, 398 England 2, 114 By 2020, we will meet or exceed the national average for the proportion of adult social care users who have as much social contact as they would like 44. 7% of adult social care service users had as much social contact as they would like in 2017/18* A 1. 3 percentage points below the national average (46. 0%) Up from 42. 2% in 2016/17 * Looking to replace this with a measure that is representative of older people more broadly and the extent to which they feel socially isolated, potentially sourced from a new GM residents’ survey * Looking to modify this measure to capture data for all 10 localities through a potential new GM residents’ survey Supporting indicators In 2017/18, there were 766 admissions to residential and nursing care per 100, 000 GM residents aged >65, down from 820 in 2016/17, but significantly above the 2017/18 England average (569 per 100, 000) R 42. 6% of deaths in GM during the year to June 2018 occurred at the person’s usual place of residence, slightly above the figure for the previous year (42. 2%), but below the England average for the year to June 2018 (46. 7%) Note that the most recent data (Q 1 2018/19) are provisional A Context and challenges • • • All of the Priority 10 indicators have been updated in this version of the Performance Report, with the exception of the number of hospital admissions for falls. With regard to the proportion of people identifying their neighbourhood as ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ age-friendly, performance is slightly down compared to the previously reported period, and lags the target trajectory, but this may reflect Ambition for Ageing’s recent focus in engaging with people who are more excluded and socially isolated. In line with data reported under other GMS priorities, progress on employment is good, with a higher proportion of 50 -64 years in work, although still a significant gap with the England average. Similarly, improved performance is evident on the proportion of adult social care users who have as much social contact as they would like, the number of care home admissions and end of life experience, albeit the gap with the national data remains. GM is seeking to address the challenges of an ageing population with a positive vision of ageing, set out in the GM Age-Friendly Strategy. Key actions have included the publication of new reports: with Tf. GM to support age-friendly transport; and with the Centre for Ageing Better (Cf. AB) and Manchester School of Architecture on housing and ageing. We are also working with Cf. AB to identify a new suite of indicators for the Age-Friendly Strategy, and will reflect this in a refreshed indicator set for future Priority 10 reporting. The Mayoral Challenge was launched by GMCA with GMCVO, and will lead to 50 age-friendly communities by 2020. The first GM Festival of Ageing was held in July 2018, led by VCSE agencies, and comprised 360 local events plus large events in each locality. 103 small investments were awarded and overall there were 12, 639 attendees.

Annex: data sources and update log

Priority 1 Children starting school ready to learn Indicator Source 1. 1 Proportion of Children Achieving a "Good Level of Early years foundation stage profile results: 2017 to 2018, ONS Development" (EYFS Profile) 1. 2 Low Birth Weight (<2500 g) Live Births at Term PHE Fingertips, 2. 01 1. 3 Early Years Settings Rated "Good" or "Outstanding" Childcare providers and inspections as at 31 March 2018, Table 7, Df. E by OFSTED at most recent inspection Statistics on Women's Smoking Status at Time of Delivery, England, NHS 1. 0. 1 Mothers Smoking at the Time of Delivery Digital 1. 0. 2 0 -4 Year Old Dental Extractions with Decay as the PHE dental health, extractions data Primary Diagnosis Priority 2 2. 1 Looked after Children (number, and rate per 10, 000 Children looked after in England including adoption: 2016 to 2017 (SFR Young people children <18) 50/2017) equipped for 2. 2 Attainment at the end of Key Stage 2 in reading, National curriculum assessments: key stage 2, 2018 (provisional) life writing and mathematics 2. 3 Average Attainment 8 score per pupil, at the end of GCSE and equivalent results in England 2017/18 (provisional)) Key Stage 4 2. 4 16 -17 year olds who are NEET (not in education, Proportion of 16 -17 year olds recorded as NEET or whose activity is not employment or training) known, end 2016 2. 5 Proportion of 16 -19 year olds in employment Annual Population Survey, NOMIS 2. 0. 1 Bed days for children and young people aged Mental Health Five Year Forward View Dashboard Q 4 2017/18 under 18 in CAMHS tier 4 wards 2. 0. 2 Average Progress 8 score per pupil, at the end of GCSE and equivalent results in England 2017/18 (provisional)) Key Stage 4 2. 0. 3 Proportion of 10 -11 year old children who are National Child Measurement Programme, NHS Digital overweight or obese Priority 3 3. 1 Median resident earnings, all employees Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings - resident analysis, NOMIS Good jobs, 3. 2 Proportion of working-age residents with Level 4 Annual Population Survey, NOMIS with qualifications opportunities 3. 3 Proportion of working-age residents with Annual Population Survey, NOMIS for people to qualifications below Level 2 progress and 3. 4 Apprenticeship starts and achievement rate FE Data Library: Apprenticeships develop 3. 0. 1 Proportion of working-age residents with Level 3 Annual Population Survey, NOMIS qualifications 3. 0. 2 Proportion of the working-age population who are Annual Population Survey, NOMIS unemployed 3. 0. 3 Claimant rate, unemployment benefits Claimant Count, NOMIS Updated Oct 2018? Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes

