Conflict CONFLICT 2 CONFLICT In this lesson we

Conflict

CONFLICT 2

CONFLICT In this lesson we will consider, in more detail than in lesson 1, what we mean by the terms ‘conflict’ and ‘violence’ in global politics. As with many terms, these are both contested concepts and it would be impossible to look at all possible interpretations. 3

Heidelberg Institute for International Conflict Research • • The HIIK's annual publication Conflict Barometer describes the recent trends in global conflict developments, escalations, de-escalations, and settlements Coup d’état, attempted coups d'états, as well as implemented measures of conflict resolution are also reported. It is subdivided into five world regions and presents all present conflicts in detailed charts and short descriptions. The methodological approach consists of the conflict definition and the measuring of the conflict intensity.

HIICR Definition of Conflict A political conflict is a positional difference between at least two assertive and directly involved actors regarding values relevant to a society which is carried out using observable and interrelated conflict measures that lie outside established regulatory procedures and threaten core state functions, the international order, or hold the prospect of doing so

Positional Difference and Conflict The essence of a political conflict lies in a contradiction, adequately represented by the concept of a “positional difference” A positional difference is a perceived incompatibility of ideas and beliefs

Elements of positional difference #1 • There must be at least two entities possessing intellectual capacity and vision, and who are capable of communicating. • Such an entity is called an actor

Elements of positional difference #2 • In order for the actors to sense incompatibility between their ideas and beliefs, there must be reciprocal actions and acts of communication between said actors. • These actions and acts of communication are called measures

Elements of positional difference #3 • Conflict actors are individuals or collectives that are relevant because they are taken into account by other conflict actors in their decision-making processes. Collective actors are characterized by their high degree of internal cohesion manifesting in a coherent structure of preferences. They include states, international organizations and non-state actors • Conflict measures are actions and communications carried out by a conflict actor in the context of a political conflict. • Conflict issues are material or immaterial goods pursued by conflict actors via conflict measures

Fivefold Typography of Conflict Dispute Non-Violent Crisis Limited War 10

Intensity Dispute Non-violent crisis Definition A political conflict is classified as a dispute if it meets all elements of the basic concept. A political conflict is classified as a non-violent crisis if physical violence is being implicitly or explicitly threatened to persons or property by at least one of the actors, or if one actor uses physical violence against property, without regarding the injury of people as acceptable. A threat of force is understood as a verbally or non-verbally communicated prospect of violent measures that is based on the conflict item. An acceptance of the injury of persons is present when the use of force against property includes the possibility of the injury of people but the violator is indifferent to this possibility. Violent crisis A political conflict is classified as a violent crisis when at least one actor uses force sporadically against persons - or things in case that physical violence against people is considered acceptable. The applied means and consequences altogether are limited. Limited war A political conflict is classified as a limited war when at least one actor uses force against persons and maybe things in a distinctive way. The applied means and consequences altogether are serious. War A political conflict is classified as a war when at least one actor uses force massively against persons and maybe things. The applied means and consequences altogether need to be framed as extensive.

Activity: • Evaluate the usefulness of the HIICR fivefold typography of conflict • For each of the five categories of conflict give a contemporary example and say why you chose it

VIOLENCE Structural violence refers to systematic ways in which social structures harm or otherwise disadvantage individuals. Structural violence is subtle, often invisible, and often has no one specific person who can (or will) be held responsible (in contrast to behavioral violence). 14

VIOLENCE 15

STRUCTURAL VIOLENCE https: //www. youtube. com/watch? time_continu e=61&v=_b. Ri. Myv 22 GI 16

THEORY OF STRUCTURAL VIOLENCE https: //www. youtube. com/watch? time_continue=21&v=-mj. Vk. GEDw-k 17

Direct Violence vs. Structural Violence It is essential for the Global Politics Course that students are able to accurately distinguish between direct violence and structural violence. 18