Estimating critical acid loads across the lower 48
- Slides: 47
Estimating critical acid loads across the lower 48 US: Opportunities and challenges Steven Mc. Nulty USDA Forest Service Southern Research Station Raleigh, NC Steve_mcnulty@ncsu. edu
Three Parts to the Presentation 1. Development of a simple mass balance equation of critical acid loading and exceedances to forest soils across the conterminous US at a 1 km 2 resolution 2. Assess how a changing climate could impact forest soil critical acid loads 3. Discuss why historic definitions of a “healthy” forest may need to change
Part 1. Development of a simple mass balance equation of critical acid loading and exceedances to forest soils across the conterminous US
Standard definition of a critical load A critical load can be defined as a quantitative estimate of an exposure to one or more pollutants below which significant harmful effects on specified sensitive elements of the environment do not occur according to present knowledge. When pollutant loads exceed the critical load it is considered that there is risk of harmful effects. The excess over the critical load has been termed the exceedance. A larger exceedence is often considered to pose a greater risk of damage. UK Centre for Ecology and Hydrology
Simple Mass Balance Equation for Forest Soils CL(S+N) = BCdep – Cldep + BCw – BCu + Ni +Nu +Nde – ANCle(crit) BCdep Cldep BCw BCu = Base Cation Deposition = Chloride Deposition = Base Cation Weathering = Base Cation Uptake Ni = Nitrogen Immobilization Nu = Nitrogen Uptake Nde = Nitrogen Denitrification ANCe(crit) = Acid Neutralizing Capacity
Simple Mass Balance Equation for Forest Soils CL(S+N) = BCdep – Cldep + BCw – BCu + Ni +Nu +Nde – ANCle(crit) BCdep Cldep BCw BCu = Base Cation Deposition = Chloride Deposition = Base Cation Weathering = Base Cation Uptake Ni = Nitrogen Immobilization Nu = Nitrogen Uptake Nde = Nitrogen Denitrification ANCe(crit) = Acid Neutralizing Capacity
Data Wet Deposition Ca, Mg, K, Na, Cl, N, SO 4, NH 4, NO 3 – Eastern US Grimms and Lynch, 2003 Incorporates elevation into calculation ~300 m 2 resolution – Western US USGS NADP/NTN 6. 25 km 2 resolution Climate – – – Spatial Climate Analysis Service Prism Temperature, Precipitation 4 km 2 and 16 km 2 resolution
Data National Forest Cover Dataset – USGS/USFS – 25 tree classes – 1 km 2 resolution Soil – Miller and White, 1998 – Soil fraction, depth to bedrock, soil unit – 1 km 2 resolution
Data Resolution – 1 km 2 across all forested soils Temporal Extent – Average 1994 - 2000 Spatial Extent – Conterminous United States
• BC = Ca + K + Mg + Na
BC = Ca + K + Mg + Na
BC = Ca + K + Mg
Acid Neutralizing Capacity
Estimated Forest Soil Critical Acid Load
Estimated Areas of Forest Soil in Exceedence of the Critical Acid Load
For more details on this study see Mc. Nulty, Steven G. ; Cohen, Erika C. ; Moore Myers, Jennifer A. ; Sullivan, Timothy J. ; and Li, Harbin. 2007. Estimates of critical acid loads and exceedences forest soils across the conterminous United States. Environmental Pollution 149: 281 -292
Part 2. Climate change Impacts on forest soil critical acid loads Define environmental conditions impacting forest soil critical acid loads that will likely change with climate Assess the directions an magnitude of change Recalculate critical acid loads based on updated parameters
Simple Mass Balance Equation for Forest Soils CL(S+N) = BCdep – Cldep + BCw – BCu + Ni +Nu +Nde – ANCle(crit) BCdep Cldep BCw BCu = Base Cation Deposition = Chloride Deposition = Base Cation Weathering = Base Cation Uptake Ni = Nitrogen Immobilization Nu = Nitrogen Uptake Nde = Nitrogen Denitrification ANCe(crit) = Acid Neutralizing Capacity
Climate change factors Base cation weathering - as air temperature increases, BCW will increase (increasing the CAL) Nitrogen uptake – as air temperature increases, productivity increases and nitrogen uptake will increase (increasing the CAL) Acid Neutralizing capacity (2 components) - as air temperature increases, productivity increases and base cation uptake increases (reducing ANC the CAL) - as air temperature increases, forest evaportanspiration increases and runoff decreases (reducing ANC and reducing CAL)
Gross ecosystem productivity change
Implications Changing climate could signficantly impact the amount of forest soil In exceedance of the critical acid load - total forest area in exceedance could decrease by 6% However, most of the exceedance occurs in New England where The impacts of climate change will be felt the most. - Therefore, the amount of area in the highest catogory of Exceedance (i. e. 750 eq/ha/yr) could decrease by over 20%
HOWEVER! Before we all go rushing out turn up our thermastats and purchase Cadillacs to do our part to contribute to global warming, we should listen to the last part of the talk. .