Priority 4 - A thriving and productive economy in all parts of Greater Manchester Priority 5 World-class connectivity that keeps Greater Manchester moving Indicator Source 4. 1 GVA per job GM Accelerated Growth Scenario (AGS) 2018 4. 2 Proportion of employee jobs earning above the Real Living Wage Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings - ONS user-requested data 4. 3 Proportion of working-age population in employment Annual Population Survey, NOMIS Business Demography 2016 (and NOMIS mid-year population 4. 4 Number of business start-ups per 10, 000 working-age population estimates) 4. 5 GVA generated from foreign direct investment (FDI) job creation Data sourced directly from MIDAS Updated Oct 2018? Yes No Yes 4. 0. 1 Proportion of working-age population from ethnic minority groups in employment Annual Population Survey, NOMIS Yes 4. 0. 2 Proportion of working-age population with a disability in employment Annual Population Survey, NOMIS Yes 4. 0. 3 Number of enterprises per 10, 000 working-age population Business Demography 2016 (and NOMIS mid-year population estimates) No 5. 1 Journeys to Work 5. 2 Journey Time Reliability 5. 3 Air Quality 5. 4 Digital Infrastructure 5. 0. 1 All Journeys by Non-Car Modes 5. 0. 2 Public Transport Accessibility 5. 0. 3 Short Journeys by Cycling or Walking 5. 0. 4 Digital Inclusion Priority 6 6. 1 Net additional dwellings Safe, decent and 6. 2 Street count and rough sleeping estimates affordable housing 6. 0. 1 a Lower quartile house prices to average incomes - Prices No Data sourced directly from Transport for Greater Manchester (Tf. GM). Yes Connected Nations, OFCOM Yes Data sourced directly from Transport for Greater Manchester (Tf. GM) Get Digital Heatmap, Tech Partnership Live tables on housing supply: net additional dwellings, Table 122, MHCLG Rough sleeping in England, MHCLG Lower quartile price paid for administrative geographies - HPSSA Dataset 15, Table 1 a & 4 a, ONS Yes Yes No No No Yes 6. 0. 1 b Lower quartile house prices to average incomes - Median Income 6. 0. 2 a Empty housing stock - Empty Dwellings Annual Survey Hours & Earnings, NOMIS - Resident Median Earnings Live tables on dwelling stock, Table 615, MHCLG Yes 6. 0. 2 b Empty housing stock - All Stock Live tables on dwelling stock, Table 100, MHCLG Yes 6. 0. 3 Positive action to prevent or relieve homelessness Live tables on homelessness, Table 792 & 792 a, MHCLG Yes 6. 0. 4 Housing benefit and universal credit housing component Stat Xplore Yes 6. 0. 5 Resident satisfaction with local community Understanding Society - The UK Longitudinal Household Study No No

