Accountability through Civilian Oversight CITIZEN COMPLAINT REPORT JANUARY

“Accountability through Civilian Oversight ”

CITIZEN COMPLAINT REPORT JANUARY 2018 Presented by Lawrence Akbar Interim Chief Investigator

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS RECEIVED YEAR-TO-DATE JANUARY 2018 vs 2017 100 85 80 74 60 40 20 0 CCRs Filed 2018 -20 CCRs Filed 2017 CCRs Filed 2018 vs 2017 Decrease 13% (11)

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED YEAR-TO-DATE JANUARY 2018 vs 2017 120 104 100 88 80 **CCRs Closed** 2017 **CCRs Closed** 2018 60 2016 2017 99 104 40 77 88 2018 Total 104 2017 Total 88 11 16 5 20 0 **CCRs Closed** 2018 **CCRs Closed** 2017 CCRs Closed 2018 vs 2017 Increase 18%

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS OPEN (Pending) YEAR-TO-DATE JANUARY 2018 vs 2017 250 200 193 171 150 CCRs Pending 2016 CCRs Pending 2017 100 2016 193 124 69 50 2017 171 97 74 2018 Total 193 2017 Total 171 22 0 Pending Complaints 2018 Pending Complaints 2017 Pending Complaints 2018 vs 2017 Increase 13%

UNIT RECEIVING CITIZEN COMPLAINTS 30 20 15 10 Walk In, 25, 34% Online, 3, 4% 1 1 12 P RE CI 30 25 23 24 21 20 15 OCI 10 Telephone(or TDD), 44, 59% 1 I 1 5 OC 1 4 T PD TH U M P M RE CH UN CI NC IE IC F O AT T IO F P NS OL O DO IC PE E W R NT AT O IO FO W NS RC N SE E IN RV VE IC ST ES I GA IN NE TE TI IG RN ON HB AL S OR A FF HO AI OD RS P OL IC IN G T 6 NC NC RE CI 11 TH TH P T 11 P CO Letter, 1, 1% 2 1 PD U T CI RE CI PR E TH 10 In-Custody, 1, 1% 3 NC T NC H CI 9 T PR E H CI NC T 1 8 T PR E H CI PR E H 5 NC 4 NC T NC CI PR E H 4 T PR E CI NC T D EC I 3 R T 2 0 2 N D PR 4 6 T 4 5 5 T CCRs 28 INTAKE 74 CITIZEN COMPLAINTS JANUARY 2018 25 5 0 OTHER 1 Telephone(or TDD) Walk In OCI 52% OTHER 48% OCI 4% OTHER 96%

P 3 R REC IN D PR CT 4 T EC IN H 5 T PR CT E H PR CIN EC CT 6 T IN C H PR T** EC 7 IN 7 T TH PR CT H PR EC EC IN 8 T INC CT H T P 9 T PR EC DU H PR IN C 10 ECIN T** 10 TH C TH PR T PD PR EC U EC IN IN CT * C 11 T P * TH DU * P 12 RE * C 12 TH IN TH PR CT PR EC EC IN CH IN CT C IE FS AU T P D CO NE T IG CHI O T U M E M H UN BO F O HEF IC RH F P T AT O O IO OD LIC E N L DO S O IAIS O M PE DO ES RA N W TIC TIO N N V GA TO IOL S NG WN EN IN SE CE R T M ELLI VICE AJ GE S NC NA OR RC VIO E** PO OTI LAT CS O L DI RS TR ICE PE VI A UN FFIC RSO SION KN EN NN OW FO EL N RCE ** CO M M EN M T AN D* * D 2 N 74 CCRs CITIZEN COMPLAINTS ALLEGED UNIT INVOLVED 78 ALLEGED UNITS INVOLVED 25 5 JANUARY 2018 10 8 5 3 1 4 3 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 23 20 15 8 3 1 1 1 1 1 2 0

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED OCI CCRs Closed - January, 2018 Findings Allegation Arrest Total Admin_ Closure Exonerated Not Sustained Unfounded 8 2 4 0 0 2 54 4 0 24 10 16 Entry 0 0 0 Force 12 0 1 1 3 7 4 1 0 2 0 1 62 15 9 16 9 13 Property 8 2 3 2 0 1 Search 5 0 1 2 0 2 Service 19 10 1 5 1 2 172 34 19 52 23 44 Demeanor Harassment Procedure Total (104 CCRs Closed)