Part 3. Beyond altering the forest soil critical acid loading on a forest, can climate change Impact how healthy forests respond to stress? A Case Study entitled “The Rise of the Mediocre Forest”
Picea rubens (red spruce) mortality near Asheville, NC
The loss of the red spruce in the southern Appalachian Mountains
Background Western NC experienced a moderate three year drought from 1999 -2002. In 2001, red spruce (Picea rubens) trees began to die in large numbers in and around Mt. Mitchell NC, USA. The initial evidence suggested that the affected trees were killed by the southern pine beetle (SPB). This insect species is not normally successful at colonizing these tree species. Subsequent investigations revealed an interesting pattern where trees died or survived the SPB attack.
Five Year Averaged Climate (1951 – 2001), Mt. Mitchell, NC, USA
Sampling damaged Southern Appalachian red spruce stand
Drought Stress Drought, Temperature, Insect, & N deposition Stresses
Residual Tree Foliar Chemistry 0. 12 Dead Plots Live Plots 1. 3 0. 1 1. 2 0. 08 1. 1 0. 06 1. 0 Foliar N Foliar Mg: N 0. 04 Foliar Mg: N Ratio Foliar N Concentration (%) 1. 4
Basal Area Growth as a Tree Water Stress
Questions What conditions allowed the red spruce to be colonized? Why did only the larger, more vigorous trees on some plots die?
Hypothesis for mortality • The area in and around Asheville received elevated nitrogen deposition, but these levels are below that considered critical acid load • The ratio between above ground growth (i. e. , stem wood, branches and foliage) and below ground growth (i. e. coarse and fine roots) increased • The increased level of nitrogen inputs likely had a fertilization impact
Hypothesis for mortality (cont. ) • The larger more vigorously growing trees had a higher AG/BG ratio than the small trees • The drought conditions reduced available water, carbohydrate reserves for the production of secondary carbon compounds such as oleoresin. The lack of oleoresin (especially in large trees) allowed for the colonization of and large scale forest mortality witnessed during that time.
Stress interactions Elevated nitrogen deposition Causing altered tree physiology Forest Mortality Climate Change Reducing carbohydrate reserves Insects Causing tree mortality through colonization and tree girdling by larval feeding
Conclusions As the climate warmers, insects become more active (no big surprise) As the climate warms, trees use more water and the potential for soil drying and tree desiccation increases Interactions between air pollutants and climate change can exacerbate the insect stress by altering the tree physiology and morphology Insect damage is likely to occur in new ways and more frequently in the future
If any one of the three environmental stresses were removed, the mortality would not likely have occurred
How a different critical nitrogen load could be determined within the same ecosystem N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr N leaching = 0 Mortality = 0% + 3 yr Drought Stress N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr + 3 yr Drought Stress + insects + temperature N leaching = 10 Mortality = 10% N leaching = 25 Mortality = 100% Critical N > 10 kg Load N leaching = 1 Mortality = 5% Critical = 10 kg Load N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr Critical = 8 kg Load Critical < 5 kg Load
For more details on this study see Mc. Nulty, Steven G. , and Johnny Boggs. 2009. A Conceptual Framework for Redefining Forest Soil Critical Acid Loads under a Changing Climate. Environmental Pollution (In Press).
Solutions Coarse scale application of simple mass balance equation predictions of forest soil critical acid loading can provide some guidance on potential areas of forest acid load exceedence, continue to use them Climate change will likely reduce the red spruce growth and acid uptake. Account for these reduction by reducing the ecosystems critical acid load level.
- Critical semi critical and non critical instruments
- Semicritical
- Lower critical temperature is
- Critical reading meaning
- Axially loaded member
- Hydraulic machines move heavy loads in accordance with
- Sensible loads
- Members used to carry wall loads over wall openings
- Sana altaf
- Racking stress of container
- Employers must not place construction loads
- Handles on these must not extend beyond
- Goodman diagram example
- The pipe assembly supports the vertical loads shown
- Handling system design
- Shock absorber design
- Handles on these must not extend beyond
- Approximate analysis of statically indeterminate structures
- The structural members supporting loads at various points.
- Reverse horseshoe hose load
- Linear static analysis theory
- Jitisa
- Fire hose loads
- Acyl chloride to nitrile
- 9-which acid is not considered a strong acid?
- Identifying lewis acids and bases practice
- Hcl lewis acid or base
- Acid fast vs non acid fast
- Lewis acid bronsted acid
- Is sulfuric acid a weak acid
- Hydrolysis of ether gives
- What are the seven strong acids
- Stomach acid vs battery acid
- Acid fast vs non acid fast
- V cc
- Thẻ vin
- Thơ thất ngôn tứ tuyệt đường luật
- Alleluia hat len nguoi oi
- Hươu thường đẻ mỗi lứa mấy con
- Diễn thế sinh thái là
- Vẽ hình chiếu vuông góc của vật thể sau
- Công của trọng lực
- Làm thế nào để 102-1=99
- Tỉ lệ cơ thể trẻ em
- Lời thề hippocrates
- Vẽ hình chiếu đứng bằng cạnh của vật thể
- đại từ thay thế
- Quá trình desamine hóa có thể tạo ra