Arguments explaining lynching Argument Problem Evidence Solution Argument
Arguments explaining lynching
Argument Problem Evidence Solution
Argument It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Problem Evidence Solution
Argument It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Problem Evidence Solution
Argument It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state Problem Evidence Solution
Argument It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state Problem Ancient barbaric customs that still survive Evidence Solution
Argument It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state Problem Ancient barbaric customs that still survive Evidence They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Solution
Argument It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state Problem Ancient barbaric customs that still survive Evidence They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Solution Education, “civilization”, modernization
Argument Problem It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state Evidence They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Solution Education, “civilization”, modernization
Argument Problem Evidence It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system They target (mostly) criminals; there is a high crime rate, and weak states and legal systems where it happens Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state Solution Education, “civilization”, modernization
Argument Problem Evidence Solution It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Education, “civilization”, modernization The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system They target (mostly) criminals; there is a high crime rate, and weak states and legal systems where it happens More courts, more police, more (formal) justice Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state
Argument Problem Evidence Solution It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Education, “civilization”, modernization The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system They target (mostly) criminals; there is a high crime rate, and weak states and legal systems where it happens More courts, more police, more (formal) justice Excluded populations are asserting control over their own lives, sending a message to the state
Argument Problem Evidence Solution It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Education, “civilization”, modernization The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system They target (mostly) criminals; there is a high crime rate, and weak states and legal systems where it happens More courts, more police, more (formal) justice Excluded Not ancient customs, populations are not (just) crime, not asserting control (just) the absence of over their own state legality; lives, sending a denial of agency: message to the state always turns state them into victims, and now they are sending a message back
Argument Problem Evidence Solution It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Education, “civilization”, modernization The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system They target (mostly) criminals; there is a high crime rate, and weak states and legal systems where it happens More courts, more police, more (formal) justice Excluded Not ancient customs, populations are not (just) crime, not asserting control (just) the absence of over their own state legality; lives, sending a denial of agency: message to the state always turns state them into victims, and now they are sending a message back It only happens in some high crime areas, where there is social and economic dislocation. The killings are highly ritualized and public and copy state proceedings.
Argument Problem Evidence Solution It’s just a manifestation of the savagery of uncivilized Indians and peasants Ancient barbaric customs that still survive They happen in remote locations; in indigenous/peasant communities; or urban locations among less educated Education, “civilization”, modernization The population is fed up with crime and the failure of the state to respond Crime, weak state, weak legal system They target (mostly) criminals; there is a high crime rate, and weak states and legal systems where it happens More courts, more police, more (formal) justice It only happens in some high crime areas, where there is social and economic dislocation. The killings are highly ritualized and public and copy state proceedings. Address socio-economic conditions that disempower these groups, so they can once again rely on the state to supply justice; reform the state so it responds. Permit alternative legal systems (indigenous law and other informal legal systems), as an empowering device Excluded Not ancient customs, populations are not (just) crime, not asserting control (just) the absence of over their own state legality; lives, sending a denial of agency: message to the state always turns state them into victims, and now they are sending a message back
- Slides: 15