COUNTERCLAIM WHAT IS IT A counterclaim is when

COUNTERCLAIM • WHAT IS IT?

A counterclaim is when the writer recognizes an opposing viewpoint and then argues against it.

In other words, it is the “yes, but…” part of the argument.

EXAMPLES: • ISSUE: A teenager wants parental permission to go to a concert. • CLAIM: I should be allowed to go to a concert without an adult.

EXAMPLE: • Recognize the counterclaim (YES) and then argue with (BUT. . . ) your response. • Of course you are worried about me going without you; however, I have a cell phone and will check in with you.

EXAMPLE: • Recognize the counterclaim (YES) and then argue with (BUT. . . ) your response. • Certainly I can see why you might be concerned because you don’t know any of my friends, but I’ll be glad to ask their parents to call and reassure you.

EXAMPLE: • Recognize the counterclaim (YES) and then argue with (BUT. . . ) your response. • Admittedly, it is a good point that I do have homework; but on the other hand, the concert is only a few hours and will try to get most of it done before I go.

PRACTICE: • Read the article titled “ADOPT a PUPPY” • Circle the counterclaim. • Hint: there are 2 in this article

PRACTICE • Read the article titled “The Case for the Cell Phone in Schools” • Circle the counterclaim. • How many can you find in this article?