Priority 7 - A green city region and a high quality culture and leisure offer for all Indicator Source Updated Oct 2018? 7. 2 Waste Recycled and Diverted 7. 3 Residents Visiting Natural Environment 7. 4 Participation in Cultural Events UK local authority and regional carbon dioxide emissions national statistics: 2005 -2015 Data sourced from Greater Manchester Waste Disposal Authority (GMWDA) Monitor of Engagement with the Natural Environment (MENE), Natural England Data sourced from Association of Greater Manchester Authorities (AGMA) 7. 5 Visitor Economy Greater Manchester's Tourism Economic Activity Monitor, STEAM, 2016 No 7. 0. 1 Life Satisfaction Personal well-being estimates, ONS Yes 7. 0. 2 FTE Jobs Supported by the Tourisms Industry Greater Manchester's Tourism Economic Activity Monitor, STEAM, 2016 No 7. 0. 3 Conference & Business Events Conference Value & Volume, Marketing Manchester, 2017 Yes 7. 0. 4 Anholt Brand Index No Yes 7. 0. 6 a Renewable Energy Generation - Electricity Anholt Brand Index Live tables on Energy Performance of Buildings Certificates, Tables LA 1 & DEC 1, BEIS Sub-regional Feed-in Tariffs statistics, BEIS 7. 0. 6 b Renewable Energy Generation - Heat Renewable Heat Incentive statistics Yes Data sourced from the Crime Survey for England & Wales at force level Yes Understanding Society - The UK Longitudinal Household Study No PHE Fingertips - 4. 04 ii No PHE Fingertips - 4. 05 ii No PHE Fingertips - 4. 07 ii No Five year forward view dashboard, NHS England Yes Active Lives Survey, Sport England Yes 9. 0. 1 Healthy life expectancy PHE Fingertips - 0. 1 i & 01 ii No 9. 0. 2 Smoking prevalence PHE Fingertips - Smoking prevalence in adults (APS) Yes 9. 0. 3 Alcohol-related hospital admissions 9. 0. 4 Adult social care locations rated "Good" or "Outstanding" by the CQC 9. 0. 5 Levels of overweight (BMI >25) PHE Fingertips - 10. 01 No Care Quality Commission, Care Directory Yes PHE Fingertips – 2. 12 No 9. 0. 6 One year cancer survival rates Index of cancer survival for Clinical Commissioning Groups in England, ONS No 9. 0. 7 High levels of anxiety Personal well-being estimates, ONS Yes 7. 1 CO 2 Emissions 7. 0. 5 Energy Efficiency Priority 8 - 8. 1 Household crime Safer and 8. 2 Personal crime stronger communities 8. 0. 1 Unsafe in a public location 8. 0. 2 Neighbourhood belonging Yes No No Yes 8. 0. 3 People in this neighbourhood don't get along Priority 9 - 9. 1 Premature mortality due to cardiovascular disease Healthy lives, 9. 2 Premature mortality due to cancer with quality 9. 3 Premature mortality due to respiratory disease care for those who 9. 4 Access to evidence-based psychological therapies need it 9. 5 Physical activity

Priority 10 An agefriendly Greater Manchester Indicator 10. 1 Proportion of people >50 identifying their neighbourhood as 'very' or 'somewhat' age-friendly 10. 2 Proportion of 50 -64 year olds in employment 10. 3 Number of falls per 10, 000 residents >65 10. 4 Proportion of adult social care users who have as much social contact as they would like 10. 0. 1 Number of admissions to residential and nursing care per 100, 000 people >65 10. 0. 2 Proportion of deaths in usual place of residence Source Updated Oct 2018? Ambition for Ageing programme data Yes Annual Population Survey, NOMIS Yes PHE Fingertips - Public Health Profiles NHS Digital, Measures from the Adult Social Care Outcomes Framework (ASCOF), England 2017 -18 Rolling Annual death registrations by place of occurrence, England, No Yes Yes