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED INVESTIGATIONS DPD SCOUT CAR VIDEO/AUDIO EQUIPMENT 104 CCRs CLOSED JANUARY 2018 25 21 20 15 10 9 10 4 5 3 0 CCRs INVOLVED SCOUT CARS (20%) INCIDENT NOT CAPTURED (43%) NOT EQUIPPED/NOT OPERABLE (19%) CAPTURED INCIDENT NOT SUSTAINED (75%) (48%) OF NOT EQUIPPED/NOT OPERABLE

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED INVESTIGATIONS DPD BODY WORN CAMERAS 104 CCRs CLOSED JANUARY 2018 60 54 50 38 40 30 16 20 13 10 0 CCRs BWC INVOLVED (42%) INCIDENT NOT CAPTURED (30%) CAPTURED INCIDENT (70%) NOT SUSTAINED (81%) OF INCIDENT NOT CAPTURED

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED INVESTIGATIONS **126 DPD MEMBERS** IDENTIFIED IN 104 CCRs CLOSED JANUARY 2018 3000 2509 2500 2000 1884 1422 1500 DPD MEMBERS TOTALS CCRs MEMBERS INVOLVED 942 1000 625 500 105 21 53 67 145 6 126 0 MALE 6% FEMALE 3% WHITE 6% BLACK 5% OTHER 4% TOTALS 5%

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED INVESTIGATIONS JANUARY 2018 DPD MEMBERS SENIORITY AND RANK **104 CCRs Closed - 126 DPD Members Identified** RANK Civilian, 6 Corporal, 3 SENIORITY Detective, 3 Investigator, 2 <1 Year, 4 <2 Years, 35 30 -40 Years, 5 20 -29 Years, 20 Sergeant, 16 Police Officer, 93 Lieutenant, 3 Rank & Seniority 16 Police Officers w/+2 CCRs 1 3 4 3 2 20 -29 YEARS 3 -4 YEARS 3 10 -19 YEARS <2 YRS 5 -9 YEARS <1 YRS 3 -4 Years, 15 5 -9 Years, 13 10 -19 Years, 34

CITIZEN COMPLAINTS CLOSED INVESTIGATIONS UNKNOWN MEMBERS/UNIT IDENTIFIED 40 of 104 CCRs Closed Involved Unknown Members/Unit 35 32 30 25 20 15 8 10 5 1 0 CCRs Identified (80%) CCRs Unidentified (20%) CCRs Unidentified (1/8 IA)

9 TH PRECINCT 2017 CCR INTAKE 1127 1200 1000 800 579 600 409 400 200 7 2 29 13 75 15 5 24 31 0 Email In-Custody (<1%) Letter Online Outside agency Telephone(or TDD) (<1%) 9 TH PRECINCT Total Walk In (2%) Total (3%)

9 TH PRECINCT 2017 4500 4208 ALLEGATIONS 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1407 1500 1139 1000 500 674 195 20 5 125 61 10 2 56 17 278 11 179 63 3 5 181 7 169 24 7 0 Total Arrest 4% Allegations 5% Demeanor 6% Entry 4% Force 6% 9 TH PRECINCT Harassment Procedure Property 3% Search 4% 6% 5% 9 TH PRECINCT PDU TOTAL Service 5%

OCI Findings �EXONERATED �Where the preponderance of the evidence shows that the alleged conduct did occur but did not violate Detroit Police Department policies, procedures or training. �UNFOUNDED �Where the investigation revealed no facts to support that the incident complained of actually occurred. �SUSTAINED �Where the preponderance of the evidence shows that the alleged conduct did occur and the actions of the officer(s) violated Detroit Police Department policies, procedures or training. �NOT SUSTAINED �Where there are insufficient facts to decide whether the alleged misconduct occurred.

9 TH PRECINCT 2017 FINDINGS 4500 4208 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1506 1500 947 1000 500 614 195 20 23 3 14 336 72 10 45 7 13 280 422 23 5 103 0 Total Findings 5% Admin_ Closure 4% Exonerated 4% No Charge 5% Not Sustained 5% Unfounded 5% 5% 9 TH PRECINCT PDU TOTAL Void 5%

9 TH PRECINCT 2017 73 CITIZENS FILED CCRs AVERAGE 40 50 45 45 41 45 40 34 35 30 28 26 25 20 15 10 4 5 2 0 Black F/M Other F/M Female Total = 73 Citizens Male Average Age F/M = 40

“Accountability through Civilian Oversight ”