Bolts in Tension pt 1 Andrei Lozzi 1

The flanges at the end of the two turbine shafts seen above, are bolted together to form a very rigid friction coupling 2

High pressure turbine casing. Note the proportion of the depth of the flanges to the bolts 3 diameter. Note also the spacing of the bolts. This is one of the most extraordinary bolted joint.

4

These are the heater elements used to ‘grow’ the length of the bolts. When left to cool and the bolts reaches the same temperature as the flanges, they develop the required preload 5

The stem of the bolts is held from turning while the nut is torqued up. Holding the end of the stem prevents torsional stresses being transmitted to the stem. 6

Note that the stem of these bolts have flat faces machine into their ends, allowing the stem to be held while the nut is torqued. Also the ‘stem’ is really a threaded bar 7

8

Simple variations in the detail design of the threads, nuts and bolts in a search to improve fatigue strength 9

Results in stress concentration from the above detail designs variations 10

The effect of fillets and bolt shank cross-section on fatigue strength 11

The effect of the reduction of the bolt shank cross-section by inserting fillets at the start of the threads. 12

Improvements in fatigue life by increasing radius of fillets at the base of external thread 13

14

Article from Volvo on new head bolts stiffness calculation 15

Villiers two stroke engine. In low performance and low efficiency engines one finds simple means of sealing the engine head to the cylinder and thereby containing the combustion products. Here a simple paper gaskets are used both at the head and at the cylinder to crankcase joints. Paper has about 1/2000 the Young’s modulus of iron. Hence the stiffness of the assembly is very poor and the alternating loads on the bolts is not helped much at all by the cast iron cylinder 16

Bolts do generate uniform pressure over the whole face of a flange. In fact they only clamp around a cone of 30 ° and then even there the pressure is not uniform. The flanges interface separates away from this cone. The separation occurs because under compression the flange material expands laterally. This effect may be seen on the FEA example shown below. Any gasket or sealant must be able to fill the gap with sufficient strength to prevent any leak. 30° cone Clearance bolt hole Washer dia Cones in compression 17

Coventry Climax, 2 liters 4 cyl, 62 The ‘head’ of this engine is removable. To seal the combustion products a reasonable even pressure has to be maintained all around the interface between the cylinder block and the head. Cylinder head Interface head to cylinder block. Cylinder head hold-down studs To achieve this the studs begin half way through the cylinder block and extend all the way to the top of the engine. Each cylinder has 4 bolts equally disposed around its periphery. By this sort of strategy the conical compression zones generated by the pretension has space to spread from the middle of the cylinder block, to all around the top of the cylinder and meet similar cones coming from the head. 18

FT A simple example of parallel load paths. Here for the spring at left, we can say because it has fewer coils, of thicker wire and of smaller coil diameter, will be stiffer than the one at right. Let the relative stiffness be: KL = 10 KR If the applied force F causes an extension of Δ, the force carried by the left and right springs are: F R = Δ KR FL = Δ KL = Δ 10 KR Where FT = FL + FR = Δ 11 KR The fraction of the force carried by either spring is proportional to the relative stiffness of that spring. FL / FT = 10 / 11 FR / FT = 1/ 11 FT The applied external force is divided between the two load paths in proportion to the ratio of their stiffness to the total stiffness. 19

20