COMMUNITY FOUNDATION BASICS FOR BOARD MEMBERS UNIT 7
COMMUNITY FOUNDATION BASICS FOR BOARD MEMBERS UNIT 7 OPERATIONAL SUSTAINABILITY
REVENUE SOURCES § Administrative Fees on Endowed Funds § Payout from Operating Endowment § Administrative Fees from Pass-through Funds § Annual fundraising for Operating Funds § Grant from Unrestricted Fund § Draw on Operating Reserve
SUSTAINABILITY IS NOT DETERMINED BY ASSET SIZE IT’S ALL ABOUT ASSET MIX = NUMBER, TYPE AND SIZE OF FUNDS
ASSET – EXPENSE MISMATCH Total Assets Asset Mix Revenue Workload Expenses
Law governing scholarship is very specific; you need to accept applications, manage a selection process; involves working with schools, individual applicants Managing a competitive grant process requires reviewing proposals, site visits, committee process and reporting Generally lots of transactions because of small gifts; can involve more reporting if CF takes expenditure responsibility Variable workload depending on purpose, process Some donors require a lot of attention; some make lots of small grants Generally involves cutting one check annually; can require meeting with agency leadership periodically; can be extremely challenging if agency runs into serious financial trouble Generally involves cutting one check annually So, workload varies dramatically by fund type; fees generally are 1 -2%
SAMPLE FUND ANALYSIS CHART (DO SIMPLER CHART) Assumptions: each fully loaded staff hour = $50; each fund has a 1% fee Fund Donor Advised Assets Fee Cost Situation $20, 000 $200 $5, 000 $50 Community Fund (unrestricted) Donor Advised $300, 000 $3, 000 $250 Donor gives most of payout to her church Field of Interest $12, 000 $120 Scholarship $40, 000 $400 Lots of small gifts requiring gift entry and acknowledgment letters; requires staff time to determine best use of fund Committee process to award scholarship Agency endowment $10, 000 $100 One check per year Designated $15, 000 $150 One check per year Agency endowment $30, 000 $300 $2, 000 $20 Agency having financial problems and wants $$ back; lots of meetings to address this issue Wants to fund charitable activities of non 501 c 3 organizations $50, 000 $500 Scholarship Donor advised Designated Donor calls all the time asking for information on agencies Committee process to award scholarship 2 grant rounds per year Donor requests change of beneficiary
SUSTAINABILITY FORMULA SUSTAINABLE REVENUE OPERATING EXPENSE “SUSTAINABILITY NUMBER”
GIFT Community Foundation Statistics Based on 2012 CF Insights Data Information 66 community foundations reporting* SUSTAINABILITY STATUS OF GIFT COMMUNITY FOUNDATIONS SUSTAINABILITY RATE 100% or more 90 -99% 80 -89% 70 -79% 60 -69% 50 -59% 40 -49% 30 -39% 0% - 29% NUMBER OF GIFT CFS PERCENT OF GIFT CFS 9 12 13 8 12 5 3 4 none 14% 18% 20% 12% 18% 7% 5% 6% NOTE: Sustainability rate is calculated by the following formula: Administrative Fee Income + Operating Endowment Distribution Divided by Total Operating Expenses *Affiliate community foundations were counted as one organization.
SO WHAT DO WE DO? § A board needs to make a policy decision as to the appropriate balance of sustainable and other revenue and make decisions that, OVER TIME, will move in that direction § A community foundation needs to educate donors about the costs of fund management. Expenses in excess of fees must come from somewhere – the unrestricted fund, annual campaign, operating reserve. § If you have some challenges with sustainability you need to create a long term plan to achieve sustainability OR § If you are currently in a sustainable situation, develop organizational decision making structures can ensure you stay that way
STAFF TIME &SUSTAINABILITY Increase efficiency Recapture staff time Redeploy staff time to activities that support asset development Laser-like focus on asset development
IDEAS § Understand your asset mix. § Learn how to say “no”; learn how to explain why you have to say “no” § Develop “products” that work; put time limits on non-productive funds § Consider a major overhaul of scholarships, the most time-consuming funds. § Raise fund minimums or establish minimum fees or services for products § Spend time cultivating large funds; find efficient ways to involve small donors § Diversify the fee structure to include other types of fees beyond asset fees § Review your grant process; can you eliminate steps or reduce paperwork? § Review your event activities – is the net income is worth the time and expense? § Evaluate your services and communications with current donors. 75% of gifts to Indiana community foundations in 2011 went into existing funds. It all adds up – a small change implemented rigorously over time can make a big difference
The Balancing Act § Meeting individual donor expectations § Providing something for everyone § Being a leader in the community § All things to all people § The fund STORY § Providing responsible stewardship § Long-term commitment to community § Adding real value to community § Building charitable assets for the future § Creating the structure of a permanent institution
Has your board ever discussed the different workload involved in managing different types of funds? What information would be helpful to you? After calculating your sustainability are you pleased? Concerned? What steps do you need to take to become more sustainable or maintain sustainability?
- Slides: 13