CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE RISK ASSESSMENT SUPPORT QUALITATIVE CRITERIA ASSESSMENT

CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE RISK ASSESSMENT SUPPORT QUALITATIVE CRITERIA ASSESSMENT (QCA) 2 nd Stakeholders’ Workshop Aschaffenburg, November, 26 th, 2015 Jaime Martín, Project coordinator

Qualitative Criteria Assessment (QCA) • Include in the decision-making process non-tangible criteria such as privacy, laws, environmental issues… • set of criteria categorised in groups have been prepared 9 categories, over 140 criteria • It requires an assessment of those qualitative criteria

QCA steps

Sample of visualization • Interdependencies: shows criteria which are related, highlighting “parents and children” of a pointed criterion

QCA steps (II)

Results Numerical comparison of alternatives

Results (II) Different graphical representatiomns are available: spider charts, bar charts

MAHP • An alternative way to perform the QCA • Its a modified version of the Analytical Hierarchy Process • Currently this is in progress more about this will explained in our final conference!

Considerations • QCA RRA (input is provided as well as RRA deals with intangible parameters) • The top goal / aggregated values from QCA are handed over as parameters to be regarded in RRA

Thank you for your attention! Jaime Martín Pérez Project Coordinator ATOS Spain jaime. martinp@atos. net +34 912148908 www. cirasproject. eu Co-funded by the Prevention, Preparedness and Consequence Management of Terrorism and other Securityrelated Risks Programme of the European Union