Closing Remarks Andrew Hutton Dear Slava It is

Closing Remarks Andrew Hutton

Dear Slava: It is only appropriate that the remarks at your 70 th birthday and in appreciation of your many contributions to Accelerator Science include a note of appreciation from some of the scientists who have benefited from the impact of these contributions on the field of nuclear physics. I will try to give voice to those scientists. (I would have preferred to do it first hand. but I agreed to be on a review at MIT prior to learning about this event. Interestingly, the MIT program being reviewed includes a proposed optical cooling experiment as one of its activities. ) The impact of beam cooling in high energy physics, particularly, at CERN and FNAL is well known, well documented and has been discussed repeatedly at this meeting. . However, in nuclear physics there also major programs that have also produced outstanding science, enabled by beam cooling. Places like IUCF, COSY, and TSL come immediately to mind, and upon further thought, facilities like LEAR at CERN, where experiments sat firmly on the border between High Energy and Nuclear Physics, should be added to the list. ). Of course at least as interesting to the scientists here at JLab is the progress being made toward the design of a high energy electron ion collider, where your insights into polarization preservation, beam cooling, and general accelerator physics has been an inspiration to all involved and where your focus on working through how to optimize the physics potential of the collider has been a model to be emulated. I can only observe, as a bottom line, that the spirit of Novosibirsk, to which you contributed so greatly so many years ago, clearly lives on in your work here and is deeply appreciated by all. We wish you the happiest of birthdays, and many more years of outstanding science. Larry

Acknowledgements Administrative support Audrey Barron, Erin Smith Meeting support Marty Hightower, Ruth Bizot, Stephanie Vermeire, Cynthia Lockwood Shannon Ritter (poster design) David Chopard (web site) Greg Adams (photography) Shahid Ahmed (video recording) CEBAF tour Michelle Lechman, Debbie Magaldi, Dean Golembeski, Mike Klopf, Balsa Terzic, Mike Spata, Jay Benesch, Douglas Higinbotham, Bob Rimmer Student assistants Ilkyoung Shin, Subashini De. Silva, Hisham Sayed, Mahmoud Ahmad, Ryan Bodenstein, Raja Singaravelu, Colin Jarvis, James Kotary, Matthew Kramer

Acknowledgements Most of all – a big thank you to Yuhong Zhang and Geoff Krafft This wonderful event would not have happened without them

Reflections on Aging • My age should not matter, but my maturity should – Anon • Communication is not about the number of things we say; it's about the number of things that are understood – David Brinkley • Teaching without words and work without doing are understood by very few – Lao Tzu

Nothing in life is to be feared. It is only to be understood. -Marie Curie Slava Keep on helping us to understand