Ao IR 16 PAYAL ARORA 3 LMantra Digital

Ao. IR 16 PAYAL ARORA @3 LMantra Digital Privacy and Citizenship Comparing Facebook cultures across low-income contexts in India and Brazil

INFORMAL SPACE AND FORMAL CITIZENSHIP Hyderabad slum Rio favela @3 LMantra

POVERTY, CHRONIC SURVEILLANCE & TECHNOLOGY 1. 2. 3. 4. Family surveillance Neighborhood surveillance Drug lords and mafia State @3 LMantra

WHY FACEBOOK? EMPOWERMENT OR WALLED GARDEN? @3 LMantra

SELECT FINDINGS I. Facebook’s Open culture & Speech politics II. Revenge Porn Cultures & Gender politics @3 LMantra

I. Facebook’s open culture & Speech politics Alternative public sphere • Many people will say that I'm a criminal…we go and knock on the door and they will slam the door on our faces. We won't be able to talk. But the social network is there and you say whatever you want - Rodrigues, Rio Privacy literacy “the Internet was the land of Marlboro, everybody would do whatever they wanted and that would be it, not now, now people know there's a limit. ” – Ketlina • “with Facebook when you post a picture you post where you are, with whom you are, with Whats. App I don't, if I want it, I can stay anonymous. ” – Meghana @3 LMantra

II. Revenge Porn Cultures & Gender politics Privacy and Gender Equality • • Sex and romance as key motivators and critical platforms for privacy India vs. Brazil Revenge porn as key motivator for policy reform Shiv Sena –Slut shaming and being corrupted by technologies Facebook as a loose Western morality “we don’t need that culture, we are Indians we have some standards. If I am an American I would have supported it. ”/ “if they want to kiss, why don’t they go to their home and kiss there” • Revenge porn: The 2013 case of Julia Rebecca @3 LMantra

Conclusion: global privacy cultures for global citizens? 1. Moving beyond the north-south divide and focus on the global poor as an essential context for privacy 2. Sexuality is a key context 3. Facebook culture = privacy culture? Twitter: 3 LMantra www. payalarora. com @3 LMantra